When listing the powerhouse programs that have established Western Pennsylvania as one of the premier locations in the country for high school wrestling, several schools immediately come to mind.

Canon-McMillan, Franklin Regional, Kiski Area, North Allegheny and Burrell are just a few of the programs that have developed a reputation for churning out WPIAL and PIAA medalists on an annual basis. Still, attending one of those traditional powers doesn’t guarantee individual success.

The record books are littered with wrestlers from unheralded programs who have risen to the top of the podium at the WPIAL and state level. But in almost a century of competition dating back to the first WPIAL tournament — 84 years to be exact — the Ellwood City Wolverines had never crowned a WPIAL wrestling champion, let alone a regional or state champion.

Then along came Walley.

Advertise with us

▪ ▪ ▪

Unlike many top wrestlers in the area, Austin Walley doesn’t come from a long line of accomplished wrestlers in his family tree.

His father, Matt, enjoyed a decent career at Quigley Catholic, but he never sought to wrestle in college. Yet a couple of years after having his first son, Austin, he decided to get into coaching with the Riverside-Ellwood City Youth Wrestling program. When Austin was about 6 years old, Matt started bringing him to practice and introducing him to the sport.

Austin liked wrestling, but he wasn’t exactly a natural. He said he probably lost more matches than he won over his first three or four years of competition.

“I was kind of taller and pudgier for a little kid. I was a big boy,” Walley said with a laugh. “I think when I was 8 I weighed about 80 pounds.”

Advertise with us

Still, despite years of watching his opponents get their hands raised and leaving most tournaments he entered empty-handed, Walley never once thought about giving up the sport.

After winning his first tournament when he was in fifth grade, Walley started attending club practices at Gladiator Wrestling Club throughout the offseason to keep his skills sharp. He experienced more success in junior high, though he never placed at the Pennsylvania junior state tournament. Still, he expected his talents to translate well to the high school level.

Once he began his high school career at Ellwood City, though, Walley realized just how steep the step up in competition is in the WPIAL. He put together an impressive 27-11 record as a 152-pound freshman, but didn’t place at sectionals and failed to advance to the WPIAL tournament.

“Toward the end of my youth and junior high I got pretty good, so I thought, ‘OK, I’m going to come into varsity and do fine,’” Walley said. “It was kind of a rude awakening. So that offseason I really hit it hard, and I got better.”

▪ ▪ ▪

Advertise with us

Until the end of his freshman year, Walley had been playing football in the fall as a tight end and linebacker. Going into his sophomore year, he decided to give up football and concentrate on wrestling year-round.

Walley continued making incremental improvements, and it showed in the form of his 31-8 record as well as his first section title. He finished third in the WPIAL at 170 pounds, but failed to place at the Class 2A Southwest Regional tournament, and again came up short of making his first trip to Hershey for states.

“It was definitely frustrating to not make states that year, but I knew with how far I grew that year, that if I put in the work again, I’m going to go pretty far next year,” Walley said.

Indeed, Walley earned his first trip to states as a junior while compiling a 36-5 record and claiming his second consecutive section title, this time at 182 pounds. But three of those losses came against Mount Pleasant’s freshman phenom, Dayton Pitzer — one in the regular season, one in the WPIAL finals and one in the Southwest Regional finals.

That left Walley — and Ellwood City — still without a WPIAL title and still without a regional title. He entered the PIAA tournament with a record of 33-3, with all three defeats coming against Pitzer. He set his sights on a rematch in the PIAA Class 2A championship finals, though each would need to win three matches in a row to get there.

Advertise with us

Walley won his first match by 10-2 major decision, then knocked off top-seeded Hunter O’Connor of Jersey Shore, 9-6, to reach the semifinals. Pitzer, meanwhile, steamrolled his way into the state finals with a 47-second pin and a pair of major decisions.

That left Walley one win away from securing a fourth clash against Pitzer with a PIAA championship on the line. Instead, Freedom senior Bryson Miller crashed the all-WPIAL party and eked out a 3-2 decision against Walley in the ultimate tiebreaker period. Walley had defeated Miller in all three of their previous matchups during the season.

Pitzer then went on to claim his first PIAA title with a 3-1 win against Miller. Walley, meanwhile, fell into the consolation bracket and settled for fourth place, ending his season with an uninspired 10-1 defeat against Union City senior Gavin Henry.

“After I lost that match [to Miller], my mind was not right for the consi-semis or the third/fourth place match,” Walley said. “That was a little lesson. I learned that even if you don’t want to wrestle a match, you have to wrestle hard.

“That hurt because I thought I was going to get another match and wrestle Dayton, but still, at the end of the year, I was like, ‘Hey, if I improve like this again, I’m going to win states.’”

Advertise with us

▪ ▪ ▪

Following Walley’s junior year, the Wolverines’ longtime coach, Craig Alberts, decided to resign. His son, Ty, had just become Ellwood City’s first PIAA place-winner before graduating in 2017, and Alberts wanted to be able to watch him and his younger brother, Jake, wrestle in college.

That opened the door for John Fleming to take over as the Wolverines’ new wrestling coach, and the first thing Fleming asked Walley at the start of practice was, “What do you need to work on the most?”

Walley told Fleming he needed to improve both his top and bottom game, but most of all, he told him he had trouble getting out from the bottom against leg riders. So they worked tirelessly on the position all year long — Fleming starting in top position and hooking one of Walley’s legs, Walley scrambling to find a way back to his feet.

In the meantime, Walley was busy putting together a dominant senior season, capturing both the first WPIAL championship and the first regional championship in school history along the way. He entered the PIAA tournament with a record of 41-1 — including 28 pins — and earned the No. 1 seed at 182 pounds.

Advertise with us

This time, Walley’s nemesis wasn’t standing in the way of his ultimate goal — Pitzer missed the entire 2019-20 season with a leg injury he sustained in the preseason. With the revenge factor off the table, Walley had to settle for a gold medal and a place at the top of the podium as his primary motivation going into his final state tournament.

Walley cruised past his first-round opponent by way of a 21-6 technical fall, but things got much tougher in the quarterfinals. He advanced to the semifinals with a 5-2 win against Line Mountain’s Jacob Feese, then earned his first trip to the state finals with a 5-3 decision against Penns Valley’s Andrew Sharer.

▪ ▪ ▪

The next day, Walley jogged out of the tunnel during the Parade of Champions before his championship match against Montoursville’s Dylan Bennett and soaked in the roar of the Giant Center crowd.

Who could have thought the pudgy kid from Ellwood City without any prior accolades would be the first Wolverines wrestler to compete on the center mat in the state finals of the PIAA tournament? Better yet, who would have thought he could win?

Advertise with us

After taking a 4-2 lead, Walley gave up a two-point reversal midway through the second period, then spent the next 70 seconds trying to get back to his feet, but to no avail. With the match tied, 4-4, Walley chose to start the third period on bottom, needing only a one-point escape to take the lead.

Sure enough, as soon as the whistle blew, Bennett tried to hook one of Walley’s legs to keep him down. Walley nearly escaped to his feet multiple times, but Bennett hung on for dear life and forced several restarts back in the center of the mat.

About midway through the period, though, Walley caught Bennett’s foot as he tried to throw a leg in, and used it to sneak out the backside for a two-point reversal. A one-point escape for Bennett cut his lead to 6-5, but he managed to avoid his foe’s desperation takedown attempts over the final minute to secure his PIAA title.

All those years of hard work had culminated in this moment. But Walley didn’t let out some giant roar or flashy celebration. Instead, he just raised two arms up, smiled, and breathed a sigh of relief. His high school wrestling career was over, and his last match will go down in history in Ellwood City lore.

At long last, the Wolverines have a PIAA champion wrestler — and now three individual PIAA champions overall. Taylor Petrak was a state champion swimmer for Ellwood City in 2015 and 2017, and Jake Walker was the school’s first individual state champion in cross country in 2005 and 2006.

Advertise with us

“We have a banner in our school of PIAA individual champions. I was eyeing that up this year,” said Walley, who will wrestle at Bucknell next year. “I’m not sure [when], but it won’t be too much longer before I’m up there.”

Steve Rotstein: srotstein@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SteveRotstein.