Only two years removed from playing for a WPIAL and PIAA championship, South Park baseball coach Steve Bucci gave his team an ultimatum after a 4-1 home loss to Elizabeth Forward on May 1 dropped the Eagles to 10-6 overall and 6-5 in section play.

“I told the team, ‘We pretty much have no wiggle room left. Maybe one here or there, but that one can put you out. We’ve got to win everything that’s left,’” Bucci said. “And we did.”

South Park responded with three consecutive wins, knocking off co-section champion Ringgold, 6-4, followed by back-to-back shutout wins against West Mifflin and McKeesport to clinch a playoff spot for the eighth year in a row. The Eagles suffered a 2-0 non-section defeat to Peters Township in their regular-season finale, but at that point, their work was already done.

“Really, for us, it’s a new season,” Bucci said. “And it is for everybody, but it really truly is for us after getting off to a sluggish start — 3-4 in our first seven games in section — then we made a nice run there in the second half going 6-1. And obviously, the works of Brenden Gray and Kevin Vaupel were huge.”

Advertise with us

Vaupel and Gray are the dominant pitching duo that together have powered South Park to the postseason, and they’re the main reason why the Eagles are one of the most dangerous teams in the Class 4A playoffs.

Gray went 5-1 in six starts with a 0.49 ERA, 0.84 WHIP and 77 strikeouts to just 15 walks in 42⅔ innings pitched, while Vaupel went 4-3 with a 1.60 ERA, 1.03 WHIP and 62 strikeouts to 20 walks in 43⅔ innings.

With two lights-out pitchers and only one baseball to go around, Bucci had to ask himself a tough question going into Wednesday’s first-round playoff game against Quaker Valley — albeit a question other coaches in the WPIAL would love to ask themselves: “Which of my aces do I send out to the mound first?”

While Gray’s eye-popping numbers would seem to give him the nod, big-game experience is hard to come by at the high school level — and Vaupel has plenty of it. As just a sophomore in 2017, Vaupel pitched South Park to victory in the first round of the PIAA playoffs as well as the state semifinals.

“Vaupel is more used to being a starter,” Bucci said. “If I go Gray then I go Vaupel, I’m not sure how Vaupel is going to do in a relief role … Gray’s kind of been in that spot in the back end, and he’s done very well with it. So those are things that are going to cross our minds and we’ll talk about a little. But no matter who I throw out there, we’ll feel extremely good about it.”

Advertise with us

Not only do Vaupel and Gray lead the way for the Eagles on the mound, they also provide the punch in the middle of the order for a team without a ton of firepower in its lineup. Vaupel, a Seton Hill commit, went 4 for 4 with three doubles and a home run in South Park’s 6-0 win against McKeesport to wrap up a playoff spot, and he led the team with five home runs and 20 RBIs in the regular season.

“Vaupel and Gray are the key,” Bucci said. “Because if they’re getting those two guys out constantly, we’re asking a lot from the rest of the lineup.”

Bucci decided to give the start to Vaupel in the Eagles’ first-round playoff matchup against the Quakers on Wednesday, and the senior lefty didn’t disappoint, tossing five innings of one-run ball. But South Park still trailed, 1-0, heading into the bottom of the sixth inning.

Then came time for the Eagles’ 1-2 punch to deliver the knockout blow.

First, Vaupel came up with a two-out single to keep the inning alive. That brought the cleanup hitter, Gray, to the plate with a chance to tie the game or take the lead with one swing of the bat.

Advertise with us

Gray chose the latter. The junior smacked a two-run home run over the fence to give South Park its first and only lead of the game, and it was the only lead the Eagles would need.

After taking over for Vaupel in the top of the sixth, Gray went back out to the mound in the seventh to close out the 2-1 win and advance South Park to the Class 4A quarterfinals, where a showdown with Yough and future Pitt pitcher Jarrett Bach awaits. With Vaupel and Gray waiting in the wings, though, Bucci isn’t fretting about his team’s chances in what could be a monumental pitchers’ duel.

“Bach’s a D-I guy, he’s a specimen on the mound. Would it be a round that I don’t look forward to? Probably,” Bucci said. “But the way I look forward to it is we’ve got to have two guys slay the dragon. They’ve got one and we’ve got two.”

Steve Rotstein: srotstein@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SteveRotstein.