The longest river on the American East Coast flows 464 miles to the Atlantic Ocean, and is one of the oldest rivers on Earth — older than the ancient mountain range it dissects. It drains 27,500 square miles, including nearly half of Pennsylvania.
But the Susquehanna River is sick. Last week two independent laboratory tests confirmed that a bulbous lump on the lip of an smallmouth bass, caught by an angler north of Harrisburg late last year, was a cancerous tumor. Those reports and a photo of the fish, shot by Arway, caught the attention of the state senate and made national news.
“I was actually on the boat when he caught it and was shocked by its appearance when we first saw it,” Fish and Boat executive director John Arway said Tuesday, during his annual report to the state Senate Game and Fisheries Committee, which focused in part on the Susquehanna’s sickness.
Arway said the unusual bass tumor is considered an anomaly. It’s the only case found in sampling of some 20,000 Susquehanna bass, and may be unrelated to well-documented long-term young-of-year smallmouth mortality, or the sores, lesions and melanoma spots found on bass and other fish. The river’s illness, Arway told the committee, has yet to be diagnosed.
The North Branch Susquehanna reaches into New York, the West Branch drains west to Indiana County and the main stem rolls through central Pennsylvania farmland and a few miles of Maryland before emptying into the Atlantic. Agricultural runoff, storm water discharges, algae blooms and pharmaceutical residue from treated sewage compound the impacts of mine drainage, sedimentation and other pollutants.
In 1997, the DEP declared the Susquehanna an American Heritage River, opening technical assistance from federal, state and local governments. In 2003, Chesapeake Bay research suggested the Susquehanna was responsible for 44 percent of the nitrogen, 21 percent of the phosphorus and 21 percent of the sediment pouring into the bay. In 2005, the environmental group American Rivers dubbed the Susquehanna “America’s Most Endangered River.”
But nearly 20 years after symptoms of the river’s sickness were first detected, and more than a decade since anglers and fishing guides started reporting a problem with smallmouths, a standoff of Pennsylvania agencies continues.
The Department of Environmental Protection needs additional data before granting the river “impaired” status. The Fish and Boat Commission says that designation is needed to release resources and build the political will necessary to cure the river’s sickness.
“More research? I could have gotten a bachelor’s degree and a masters and been working on a post-doc on this issue in that time. They’re still collecting data,” said Arway, in an interview Thursday. “My frustration is we’ve known about this for 10 years and still don’t know what the problem is.”
Jonathan Niles, director of the Freshwater Research Initiative at Susquehanna University in Northumberland County, said it’s not that simple.
“I think there’s not enough research going on,” he said. “It’s such a vast and complicated system it needs to be looked at from all angles.”
DEP and the federal Environmental Protection Agency agree that the non-native smallmouth is in decline on the middle Susquehanna and lower Juniata. But there’s not enough data, they say, to satisfy established protocols required to assess whether the problem is with the fish or the water.
By some standards, said Niles, the river is doing fine but the bass have a problem.
“If you look at the invertebrate data, the mayflies and caddisflies are doing very well. Other fish are doing basically OK,” he said. “If you look at smallmouths across their introduced range, they are also having problems in the Shenandoah River and the Tennessee River. It may be something with the species. The fact is, we just don’t know what’s going on in the Susquehanna.”
Niles said insufficient agency funding and general difficulties in pinpointing the cause of pollution that doesn’t come from a single source, contribute to the Susquehanna’s problems.
Some insiders have suggested the problem isn’t the research, it’s politics. Declaring that the river has been impaired by commercial interests could result in retaliatory lawsuits being filed against the state.
This year Fish and Boat, DEP, EPA and other agencies and experts are collaborating on a joint project intended diagnose Susquehanna’s sickness. Research will continue to September.
“The federal EPA has told the DEP that they have to come to a conclusion about whether the river is sick or not by January 2016,” said Arway. “We also understand that DEP will make a decision about whether the river should or should not be listed as an impaired water.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.