Sean Casey had an illustrious career in Major League Baseball. But Casey is sincere when he acknowledges that some of the greatest and most memorable times of his career didn’t come while wearing any major-league uniform.

They came as a teenager 30 years ago, when he wore the pinstripes of Upper St. Clair High School, when he played with Junk, Buck, Gooch and a number of other longtime pals, when he had an unforgettable spring and a terrific final high school baseball season.

The year was 1992. While the University of Pittsburgh’s athletics booster club was the Golden Panthers at the time, Upper St. Clair baseball had its own group of Golden Panthers. The Upper St. Clair Panthers baseball team, with Casey as one of the leaders, won the gold trophy and gold medals for capturing a WPIAL championship for the first time in school history. Upper St. Clair beat Butler, 7-2, in what was an unusual championship game because of who played in it. How many WPIAL title games have two future major-leaguers? But that’s what 1992 had with Casey, who played 12 seasons in the majors, and Butler’s Matt Clement, who played third base in the title game. Clement was a major-league pitcher for nine seasons.

Thirty years ago was a different time for high school baseball in the district because the WPIAL had only two classifications (there are six today) – and Casey was having the time of his life.

Advertise with us

“When I look back, I made the [MLB] All-Star Game three times and played in a World Series,” Casey said. “But that 1992 team might have been my favorite team I played with of all time. That was the first time in my life I realized how hard it is to win something and how tough it was to get where we did.

“There were kids on that team I played with since we were 8 years old. They were like my brothers. They were guys you went through puberty with. To win a championship with them … Playing in the World Series was unbelievable. But the bond I had with those guys in 1992 is unbreakable. A lot of us are still friends today.”

Heck, Tim McGarvey, the third baseman on the 1992 team, was at Casey’s house on Monday for a little Memorial Day cookout. The two live in Upper St. Clair. One of Casey’s best friends is Mike Junko, Upper St. Clair’s football coach and a catcher on the 1992 team. On Monday afternoon, Mike McHugh texted Casey a picture of the game ball he still has from the 1992 WPIAL title game. McHugh was the winning pitcher and the yellowed ball has Upper St. Clair’s starting lineup written in pen on it.

“I mean, I’m 47,” Casey said, “and I still reminisce with those guys and we say, ‘I still can’t believe we won it in 1992.’ It’s crazy. It seems like yesterday we won it. And it’s so cool that this year’s team got back to the championship.”

This year’s Upper St. Clair team made it to a WPIAL title game for only the third time in school history and were trying to win a championship for only the second time. How coincidental that it came on the 30-year anniversary of the 1992 team. The success of this year’s team stirred up many memories of the 1992 Panthers, who won their WPIAL title just four days before the Penguins won their second Stanley Cup. The 1992 team was full of Malarkey and that was a good thing. Jerry Malarkey was in his eighth year as coach and only retired from his coaching position after last season.

Advertise with us

“You coach 37 years and I’ve always said it’s about kids and relationships,” said Malarkey. “It amazes me 30 years later that I’m still talking with guys from that team, we’re still going to lunch together sometimes and staying in touch with each other. That was a special group among a lot of special groups I had.”

A ‘smoky’ start

The 1992 season started for Upper St. Clair with a trip to Rock Hill, S.C., for a few games in good weather. This team had some characters on it who had known each other since playing together on an Upper St. Clair travel team from ages 8 through 12.

The hotel for the team in Rock Hill had rooms that weren’t enclosed in a building. Room doors opened straight to outside. Well, a few mischievous players thought it would be funny one night to set off a couple smoke bombs on a regular basis outside the rooms.

“The smoke kept getting sucked into the cooling system at the hotel and there was a construction crew staying at the hotel who had to get up at 4 a.m.,” Malarkey said. “It got to the point where I got a knock on my door, I opened it and there was a guy as big as Paul Bunyan standing there from the construction crew. He asked if I was the coach of the team and he wasn’t real happy.

Advertise with us

“Sean Casey tells that story all the time and he always seems to know the facts. We never found out who set off the smoke bombs. But you know, I’m not a member of CSI, but how does he know all the facts?”

Casey is a superb story teller. He can put a banquet room of a couple hundred in tears of laughter with his stories. He gives a hearty laugh at the smoke bomb story, but said, “I swear it wasn’t me who did it. Every time I tell the story I blame someone else, but it wasn’t me.”

The team has many other stories from a memorable season. The ’92 Panthers were a bunch of players who were extremely close, having unforgettable moments on and off the field.

A Post-Gazette story in early May of that season had a comment from Malarkey where he said he never had a team with such great chemistry.

“That team was before the days we have now where players from high school teams scatter to 15 different travel teams in the summer,” Malarkey said. “These kids all came up together and the parents were a pretty tight-knit group, too.”

Advertise with us

Many of the players on the ’92 team played on Upper St. Clair’s 12-year-old travel team in 1986 and that team won five of six tournaments.

“Sean and I always talk about that 12-year-old team,” McGarvey said. “From that point on, we pretty much kept the same nucleus of players.”

Casey said, “We stayed over each other’s house all the time on that team. I practically grew up in Mike Junko’s house. I still remember that 12-year-old travel team, we were 25-6.”

Malarkey said Casey as a high school senior was very much the same person as he is today – jovial, upbeat and humorous. But Malarkey and those who know Casey well say there is a very serious and extremely competitive side to Casey. And it came out often during that 1992 season.

“He was the leader of the team, a vocal leader,” Malarkey said. “At the same time, he set pretty high standards for himself. He expected all to have the same level of intensity as himself, whether you were a starter or the 18th or 20th guy.”

Advertise with us

Casey wasn’t afraid to get on teammates, either. These days Casey is well-known commentator on the MLB Network and also has a popular podcast - “The Mayor’s Office.”

“I knew how special that team could be,” Casey said. “Early in the season, there were some underclassmen who weren’t playing and they were just bringing bad vibes. I remember going up to them before a practice and said, ‘If you don’t want to be a part of this, then just quit. Be on board because we’re going to the top. If you don’t want to be on board, then leave.’ I think that conversation cleaned up a lot.”

The talent

The 1992 team relied heavily on seniors, but some juniors and even a sophomore contributed heavily. The Panthers also had some outstanding athletes who were standouts in other sports. McHugh, who was called Buck, was a standout soccer player who won a WPIAL title in that sport and also played basketball. He played baseball at Penn State and was selected in the 25th round of the 1995 MLB draft.

The team also had some talented football players. Junko, a part-time catcher nicknamed Junk, played Division I football at the University of Akron.

Advertise with us

Outfielder Rick West led the WPIAL in hitting in 1992 with an average about .600. He played football also, but went on to play baseball at Vanderbilt.

McGarvey, called Gooch, played football at Washington & Jefferson. Second baseman Erik Gloff also was a football player.

Gabe Smith played shortstop for Upper St. Clair, while Mike Phillips and Ryan Klein were outfielders. Kurt Glaser was the catcher.

McHugh was the leader of the pitching staff, but Grant Jackson and Mike Tomko also played big roles. Tomko was a sophomore who would go on to be USC’s quarterback in football. Jackson was the son of Grant Jackson Sr., who was a pitcher for the Pirates World Series champion in 1979.

“His dad taught him a curveball that no one could hit,” said Casey, who led the WPIAL in doubles and hit close to .500 in 1992 before going to play at the University of Richmond.

Advertise with us

Malarkey said, “The thing about that team was that they could all hit, 1 through 9 in the lineup.”

Playoff run – without pub

You won’t find any newspaper clippings about Upper St. Clair’s postseason games. That’s because the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and Pittsburgh Press went on strike just as the WPIAL playoffs were about to begin.

“I was devastated the newspapers went on strike. We got no coverage,” Casey said. “All we had was Eleanor Bailey writing about us in The Almanac [South Hills area newspaper].”

Malarkey said, “When we won the WPIAL, all we got was a 10-second blip on the TV news.”

Advertise with us

The quarterfinals and semifinals of the playoffs were close games against Laurel Highlands and Blackhawk, respectively.

“I remember Laurel Highlands in the quarterfinals, I think it was a one-run game, and McHugh loaded the bases with walks,” Casey said. “Coach Malarkey came out, we all came to the mound and we thought he’d take him out. He must have thrown 140 pitches. But Buck said, ‘I got this, coach.’ Coach let him in the game, he got the next three punchouts and we won.”

McGarvey remembers beating Blackhawk, 5-4, in the semifinals and Casey had a big hit.

The title game was played at Flaherty Field in New Castle. Although he was a future major-league pitcher, Clement didn’t pitch for Butler. Heck, Clement pitched only nine innings his junior year and 18 his senior. He was a late developer.

Upper St. Clair got to Butler’s pitchers in the final few innings and won, 7-2.

Advertise with us

“We kind of knew deep down inside we had something special,” McGarvey said. “We knew we would have a dogfight, but we were dogs, too.”

Upper St. Clair started the PIAA playoffs with an easy 13-3 win against Harborcreek. Three days later, Upper St. Clair played DuBois and Malarkey remembers the game being suspended because of rain. The two teams had to come back the next day and finish the contest. Malarkey said DuBois was then able to pitch Jim Pittsley, who would be a first-round draft pick of the Kansas City Royals and eventually pitch in the majors. DuBois ended Upper St. Clair’s season with an 11-9 victory.

Although Upper St. Clair didn’t win a state title, the memories of that great season are still fresh in the players’ minds. And their affection for Malarkey is evident.

“He was more than just a coach. He was a dear friend to all of us, a mentor,” McGarvey said. “There’s not a greater guy to teach young kids. I had some kidney problems recently and was in the hospital. The first three people to visit me were Sean Casey, Jim Render [retired Upper St. Clair football coach] and Jerry Malarkey. That says a lot.

“I can’t speak to the level of play that Sean Casey had of playing in the major leagues and the World Series. But I played in the national football playoffs at W&J. I’d compare that 1992 season as one of the special moments in my life. Thinking of it, brings a smile to all of our faces.”

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh