Even in a "trout state" like Pennsylvania, bass fishing is big. Pennsylvania's 400,000 bass anglers enjoy 5.5 million days on the water every year, an average of 14 bass fishing-days each according to U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service's 2006 National Survey of Fishing, Hunting and Wildlife-Associated Recreation, .

The most recent in a survey conducted at five-year intervals, the report doesn't specify how many of those days are devoted to largemouth bass or their closely related but distinctly different kin, the smallmouth.

How all that bass angling activity is divided is a fair question here because Pennsylvania -- specifically western Pennsylvania -- lies within the relatively small region where the original native ranges of both bass species overlap. Due to their popularity, both largemouth and smallmouth bass have since been stocked worldwide, but Pennsylvania's rivers and lakes still offer some of the best fishing for both species conveniently close together. Since the 1800s, smallmouth transplants have been particularly successful in eastern Pennsylvania rivers including the Delaware and Susquehanna.

From Friday

Advertise with us

Fishing Report: 6/12/10

"I don't know of any formal studies that have attempted to differentiate angling popularity of largemouth bass vs. smallmouth," said Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission warmwater biologist Bob Lorantas. "But fishing success for both species tends to be fairly consistent in Pennsylvania due to generally constant or improving water quality and to anglers who have embraced the catch-and-release ethic."

Lorantas said bass are available during those 5.5 million angler days with virtually no help from the state.

"Both smallmouth and largemouth fisheries in the state sustain themselves naturally. There is virtually no stocking to maintain bass fishing," he said. "Occasionally, [the PFBC] stocks bass fingerlings, but it is done only to re-populate reservoirs that have been drawn down or to introduce fisheries to streams where acid mine drainage remediation has improved the habitat."

The most striking differences between these two most popular freshwater bass are general coloration and habitat preference. Largemouth bass are generally greenish on the back and sides, blending to light green or white on the belly. A horizontal black bar, varyingly solid, spans the body at mid-depth.

Advertise with us

Yellowish or olive-brown dominates the back and head of the smallmouth, blending to yellowish-white undersides. Dark vertical bars, nine to 16 in number, parallel one another on the side of the body. The eyes of smallmouth bass are generally red.

Sometimes the characteristic colors and markings are indistinct. Largemouth and smallmouth bass can always be distinguished by the upper jaw. In largemouths the upper jaw always extends well beyond the eye. The upper jaw of smallmouth bass extends only to about the eye's midpoint.

Largemouth bass prefer the still water of lakes and ponds, especially where aquatic vegetation laces open water. Smallmouth are more at home in flowing streams and rivers with rocky bottoms, boulders and ledges. Largemouth bass seek out slightly warmer water than smallmouths. When other environmental factors are met, largemouths prefer water at 80-90 degrees. Smallmouths are more likely found in waters 78-88 degrees.

Scientists have documented other differences not clearly apparent to anglers. In laboratory tests, smallmouth bass showed a faster "learning curve" in avoiding threats such as nets and electric shock. Captive smallmouths also learned faster to bump a lever to release food. Largemouth bass are more tolerant of brackish habitats where rivers meet saltwater in estuaries, such as the upper Delaware Bay.

Biologists refer to both bass as "ambush predators," which dart out from cover to seize prey. Adults of both bass feed heavily on small fish but smallmouth often exploit a more diverse diet including large proportions of insects and crayfish. Both bass can locate potential prey by sensing acoustic vibrations through their inner ear and lateral line, a narrow, nerve-packed organ running the length of the body.

Advertise with us

"As predatory fishes they rely heavily on sight," Lorantas said. "However, we have collected fish with an eye missing and yet that fish seemed to be healthy, so it's clear that the ability to analyze vibration is part of their hunting strategy."

That explains why splashy or rattling lures are often effective bass catchers, for both largemouth and smallmouth.

Concern for the nationally famous smallmouth fishery in the Susquehanna River followed a die-off of juvenile smallmouth bass first noted in the summer of 2005. Lorantas said investigations point to various environmental "stressors" that cause periodic drops in dissolved oxygen in the river, especially near the shoreline. Young bass are most susceptible to the condition, he explained, because they spend much time in shallow water where they are less vulnerable to predation by larger fish. He said the stress factors are being continually monitored.

"However," Lorantas said, "the year classes of young bass produced after that in 2006 and 2007 did show reasonable survival, and we are seeing those fish in the recreational fishery now."