ERIE, Pa. — Sometimes in some places of Erie County, the phrase “elbow to elbow” does not accurately describe the combat fishing conditions created during epidemics of steelhead fever.

Sometimes, they get even closer.

When big fish are visible, the worst among us — selfish, rude and competitive — may intentionally cast over lines or deliberately step in front of anglers who are getting hits. Who wants to fish around jerks like that?

Well, you don’t have to. Let the meat-hungry hordes have the battlegrounds north of Rte. 5. Significant numbers of steelhead swim under the Rte. 20 bridges and beyond, and can be caught in peace in accessible waters.

Advertise with us

Psst. Don’t tell the lunkheads.

“That’s definitely what we do as the season progresses. We follow the fish rather far up the creeks,” said steelhead guide John Stanton, who held a clinic on steelhead fishing basics last week at International Angler fly shop in Robinson.

Steelhead don’t run for fun. Whiffs of their home stream’s particular chemical signature trigger in mature steelhead an irresistible urge to get upstream and attempt to spawn. Waterfalls and other natural impediments may limit or block their passage. Within the narrow 75-mile Pennsylvania panhandle, they face another impediment — a wall of anglers generally scrunched between the lake and Rte. 5, who legally harvest a disproportionate percentage of their catch.

Chuck Murray, the fisheries biologist who runs the state Fish and Boat Commission’s steelhead program, is quick to point out that with a license and Lake Erie permit, anglers are entitled to harvest legal catches. Great effort is made, he said, to manage the fishery in ways that accommodate harvest estimates. But the same management perspective takes into consideration the varying values of various angler cultures.

A 2003 tributary-specific creel analysis charted catch-per-effort and catch-and-harvest data on Pennsylvania’s steelhead tributaries. The survey found substantially increased interest in catch and release south of Rte. 5, where fewer anglers fish, and later in the season, when fewer anglers are on the water.

Advertise with us

“This is important because it shows us where the fish are likely to be harvested,” said Murray. “It was in 2003 — the fishing has changed some since then — but this gives us an idea of where can expect catch-and-release to take some pressure off the the stream.”

No surprise that Pennsylvania’s highest collective steelhead harvest rates occur near the Walnut Creek Access Area, built by Fish and Boat to give anglers optimum accessibility to the steelhead fishery. The creel survey shows that of 62,103 steelhead caught from the mouth to Manchester Road, 19,981 were kept at a harvest rate of 32 percent. Harvests were also high at the Manchester Pool area (59,317 caught, 11,990 harvested, 20 percent harvest rate) and under Rte. 5 (1,521 caught, 645 harvested,42 percent harvest rate).

Since the 2003 survey, the landowner at the Manchester Pool posted his property citing litter and trespassing through his front and back yards -- his dog got a hook in its paw while playing near the house.

“Guys that want to take fish home want to congregate at Walnut Creek,” said Murray. “About one-third of the steelhead caught at the Walnut Creek Access are harvested. Also, it accounted for 25 percent of all of the steelhead harvested in the 23 sites we surveyed. High harvest in this area is likely impacting the amount of steelhead that make it upstream..”

Waterfalls and walls of anglers, however, do not prevent fish from making it farther south on Walnut.

Advertise with us

“When the flow is good, steelhead have little problem making it up over the falls,” said Stanton. “When they get past the Manchester Pool, there’s almost no one fishing south of Rte. 5.”

Elk Creek gets heavy pressure and high harvests where access is easiest: 21 percent harvest at Legion Park, 29 percent at the Rick Road bridge. At a rare southern access point, the I-79 crossing, the harvest is 36 percent of the catch.

More typically south of I-90, the harvest rate at Folly’s End campground was just 12 percent, despite excellent access. No surprise that it’s mostly the catch-and-release crew who made the long walk to Streuchen Flats, where the steelhead harvest was just 9 percent of all fish caught.

“Once you walk up into the Flats, there are a couple of long pools and you can get away from the crowds,” said Stanton. “Most guys don’t want to go too far from the car. And between Sterrettania and McKean there are some good places that get little pressure.”

Stanton sometimes takes clients beyond I-79 to McKean, where parking is tight and some land is posted. But no one has told the steelhead.

Advertise with us

“When you get that far upstream, the smaller water is trout stream size,” he said. “I’ve heard of guys going up some even smaller tributaries. The fish are in shallow narrow water with trees and rocks. It’s a greater challenge. It’s a crapshoot.”

The new fish ladders and increased smolt stocking at Fourmile are working, said Murray, with steelhead passing Rte. 5 and Rte. 20, moving all the way to the Penn State property north of I-90.

Just 11 percent of caught steelhead were harvested at tiny Sevenmile Creek, where the Glinodo Center Benedictine Sisters’ walk-in-only access promotes catch-and-release values.

When steelhead make it to waters south of Rte. 20, they’re less likely to meet up with anglers. When anglers make it to those waters, they’re more likely to meet up with No Trespassing signs.

“Don’t go where they don’t want you,” said Murray. “There’s a reason they post — litter, invasion of privacy, poor parking choices. Push them, ignore the signs, and we’ll find even fewer places to fish.”