Ever since girls wrestling became officially sanctioned by the PIAA in 2023, a handful of local grapplers have made headlines, proving that Western Pennsylvania remains one of the premier hotbeds in the nation for producing top-notch talent.
That being said, the WPIAL has yet to witness a pair of girls wrestling prodigies quite like Mt. Lebanon’s Isla Silva and Camilla Hathaway.
But don’t just take one of their own coaches’ word for it — ask North Allegheny girls wrestling coach Dan Heckert, who played an instrumental role in helping the sport become sanctioned by the PIAA and has won numerous awards in recent years.
“For freshmen, they’re in another universe,” Heckert said.
Each only 14 years old, Silva and Hathaway are childhood best friends who have spent roughly half their lives dazzling crowds with their incredible displays of dominance on the mat. Both have already represented Team USA and brought home gold on the international stage. Now, Silva and Hathaway have finally arrived in the WPIAL — and this is only the beginning of their journey together to wrestling stardom.
But while both are making an immediate splash in their varsity debuts, that’s pretty much where the similarities end for these two phenoms.
Read More
Standing barely 5 feet tall with a compact 112-pound frame, you probably wouldn’t consider the blonde-haired Silva much of a threat if you happened to cross paths with her in the middle of the street. Her playful smile and shy, unassuming demeanor belies her fierce-yet-graceful nature on the mat. Once the whistle blows, she transforms into an entirely different beast — and she has a gold medal from the 2024 U15 Pan-American Games in El Salvador to prove it.
“Obviously, Isla and Camilla have been in very high-pressure situations,” said Mt. Lebanon girls wrestling coach Amanda Lebec. “I’ve known them probably since they were in first and second grade. They’ve always been hammers. But I think what’s so interesting about both of the girls is, as long as they’ve been in the practice room, they’ve always been such hard workers.”
Say hello to one of the future stars of girls wrestling in Western PA and beyond — Mt. Lebanon freshman and 2024 U15 Pan Am Games champ Isla Silva.
— Steve Rotstein (@SteveRotstein) January 11, 2026
A runner-up at the Ironman and Beast of the East tournaments, Silva won the 112-pound title at the Blue Devil Girls Winter Classic: pic.twitter.com/4tCmuBQ51O
While Silva is known for her slick, smooth style on her feet that is almost like poetry in motion, Hathaway prefers to pulverize her opponents from start to finish. From the moment the match begins, she simply bulldozes her helplessly overmatched opponent to the floor, locks them up in one of her trademark pinning combinations — preferably an armbar — and sticks them to their back until the referee slaps the mat.
“I think I’ve known her since I was 6,” Hathaway said about Silva. “We just got super close. And we trained together all the time, and I think that’s really helped us. … It’s great. She’s my best friend, and we get to go through everything together.”
So, where did Silva’s cat-like quickness and passion for sports come from? Well, her father, former Indianapolis Colts safety Jamie Silva, may have had something to do with it. Jamie played two seasons for the Colts before a knee injury in 2009 ended his career.
“There was a wrestling camp going on, and they weren’t sure if I was into the tackling [in football], so my mom signed me up, and I really loved it,” Silva said.
Of course, while she got her genetic gifts from her parents, Silva credits much of her development to Mt. Lebanon assistant wrestling coach Matt Kocher, a former NCAA All-American in 2007 who won 151 matches during his decorated career at Pitt. Kocher now runs the South Hills Wrestling Academy, where Silva, Hathaway and several other girls on the Blue Devils’ team also train to gain an edge on the competition.
Despite having active wrestlers in only seven of 13 weight classes, Mt. Lebanon is currently ranked No. 2 in the Post-Gazette girls wrestling rankings, and each of their girls are ranked in the top five in their weight class — including four girls ranked No. 1. The other top-ranked girls besides Silva and Hathaway are Carly Jox at 106 pounds and Paige Jox at 148 pounds.
“At Ironman, we got fifth place. At Beast, we got fourth place. At Powerade, we got third. So it’s just a testament to all of them and how they make each other better in the training room,” Lebec said. “We have a pretty fun practice room. We have small numbers, but everybody in the room has four-plus years of experience, so they know how to work, how to wrestle, how to drill, how to experience tough practices, how to keep pushing through, and that is so valuable.”
Both Silva (16-2) and Hathaway (23-2) have only tasted defeat twice so far this year, with both losses coming against two of the top-ranked girls in all the land.
Silva, ranked No. 6 in the country at 110 pounds in the latest Sports Illustrated rankings, fell to No. 1 Kayla Batres of Green Farms Academy, Conn., in a razor-close 4-3 decision in the finals of the Ironman tournament on Dec. 14. Less than a week later, she lost to No. 4 Julia Horger of Conwell-Egan by an 18-9 major decision in the finals of the Beast of the East tournament.
Silva nearly pinned Horger earlier in the bout, then Horger took her to her back for an eight-point swing in the third period to decide the match. Horger, a senior, is a two-time defending PIAA champion with a career record of 88-2.
“That was the second time they had met up, and Isla beat her before in freestyle,” Lebec said. “I was really excited about how our season schedule panned out. Such a gauntlet.”
At 155 pounds, Hathaway finds herself ranked No. 13 in the nation, where her only losses to date have come against No. 1 Ella Poalillo of High Point Regional, N.J., and against Wyoming Seminary’s Ciyanna Okocha, who is ranked No. 3 at 170.
After her third-place finish at Ironman and second-place finish at Beast of the East, Hathaway dominated her way through the bracket at her first Powerade tournament last month, pinning reigning WPIAL champion Karsyn Champion of Norwin for the second time this season before flattening No. 15 Sawyer Ward of Science Hill, Tenn., with her signature armbar in just 2:33 to claim the crown.
“I feel like that has been my favorite move, I would say, for years,” Hathaway said. “I really feel confident in it.”
Although Silva had to settle for second place at both Ironman and Beast of the East and was unable to make it to Powerade, she finally took home her first major varsity tournament title last weekend — and she did it in her home gym, helping Mt. Lebanon secure the team title in the process while hosting its third annual Blue Devil Girls Winter Classic.
More than 200 competitors from 32 teams packed the house for the event, which has turned into one of the premier showcases for girls wrestling in the state. Each of Silva’s first 15 wins this season came via fall or technical fall, but she went the distance against Connellsville’s Trinity Moore in the finals, winning a 7-3 decision.
“It was a bit nerve-wracking,” Silva said afterward. “I wish I dominated the match a bit more, but this tournament is amazing.”
Hathaway was as spectacular as ever, scoring two technical falls before steamrolling Clearfield’s Makayla Taylor with a 54-second pin in the finals. She now has 17 pins and four technical falls this season with just one win by decision. That came in a 4-1 win against reigning PIAA champion Juliet Alt of Chestnut Ridge in the Beast of the East semifinals.
What an absolute powerhouse.
— Steve Rotstein (@SteveRotstein) January 11, 2026
Mt. Lebanon’s other nationally acclaimed freshman, Powerade champ Camilla Hathaway, needed less than a minute to secure a pin with this wicked armbar in the 155-pound finals. This is quickly becoming Hathaway’s signature move: pic.twitter.com/GXnRtk845c
And to think, she’s doing all of this at 155 pounds, all while planning on dropping down two weight classes to 142 pounds for postseason competition.
“They’re competing against these girls who have been competing for so much longer and they’re so much older,” Lebec said. “We started with Ironman and then we went on to Beast and then Powerade, and every tournament, she’s improving on her placement. And she’s just getting after it. Camilla will compete against anyone who will put her toe on the line.”
Now, with the postseason on the horizon, Mt. Lebanon is getting set to host both the WPIAL girls championships on Feb. 21 and PIAA girls West Regional championships on Feb. 28. That means Silva and Hathaway will have two more opportunities to shine in front of their home fans while introducing themselves to the rest of the wrestling world.
And how fitting it is that they’re doing it in the same blue-and-gold singlet worn by the only Olympic wrestling champion the WPIAL has ever produced — the one and only Kurt Angle.
“I think it’s awesome,” Hathaway said. “That’s definitely our goal. I think it’s really cool. We’ve definitely been looking forward to it.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.