You don’t need to look at the faces of Jarrod and Anthony Malagise to know they are identical twins. Just look at their baseball statistics.
The Malagise brothers are seniors for the Blackhawk Cougars, and it’s a bit surreal how some of their statistics are either identical or close to the same.
Get this: Coming into this final week of the regular season, the Malagises (pronounced MAL-a-geese) had the exact same number of doubles, triples and home runs. They also were hit by a pitch the same number of times — and their statistics in batting average, walks and OPS were almost identical. Anthony is a pitcher-shortstop and Jarrod a catcher.
While the statistics are so similar, the real good news for Blackhawk is the Malagise statistics are doubly good. The senior brothers are two of the main reasons Blackhawk finished tied for first in WPIAL Class 4A Section 1 with a 9-1 record and a 13-2 mark overall. The Cougars figure to be one of the top seeds for the Class 4A playoffs when the WPIAL announces playoff pairings Friday.
“They’re amazing young men and players,” Blackhawk coach Lou Wolber said. “Two years ago, when they were sophomores, the only way I knew them apart was if they had their jerseys on. Now, I know they look just a little different to me.”
But about those statistics that are so similar or identical: Anthony is hitting .490 with six doubles, one triple, one home run, 11 walks, four hit by pitches and a 1.323 OPS. Jarrod is hitting .477 with five doubles, two triples, one home run, 10 walks, four hit by pitches and a 1.333 OPS. Is it “twinsanity?”
Read More
“They’re the leaders of the team. The rest of the kids look to them for leadership,” Wolber said.
Wolber will tell you the brothers do so much together, even outside of baseball. In fact, they gave up opportunities to play college baseball and will instead go to Penn State, just as students. Of course, they will be roommates.
“They’re best of friends,” Wolber said. “They were looking to maybe go and play together in college. I think they could’ve easily gone to a Division II college. But they said, ‘We’re not being recruited together by the same school and we want to play together in college, so we just want to go to school together and not play.’ ”
Another brother act
New Brighton has been one of the hottest teams in the WPIAL lately. The Lions head into Wednesday’s game against South Side with an eight-game winning streak. And two of New Brighton’s top players have been “Killer B’s” — brothers Bobby Budacki and Brock Budacki.
Bobby, a senior and a Washington & Jefferson recruit, is 8-1 this season with a 0.77 ERA. He has struck out 51 in 45⅔ innings. He also is hitting .325 with 14 RBIs. Brock Budacki, a sophomore, is batting .310 with 12 RBIs.
The Lions’ success in recent weeks could give them a pretty good seed in the Class 2A playoffs.
Rough times for ‘Canes
New Castle won WPIAL and PIAA championships only two years ago. Things have been rough for the Red Hurricanes ever since.
After the great 2021 season, New Castle missed the playoffs the past two years. Last season, the Red Hurricanes finished 3-10 overall and 3-9 in section. It didn’t help matters that New Castle was bumped up to Class 5A this season. The team finished section play 2-8 and was 4-9 heading into Wednesday.
First-rounders from Pa.
In five of the past seven years, at least one high school player from Pennsylvania has been selected in the first round of the Major League Baseball draft. In three of those years, a first-rounder came from the WPIAL (North Allegheny’s Cole Young in 2022, West Allegheny’s Austin Hendrick in 2020 and Plum’s Alex Kirilloff in 2016). It looks like Pennsylvania might have another first-rounder again this year — and he’s from the eastern part of the state.
Kevin McGonigle is a 5-foot-10, 190-pound left-handed-hitting shortstop who plays for Bonner-Prendergrast in the Philadelphia Catholic League. Baseball America rates McGonigle as the No. 5 high school player for July’s draft. McGonigle came into this week hitting .455.
Check this out
• Peters Township has a pair of Jacks that often leads to a winning hand. The Post-Gazette will publish WPIAL regular-season statistical leaders next week and Peters Township’s Jack Natili and Jack Lutte will both be among the home run leaders. Natili has eight home runs this season and Lutte five. Natili also has 24 RBIs and Lutte 20.
• Avella was 9-6 heading into Wednesday’s regular-season finale, which means the Eagles are guaranteed to finish with a winning record for the first time since 2014. They also have qualified for the WPIAL playoffs. Avella has the second-smallest boys enrollment among all schools in WPIAL baseball.
• The WPIAL baseball committee meets Friday to determine playoff pairings and seedings. A few of the No. 1 seeds are easy to figure, but Class 4A will be tough for the committee. Montour (16-2) is the defending PIAA champion, but Blackhawk (13-2) tied Montour for the section championship and the two teams split two games. Then there is defending WPIAL champ West Mifflin (15-2), but Chartiers Valley (13-4) tied West Mifflin for the section championship and they split two games.
“I think all of those teams are really good and I think all of them have one or two pitchers who can change the outcome of a game,” Wolber said. “It will be interesting.”
Where are they now
• Former Mars High School catcher Jack Anderson is the second-leading hitter for Pitt. Anderson, a senior who started his career at Northwestern, came into the week starting all 45 games for the Panthers (21-24) and had a .308 average with nine doubles, five home runs and 32 RBIs.
• Another former WPIAL catcher is having a good start to his first full season of minor-league baseball. Matt Wood, a Pine-Richland graduate who played at Penn State, was selected by the Milwaukee Brewers in the fourth round of last year’s MLB draft. He is playing for the Carolina Mudcats in the Carolina League and is fourth in the league in OPS at 1.014. He is batting .313 in 20 games with six doubles, three home runs and 17 RBIs.
Correction: Avella qualified for the playoffs in 2022 and 2021. Earlier versions of this story incorrectly stated Avella’s last playoff appearance was 2014.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.