When the Indiana baseball team made it to a state championship game for the first time two years ago, coach Dan Petroff had his team arrive three hours before game time. Petroff told his players to walk around the stadium, take in the sights and sounds and cherish the atmosphere.

“I wanted them to take it all in,” Petroff said, “because you don’t know if you ever will get back there again.”

But Indiana did get back again. And again.

Now Indiana has a chance to put itself in a most elite class of WPIAL teams. The record book has a page reserved for Indiana, and the Little Indians have a pen in their hands, with a chance to author their own chapter.

Advertise with us

Indiana has made it to the PIAA Class 4A title game for the third year in a row. Only four other teams in Pennsylvania history have made three consecutive trips to PIAA title games.

But what could really make this Indiana team special is a win against Holy Ghost Prep (15-10) in Thursday’s title game at Penn State’s Medlar Field at Lubrano Park. That would make Indiana (21-4) one of only five teams from the WPIAL to ever win back-to-back PIAA titles.

This from an Indiana program that had played in a grand total of three PIAA playoff games before Petroff took over in 2024. Petroff, 51, is a former Punxsutawney player and has done a masterful job with the Little Indians.

“I didn’t take over an empty program,” Petroff said. “We had some talent. But to say we’d be in the state championship game three times in a row, I wouldn’t say I thought about that. I’ve talked to a lot of coaches who say they would’ve loved to play in one. To play in three means you have a good cycle of players. We didn’t invent anything new with baseball or do anything different.”

Indiana lost to Holy Ghost Prep in the 2024 PIAA championship after losing in the WPIAL championship, too. Last year, Indiana won both WPIAL and PIAA titles. This year, the Little Indians won their second WPIAL title in a row and had a historic streak of five scoreless postseason games.

Advertise with us

Only two teams in WPIAL history went five postseason games without allowing a run.

“The first year we got to the state championship, I’m not saying it was easy, but that was the easiest one to get there,” Petroff said. “The last two have been extremely difficult because you’re getting everyone’s best punch no matter who you play. This year’s squad on paper may not have been as strong as the other two. But the heart, the will and the soul of these kids is the best we’ve had.”

Indiana will face a Holy Ghost Prep team that beat Indiana 6-5 two years ago and lost to Montour in the 2022 final. Located in Bensalem, a suburb of Philadelphia, Holy Ghost Prep is an all-boys school. It has allowed only three runs in three PIAA games.

Holy Ghost Prep is a senior-laden team. In a 4-1 semifinal win against Montoursville, pitcher Bam McNab, a Wagner recruit, pitched a complete game four-hitter. Eddie Rosado, a Saint Joseph’s recruit, hit two home runs.

Indiana will start Brady Oakes, a senior left-hander who threw a no-hitter in last Thursday’s quarterfinals. If Indiana wins, it will join Moon (2001-02), Riverside (2005-06), Riverside again (2011-12) and Bethel Park (2021-22) as the only WPIAL teams to win back-to-back state titles since the PIAA playoffs started in 1977.

Advertise with us

Indiana is one of four WPIAL teams to make the PIAA finals this year at Penn State. Here is a look at the three other games involving WPIAL teams:

Butler pitcher Nolan Stefaniak will take an 8-1 record into Thursday's Class 6A title game against Neshaminy. (Matt Freed / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Class 6A

Butler (23-3) plays Neshaminy (20-7) in what is a championships of firsts. Both teams are playing in a PIAA title game for the first time in school history.

Butler has two standout senior pitchers in Nolan Stefaniak and Kyle Casteel. Stefaniak will start against Neshaminy after Casteel pitched a complete game in the semifinals against Owen J. Roberts. Under PIAA pitching rules, Casteel, at West Virginia recruit who is 10-0, is ineligible to pitch against Neshaminy.

Stefaniak, a Penn State recruit, is 8-1 and has allowed only four earned runs and 21 hits in 53 2/3 innings. He has struck out 80.

Butler has won five postseason games by one or two runs, and this one could be close, as well.

Advertise with us

Neshaminy has had some close games in the PIAA playoffs, winning by scores of 4-2, 3-0 and 2-1. In a 2-1 win against Pennsbury in Monday’s semifinals, Neshaminy had only two hits against Pennsbury ace Keller Bradley, a Vanderbilt recruit who is considered one of Pennsylvania’s top prospects for the July MLB Draft.

Matthew Gryn (8-1) pitched the distance against Pennsbury, and Neshaminy will likely pitch senior Chase Bonner against Butler. Bonner is 7-1 with a 2.59 ERA.

Class 3A

WPIAL runner-up South Park (18-6) has made it to a final game for only the second time. (The other was in 2017.)

On Friday at 1:30 p.m., the Eagles will face a Bermudian Springs team that is 22-3 and also making only its second championship appearance.

Both teams threw their ace pitchers in the semifinals. South Park’s Cooper Hochendoner threw a one-hitter against Fairview, while Bermudian Springs’ Branson Diller pitched his seventh complete game of the season and beat Mifflinburg. Diller is undefeated over the past two years and has a 22-1 career record.

Advertise with us

One thing is for certain: The Eagles will soar in this game. (Both teams are nicknamed the Eagles.)

Class 1A

Eden Christian joins Indiana in making a third consecutive appearance in a PIAA title game.

The only other two schools in Pennsylvania to make a state championship game three years in a row are Serra Catholic (2009-11) and Neumann-Goretti (2015-17). It is a little easier to make a state championship these days with six classifications. From 1977-1998, the PIAA had only two baseball classes and three from 1999-2004.

Still, making it three years in a row is an achievement. Eden Christian just hopes the third time is the charm. Eden Christian (19-4) lost in the title game in each of the past two seasons. Eden will face Dock Mennonite (11-14) for the title this time on Friday at 10:30 a.m.

Dock Mennonite used to be Christopher Dock, and Christopher Dock is the opposite of Eden Christian — meaning it is 3-0 in title games.

Advertise with us

Eden Christian will use ace pitcher Noah Emswiler. In his past two starts, in the WPIAL final and the PIAA quarterfinals, Emswiler has allowed only 11 hits and struck out 22.

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and @mwhiteburgh on X.