Meriwether McCargo had previously felt the pressure of playing in a WPIAL singles final.

Three times before, in fact.

Yet the top-seeded Shady Side Academy senior knew this time being in the championship match, with a potential career sweep on her racquet, was a lot different than her previous appearances.

“Every single year has been hard for me and so nerve-wracking,” McCargo said. “But this year, I felt the pressure was extra on me this year because, if I didn’t win, then I would be one match away from being the first person ever, so it definitely made it more scary for me.”

Advertise with us

It didn’t help that her opponent, No. 2 seeded Bethel Park senior Cami Fisher, was playing on her home court, took the first set and broke her in the first game of the second. But that was the moment she showed why she had won the last three years and will head to the University of Chicago next season.

McCargo pulled off an amazing comeback as she rallied and came away with a thrilling 4-6, 6-1, 6-1 victory against Fisher to win the WPIAL Class 3A singles title Thursday afternoon at Bethel Park.

With the win, McCargo is now the only second player to win a WPIAL singles title all four years and the first to do so in the highest classification. She joined Knoch alumna Laura Greb, who swept Class 2A from 2017-2020.

“It feels amazing,” McCargo said. “I’ve put in so much hard work over the years and I sacrificed a lot from my high school experience to play tennis and I feel like it’s definitely paid off. It just makes me happy to be able to show it in this way.”

Fisher and McCargo had played during the regular season and the team playoffs on several occasions, but this was the first time they met in the singles tournament since their freshman year in 2023 when Fisher gave her all she could handle before McCargo escaped with a 10-8 win in a quarterfinal pro-set format match

Advertise with us

McCargo also won their most recent meeting earlier this season when Shady Side Academy and Bethel Park met in a non-section match. But this time the Black Hawks’ No. 1 singles player thought she had enough to pull off the upset.

“I think that she started playing more consistent and I was playing impatient because I was trying to end points a little early,” Fisher said. “I liked how aggressive I was being. I was swinging and I wasn’t just letting her run me around. I think I could have stayed in the points longer and waited for a better opportunity.”

McCargo is no stranger to three-set finals. Each of the last two years she was taken to a third set by Penn-Trafford grad Amelia Williams, including on the same court in 2024.

In each of those matches, however, McCargo won the first set. This was the first time in her four finals that she failed to win the opening set in the championship match.

“In the first set I was being impatient. I wasn’t really playing my game and I was being too aggressive,” McCargo said. “Then I remembered what I do best is staying consistent and waiting for the right time to be aggressive, which is what I did.”

Advertise with us

While McCargo celebrated winning her fourth consecutive title, Mollie Sclichter broke new ground. The third-seeded Oakland Catholic senior rolled over Class 2A No. 1 Avery Allan of Quaker Valley, 6-1, 6-1, and became the first Eagles tennis player ever to win a WPIAL singles title.

“I honestly don’t believe it,” Sclichter said. “I have imposter syndrome. A lot of times I feel like I can’t do it and I’m not good enough, but I worked so hard for this. I’ve been training year-round and this is what I’ve been training for and it’s so worth it.”

Allan also played in the final last year at North Allegheny where she lost to three-time champion Gabriella Dusi of Belle Vernon, 6-1, 4-6, 6-4. To reach that final, Allan defeated Sclichter, 6-2, 6-3, in the semifinals.

“She was just a wall. All props to her, she played amazing,” Allan said. “She made every shot. She just played awesome.”