On the line, smallmouths keep you guessing. They can dig deep to wrap around wood or stone, or explode through the surface to shake off the hook. In rivers, smallmouths use their broad bodies to plane against the current, testing the best vectors for escape.
Add to all that the challenge and intimacy of fly fishing — the physics of rod loading and line control, the absence of apparatus separating fish and angler, the better odds for the bass.
“I enjoy catching trout — no doubt about it — but my favorite fishing is smallmouths with a fly rod,” said Bob Heil Jr., of Sewickley.
Last week, while regional rivers ran high and muddy, the avid fisherman and member of Trout Unlimited and Allegheny Fly Tyers spoke at a free meeting at International Angler in Robinson about gearing up for, and locating and catching, western Pennsylvania’s most abundant aquatic game species on a fly rod.
“Why use a fly rod for bass instead of a spinning or casting rod? That’s easy,” said Heil. “There’s nothing else like it around here. It can be challenging — just getting to the right position to cast can be hard — but the rewards are great when you get a nice fish on the line.”
Heil fills his fly box with homemade poppers and other bass bugs and Clouser-style streamers, which were developed for Pennsylvania smallmouths. He fishes rivers and big creeks throughout Southwest Pennsylvania, but says he’s most at home on the Youghiogheny River, far below the whitewater rapids, down in the calmer waters from Smithton, Westmoreland County, to the mouth at McKeesport.
Read More
“I do mostly all wading from shore,” he said. “Finding access is the hardest part … but the Youghiogheny River Trail is there the whole way and gets you into good places that don’t get fished that often. Sometimes it’s deep right off the bank. You have to be careful.”
With some 30 days of unseasonable rain in the past six weeks, he said, water conditions for fish and anglers are “just terrible.”
“When the flow is 3,000 to 6,000 cubic feet per second, you can’t even wade that water — it’ll knock you off your feet — and I would feel unsafe being in a canoe.”
Internet posting of the U.S. Geological Survey gauge at Sutersville is a valuable point of reference.
“It’s hard for fish to breath when it gets too silty, and when the flow gets too high during spawning season, the eggs don’t stay there. They get washed away from the redds,” he said.
Despite the high flow, Heil has released several nice smallmouths in recent days.
“It’s fishable as long as you can safely wade into the muddy water and cast back to the cleaner bank water,” he said. “Sometimes you can do it from shore if you can get a good drift.”
Forage fish hug the banks to avoid high flow and silt, and the bass follow them into those slower, clearer waters. Heil prefers crayfish and hellgrammite patterns and large stonefly nymphs, but sometimes the smallmouths prefer size-specific hair or cork bass bugs.
“The nice thing about bass fishing, especially smallmouths in rivers and creeks — they’re not real picky,” he said. “The fly doesn’t have to be perfect, it just has to suggest what they’re eating. And they’re not steelhead or trout — if you’re in the bass’ ZIP code and the water temperature is warm enough that they’re active, that bass is going to hit that fly.”
Part of the challenge, he said, is getting the presentation down deep in front of the fish. On a fly rod. In a river current. Wading from shore.
“Whatever you can do to keep the fly in front of the fish for a long time, the better,” he said. “For streamers, I use a floating line with an intermediate sink-tip. My second line is a full sinking line, and I use some weighted flies and split shot.”
When Heil arrives at the river bank, the first thing he does, he said, is check the water temperature. That will determine the flies he’ll fish, the line he’ll choose and speed of the retrieve. Next he reads the water for seams, boils, eddies, structure and other clues to where the smallmouths are likely to be, and calculates where on the water he needs to be to get position relative to the fish.
“All that,” he said, “before stepping into the water.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.