Rematches don’t come along very often in the state softball playoffs.
But when they do, it certainly ramps up the intensity.
And there will no doubt be a lot of emotions for Union (20-2) when it takes the field at 2 p.m. Thursday at Slippery Rock University against District 9 champion DuBois Central Catholic (12-10) in the state quarterfinals.
It’s not just that the Cardinals are the reigning PIAA Class 1A champions. It’s that they went through the Scotties to get there.
A year ago, DuBois Central Catholic shut down the Union offense behind a dominant performance from pitcher Rylee Kulbatsky — now a junior and another in a line of recent Western Pennsylvania players who has committed to Kent State — and took home a 6-1 victory at Heindl Memorial Field in the Cardinals’ backyard. This time, though, Union is hoping to turn the tables.
“We didn’t hit. We hit, we win. It’s the same concept this year,” Union coach Doug Fisher said. “[Kulbatsky has] a couple different locations on her riseball, and we were biting on that a little too much. If we can stay away from that high ball, I think we’ll be OK.”
Read More
DuBois Central Catholic is getting used to PIAA playoff rematches.
Last year, the Cardinals exacted a measure of revenge when they defeated Carmichaels 2-0 in the PIAA Class 1A championship game at Penn State University’s Beard Field. A year prior, the Mikes knocked them out in the first round of the tournament in a 7-0 blowout.
Because of how the PIAA designed its brackets for 2023 and 2024, along with a glut of the smaller schools that are in the western half of the state, the WPIAL runner-up had to play out of the eastern side of the bracket in those two years. That is how Union ended up playing against the Cardinals, as the District 9 champion was placed on that side, as well.
Now, with both in the western half and with the WPIAL champion slated to play the District 9 champion much earlier, Union is hoping turnabout is fair play and it can do to DuBois Central Catholic what the Cardinals did to Carmichaels.
“It’s kind of a revenge factor, but it’s also kind of — do you really want to see them again?” Fisher said. “I know they don’t have the same team and there’s a lot of new ones on there, so I figure if we can get on base, we can win.”
Union may not have won a state title, but this current group of seniors has been to the big game, where it lost to Tri Valley 6-3 in 2023. The Scotties also have a lineup that has belted nearly 50 homers this season, led by sophomore Irelyn Fisher with 13, and senior pitcher Mia Preuhs tossed a no-hitter at Carmichaels in the WPIAL final.
“It means a lot more this year because it’s her last year,” Fisher said of Preuhs. “She’s a little more dialed in. She’s been there before. It’s not like she’s starstruck.”
No pressure at all
West Allegheny might not have been seen as a threat for a state title after finishing third in the WPIAL playoffs.
But after the dust settled in the first round of the PIAA Class 5A tournament, the Indians are still alive and geared up for their first quarterfinals game since they made it all the way to the state final in 2018.
“I feel like this is one of the more laid-back, go-with-the-flow groups of kids I’ve coached in a while,” West Allegheny coach Mindi McFate said. “They’re just taking it like [Thursday] is just another softball game.”
Looking at the bracket, it may appear West Allegheny (16-5) would have a slight edge, as it will be taking on the fourth-place finisher out of District 3. But Twin Valley (21-5) put up four runs against Shaler junior pitcher and Indiana University recruit Bria Bosiljevac in a 4-3 extra-innings win on the Titans’ home field, so the Indians will have to be wary when they take the field against the Raiders at 2 p.m. Thursday at Everett High School.
“It’s really a great attitude to have,” McFate said. “It’s working for us, so we’re going to go with it.”
Speaking of Everett
It was two years ago when Neshannock went into the state playoffs riding a long winning streak, blew past Sharpsville in the tournament, then was upset by a team from District 5.
This isn’t 2023, and Chestnut Ridge (16-6) certainly isn’t the Everett team that ended up winning a state title, but the Lancers (23-0) have to be wary their path to a third state title in four years doesn’t end at 11 a.m. Thursday at Norwin.
Neshannock is coming off of a 10-0, five-inning victory against Sharpsville, the old stomping ground of Lancers senior pitcher Addyson Frye.
Winner take ... a ride home
Being a WPIAL champion is no guarantee of success in the state playoffs, and this year is proving that out.
Of the six schools that were the top seeds in their classifications after winning championships at PennWest California’s Lilley Field last week, only four — Union, Neshannock, Hampton (Class 4A) and Hempfield (Class 6A) — remain.
Being a state champion is no guarantee of a return visit to State College, either. After North Penn lost to District 11 runner-up Nazareth in the first round, Neshannock and DuBois Central Catholic are the only reigning champions remaining in the PIAA playoffs.
Only two state runners-up from 2024 remain in the playoffs — Council Rock South in Class 6A and South Williamsport in Class 2A.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.