A dozen or so women have a reunion planned in Pittsburgh for May of 2021. It’s a group of 50-somethings who will come from such places as the mountains in Salk Late City, Utah, and Rehoboth Beach, Del.

They all are former high school teammates who will gather together for induction into the WPIAL Hall of Fame. A day later, the group has a celebration picnic planned in North Park.

But for the 1980 North Hills High School softball team, there would be no HOF enshrinement, no reunion and no plans for a picnic, if one school superintendent had his way 40 years ago. Heck, there would’ve been no PIAA tournament at all for the first state championship softball team from the WPIAL.

This is the 40-year anniversary of a unique North Hills softball squad made up of terrific all-around athletes (three Division I college basketball players) that won five games in five days to win the PIAA title. But part of this team’s unique tale is an untold story where North Hills’ superintendent didn’t necessarily want the team to compete in the PIAA tournament because of costs to the district.

Advertise with us

The backstory is that in 1980, every team that qualified for the PIAA playoffs — softball and baseball — went to Shippensburg for a double-elimination tournament that lasted five days. Each win meant another game and another day in the Shippensburg University dorms. But it also meant more money for room and board.

North Hills won the WPIAL Class 3A championship, but according to coach Dennis Papalia, then North Hills superintendent Joshua Geller didn’t really want the team going to the PIAA tournament because of money.

“I remember my mom going and talking to [Geller] about it,” said Melanie Lees, starting left fielder on the 1980 team. “My mom wasn’t afraid to get involved.”

Could you see if this happened today? A superintendent might be vilified. Geller eventually permitted the team to participate in the PIAA playoffs.

“I remember,” Papalia said, “telling [North Hills athletic director] Earl Ceh to tell Geller that if we couldn’t go, Geller had to be the one to tell the public and the media that the WPIAL champ wasn’t going to the PIAA playoffs. Faced with that, Geller backed down.”

Advertise with us

The money ordeal from 40 years ago is now a funny matter to a team that was seriously good. North Hills would’ve been inducted into the WPIAL Hall of Fame this year, but ceremonies were postponed to May of 2021 because of the COVID-19 pandemic.

The 1980 North Hills team had Pooch, Howie, Mel and Pickle, but they made a name for themselves with a cast of outstanding athletes (five softball starters are in the North Hills Sports Hall of Fame) and a couple great comeback victories in the PIAA tournament. And what might have fueled the championship run was, of all things, a basketball loss.

“We thought we should’ve won the state championship in basketball,” said Mary Ann Maloney, the starting second baseman.

Maloney, Lees, Leigh Curl and Linda Massucci were senior softball standouts but also starters on the strong 1980 North Hills basketball team. North Hills was expecting big things in basketball, especially after finishing the regular season 23-2 and winning a section title. North Hills was the No. 1-ranked team in the WPIAL heading into the playoffs. But in what is still today one of the biggest upsets in WPIAL girls playoff history, North Hills lost in the first round to Penn Hills, 55-32, a game where North Hills made 3 of 28 shots in the second half.

The basketball loss was even more crushing when North Hills watched Shaler go on to win the PIAA championship. North Hills had defeated Shaler in a playoff for the section title.

Advertise with us

“I still remember we were all in the locker room crying after the Penn Hills game,” Maloney said. “That was it. It was over. We finally started softball, but to say we set out to win the state championship in softball really wasn’t the case. Things just fell right for us.”

Papalia, also a basketball assistant, said, “That was an amazing class of athletes and I always felt there was much more to come after that basketball game. Maybe it made them more determined.”

North Hills had to overcome an injury to a key player to win the softball state title. Senior shortstop Lauri Howard, the team’s leading hitter with a .512 average, suffered a torn ACL in her knee during a practice just before the WPIAL playoffs. She was replaced by sophomore Lisa Schlosser.

“Howie was devastated,” said Lees, a close friend. “I was her roommate all week at Shippensburg. I remember all she did was sit in the room and listen to Pink Floyd’s ‘The Wall.’ But she was still with us the whole way.”

Howard said, “It was like I was at the runway and the plane took off and landed without me. But it was still great to see what they did.”

Advertise with us

North Hills had two stellar pitchers in 1980 with Curl and Massucci. Massucci was 10-0 with a 1.97 ERA, but Curl pitched every postseason game and finished 14-0 and gave up only three runs and 14 hits in five PIAA games. Curl, by the way, is now the orthopedic doctor for the NFL’s Baltimore Ravens.

North Hills pretty much cruised to the WPIAL championship in 1980, defeating Mt. Lebanon, 9-3, in the title game. The PIAA tournament started in unusual fashion, with both Curl and Bedford’s Mickey McCann throwing no-hitters. But North Hills scored three runs on errors in a 3-0 victory.

The first great comeback was Tuesday when North Hills scored three runs in the top of the seventh to beat Pennridge, 3-2. With the bases loaded, Schlosser hit a grounder to the pitcher, who threw wildly to home, allowing two runs to score. Christina Marino’s groundout drove in Janet Bowker with the winning run.

North Hills beat Whitehall, 6-0, on Wednesday, and North Penn, 1-0, on Thursday.

In the championship round on Friday, North Hills again played North Penn of suburban Philadelphia. North Penn had to beat North Hills twice if it wanted to win the title.

Advertise with us

North Hills trailed North Penn, 1-0, in the top of the seventh, but the team of destiny prevailed. With one out, Sue Spragale singled and Bowker followed with a triple to center field. The throw from the outfield sailed over the third baseman’s head, allowing Bowker to score the winning run.

In the bottom of the seventh, North Penn had runners on first and second when Lees made a terrific running catch in the outfield, spun and threw to Maloney to double the runner off second and end the game.

“That’s, like, my best memory ever,” Lees said. “That play still gives me goose bumps, thinking about it.”

That entire season was filled with goose-bump moments for North Hills, which won its final 23 games to finish with a 25-1 record. It was 19 years before another WPIAL team won a PIAA title in the largest classification.

North Hills was a well-rounded team that was excellent defensively (.954 fielding percentage) and balanced offensively. Eight starters hit above .300. Curl hit .380 with 30 RBIs, Lees .369, Spragale and Schlosser .366, and Massucci .344.

Advertise with us

But to appreciate the athleticism that was on the 1980 North Hills team, consider that Curl went on to play basketball at the University of Connecticut, where she scored 1,388 points and had 834 rebounds. Maloney played basketball at St. Bonaventure while Lees played basketball and softball at Kansas State. Massucci played volleyball and softball at Clarion while Caye played softball at Clarion. Schlosser played basketball and tennis at Seton Hill, Bowker volleyball and softball at Edinboro and Howard volleyball at LaRoche.

The players now live in various parts of the country, but some in Western Pennsylvania. Bowker resides in Edinboro, Massucci in Butler, Howard in Natrona Heights and Caye in Gibsonia. Curl, whose sister, Laurie, was a backup catcher on the team, lives in Owings Mills, Md. Lees lives in the mountains in Salt Lake City. Schlosser resides in Rehoboth Beach, Maloney in Silver Lake, Ohio, and Marino in Acworth, Ga.

Many of the players haven’t talked in decades, but the WPIAL Hall of Fame selection has them reconnecting through group text messages. Papalia, 73, is a retired coach and teacher living in McCandless.

“When I saw them texting back and forth,” Papalia said, “I had to smile because they all sounded like they were 18 again.”

And how does WPIAL Hall of Famers sound?

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh