As a 6-foot-10 former Pitt star and NBA player, you might think Darren Morningstar was destined to have a son follow in his footsteps.

But when he and his wife, Kim, started a family, fate had other plans.

First child: Girl.

Second child: Girl.

Advertise with us

Third child: Girl.

“I was kind of hoping by the third try we’d have a boy,” Darren said, laughing, “but it’s worked out great.”

The couple might have gone 0 for 3 when it came to producing boys, but the Morningstar girls have all sparkled athletically. Each has been a standout in basketball and volleyball at North Allegheny High School. And when the youngest sister, Paige, begins her volleyball career at Louisville in the fall of 2021, the family will have gone 3 for 3 producing Division I athletes.

These sisters haven’t just been good … They’ve been “Morningstars.”

“I think there are reasons why he didn’t have a son, and they’re all good,” said Kim, Darren’s wife of 23 years. “He’s coached all three of the girls through the years and that’s just been fantastic. It’s kind of funny. I think of people’s perceptions: ‘Oh yeah. Darren. Pro athlete. Former Pitt player. Of course his daughters are going to be good at sports.’ But I don’t think anyone understands how much work they’ve put into it.”

Advertise with us

• Meg is the oldest. She was the Gatorade Pennsylvania Player of the Year in volleyball her senior year at North Allegheny. After graduating in 2015, she went on to play at Notre Dame, where she was a four-year starter and led the Fighting Irish in blocks her senior season.

• Piper, the middle child, graduated from North Allegheny in 2018, and is the only sister who chose to pursue basketball in college. She played last season at Radford, which won the Big South Conference tournament title and advanced to the NCAA tournament for the first time in 23 years. Piper has since transferred to Washington & Jefferson.

• Paige is following Meg’s path. Only a junior, Paige is already considered one of the best players in the WPIAL. She is part of a juggernaut program that has won two consecutive WPIAL and PIAA Class 4A titles. The Tigers are 9-0 this season and have won 56 matches in a row, their previous loss coming in 2016.

If you have followed Pitt basketball over the years, you’re likely familiar with the Morningstar name. Darren played three seasons for the Panthers. As a senior in 1991-92, he averaged 12 points and six rebounds per game on a team that included Sean Miller, Chris McNeal and Eric Mobley. Morningstar was selected by Boston in the second round of the 1992 NBA draft. A brief NBA career also included stops in Dallas and Utah. He then played professionally in Spain, Italy, Argentina and Canada. Meg was born in 1997, a year before Darren finished up his career.

All three sisters are tall just like dad: Meg is 6-2. Piper and Paige are 6 feet. That height has obviously helped them in basketball and volleyball. However, Darren said he would have never guessed that two of the three would end up making volleyball their top sport.

Advertise with us

“I didn’t know anything about volleyball, to be honest,” he said. “We joke that one of the reasons they gravitated to volleyball was because on the basketball court I was always on them about something. I didn’t really know volleyball, so maybe it was kind of a way to get away from me.”

Meg picked up the sport in seventh grade and fell in love with it, and her sisters soon took a liking to it, as well.

“Volleyball kind of became my passion. My Meg passion. Not a Meg family basketball passion,” she said. “I kind of formed my own connection.”

North Allegheny volleyball coach Heidi Miller has coached all three Morningstar sisters. Meg was a middle hitter for the Tigers, while Piper and Paige have both been setters.

“It’s been an interesting dynamic because I’ve had a Morningstar on the team every year for a decade, or so it seems,” she said. “They’re very competitive. All of them started when they were in middle school being lanky girls. I called them baby giraffes. They kind of grew into their bodies and they bring a good IQ and competitiveness to the court.”

Advertise with us

They’ve also helped bring North Allegheny lots of victories. Meg led the volleyball team to a WPIAL title her senior season. Piper was a freshman on that team, and she later won WPIAL and PIAA volleyball titles her junior season — she didn’t play as a senior — and started on back-to-back WPIAL championship basketball teams her final two years. Paige was a reserve on that 2018 basketball team, and already has two WPIAL and PIAA titles to her name.

“It’s pretty amazing when you think about it. It’s cool all three of us have won titles,” Paige said.

But with so much success, comes pressure. Paige said she doesn’t want to think about what it would feel like if the volleyball team’s long winning streak would come to an end this season.

“I can’t even express the words, it’s so important to me,” she said. “I don’t even know what I’d do if we lost. I’d probably freak out.”

A common theme in the family is competitiveness. That comes from both mom and dad, the sisters said. Meg called her mom “sneaky competitive.” The competitive nature extends outside the lines of sports.

Advertise with us

“It’s the silliest stuff,” Piper said. “Board games. Computer games. Monopoly was a big one. Risk. It would get heated.”

It turns out “game night” at the Morningstar home in Franklin Park has led to some fierce battles.

“They still end in tears,” Meg said, laughing. “Now it’s hard because I don’t want to get into a big screaming match if I’m home for just a week. But we make it fun.”

The sisters have all had to overcome their share of adversity. For Meg, it was being that really tall girl who felt awkward as she grew into her body. Piper has epilepsy, and although she doesn’t get seizures anymore, she still has to deal with that disorder on a daily basis. Paige suffered an OCD fracture in her right knee in seventh grade. She had two surgeries, one that forced her to miss a significant amount of school. She ended up repeating eighth grade.

Although the sisters don’t all live under the same roof anymore, they remain close.

Advertise with us

“Honestly, I look up to them even more than my parents sometimes,” said Paige. “It’s their success and their struggles. I’ve learned what to do and what not to do, and I’ve based a lot of my decisions in life on what they’ve done.”

Darren turned 50 in April. He has spent the past 18 years working as a financial adviser for Morgan Stanley. His goal this year was to lose weight, and he said he has dropped 70 pounds, putting him “back to my playing weight.” You can usually find him in the crowd at North Allegheny volleyball and basketball games. He’s the 6-10 guy who isn’t shy to let his voice be heard.

And he’s one proud father.

“I’m just so happy for all three of them, that all three of them were able to get recruited and be good enough to play at the next level, really in both sports,” Darren said. “And hopefully, God willing, we have another six years to go. Two years of high school with Paige and four in college. And we have Piper closer to home, having her at Washington & Jefferson. We already miss traveling to Notre Dame to watch Meg play. It will definitely be sad when it’s all over.”