UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Once the rain subsided and the tarp was rolled off of Medlar Field at Lubrano Park, a nearly three-hour delay finally reaching its conclusion, the sky was blotched with a pinkish hue.
Neither Butler nor Neshaminy had ever been here, playing for a state championship.
Senior Nolan Stefaniak — a flamethrowing right-handed Penn State signee — took the very mound he’s slated to be playing on collegiately for the Nittany Lions next spring.
It had been a historic season for Butler (23-4), which won the program’s first WPIAL Class 6A championship late last month, but it couldn’t add another magical chapter. District 1’s Neshaminy (21-7) unleashed a four-run fifth inning as Butler lost, 7-3, Thursday evening in the Class 6A state title.
“It stings, obviously, but I’m still super proud,” Butler coach Josh Forbes said. “I’m gonna carry my head up high because we accomplished a lot of things that nobody else in Butler history has done.”
Neshaminy opened the scoring with an RBI groundout in the bottom of the first inning, but Butler responded in the second after drawing four consecutive walks.
Though Neshaminy starter Chase Bonner appeared to lose his command, it was only a blip in an otherwise dominant outing. The senior righty went 4⅓ innings without allowing a hit and struck out eight in 95 pitches.
“He dialed in,” said Neshaminy coach Dan Toner.
With Butler’s bats struggling to find answers for Bonner, the Golden Tornado relied heavily on Stefaniak. He was sharp early on — with his fastball reaching 97 mph — and wiggled out of multiple jams through the first four innings.
“It’s nothing new to us,” Toner said of facing high-speed pitching. “No matter what the velo is, who the pitcher is, our guys know that they can get barrels to it. One of the big things that’s a part of our team is we hit velo — and we always have.”
Then, in the fifth, Neshaminy broke the game wide open.
Michael Welsh led off the inning with a single and moved to second after a throwing error, which marked one of five errors for Butler in the game. Neshaminy hit two more singles and a double off Stefaniak to take a 5-3 lead heading into the sixth.
Stefaniak — who entered Thursday with an 8-1 record and a 0.52 ERA across 53⅔ innings — threw 104 pitches and gave up seven runs, four of which were earned.
The state final marked just the second time since April 30 that Butler surrendered more than three runs in a game.
“He threw in a lot of stressful innings, and he battled his butt off,” Forbes said. “He was really good for us tonight once again. It’s just unfortunate that we didn’t play defense behind him to really seal the deal for him.”
Butler broke up the no-hit bid in the sixth inning after Stefaniak led off with a double, and the Golden Tornado tacked on a run when Ryan Rattigan slapped an RBI single. Mavrik Clement hit an RBI single in the seventh, but Butler couldn’t add on any further.
Butler batted 4 for 24 (.167) overall compared to Neshaminy’s 8 for 24 (.333). Junior outfielder Daniel Marable led Neshaminy at the plate with a 2-for-3 performance and two RBIs.
“Probably didn’t pick the best time to play our worst baseball game of the year,” Forbes said. “ ... You just got to tip your cap. They ground it out and they won gold.”
There are a considerable number of seniors departing from this Butler team, including Stefaniak, Casteel, Clement (Pitt recruit) and shortstop Boden Lenyk, among others. Before the game, Forbes said he told his players to “look up and smile.”
Prior to this season, Butler had only played in three state playoff games — all of which came in 1992.
So, even with the sour ending to a historic season, Forbes maintained a strong sense of pride.
Seeing the Butler community cheering and youth players reaching over the railings to ask for signed balls and pictures from the Golden Tornado made the experience all the more special.
“It’s awesome because we’re getting the youth involved, and that’s really how you start building programs,” Forbes said. “You get your youth traveling out, cheering on these guys and really wanting to emulate what these guys are doing on the field.
“Hopefully there’s more of these down the road in the near future.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.