Not many softball teams in the WPIAL can say they have a No. 1 starter like Mount Pleasant senior Carolyn Alincic.
Alincic entered the week with a 5-0 record to go with a 0.91 ERA, 69 strikeouts and just six walks in 38 innings pitched. In her past two starts, Alincic has racked up an astonishing 38 strikeouts — including 20 K’s in a 7-4 extra-inning triumph against Connellsville in which Alincic pitched all nine innings.
Oh, and she was the winning pitcher in the 2017 PIAA championship game as just a sophomore.
With Alincic’s combination of elite talent and experience coming through in big games, most coaches would probably send her out on the mound over and over again until her arm starts to fall off. That hasn’t been the case with the Vikings this year, though, as Alincic only started five of the team’s first eight games as they’ve raced to an 8-0 start.
Luckily for Mount Pleasant coach Chris Brunson, the first-year skipper can afford to give Alincic as much rest as she needs thanks to the emergence of sophomore Mary Smithnosky.
“It’s a luxury,” Brunson said. “I imagine that most coaches would like that luxury. Like anything else, you have to manage it. What it’s allowed us to do, is Carolyn doesn’t have to go out there every game and throw 150 pitches, which isn’t good for her and her future.
“We feel like we have a chance to win every time we go out there and play, and it’s because of the caliber of those pitchers.”
Smithnosky has made three starts in place of Alincic, and her numbers stack up favorably to those of the Vikings’ ace, who may be having the best season of any No. 1 pitcher in the WPIAL so far. Smithnosky is 3-0 with a miniscule 0.32 ERA along with 23 strikeouts and only one walk in 22 innings.
The numbers don’t stop there for Smithnosky, though. When she’s not on the mound, the 5-foot-5 sophomore also splits time at third base and left field and has provided a huge spark in Mount Pleasant’s lineup with her bat. She came into the week batting .545 and sitting near the top of the WPIAL leader board with 18 hits on the season.
“I’ve been practicing, I can’t even tell you, nonstop, every day,” Smithnosky said. “I haven’t taken one down day. If I’m not practicing somewhere to hit balls live, I’m hitting off the tee downstairs, I’m practicing my motion pitching. Every little bit of time I have, I’m practicing.”
Although they’re both pitching as well as anyone in the WPIAL, Smithnosky and Alincic say there’s no competition between the two to see who can put up the better stats. Instead, they use each other as motivation to raise their game every time they step on the mound.
“I don’t think there really is,” Alincic said. “We both definitely have different strong suits. Her bat is insane. If I was even in the order still, I think she’d be outbatting me all day, every day.”
Smithnosky, meanwhile, is soaking up every chance she gets to watch Alincic pitch and learn from her before the 5-foot-9 senior graduates and moves on to play for Morehead State.
“She is a perfect role model for me,” Smithnosky said. “I absolutely love watching her pitch. I love cheering her on. I have so much confidence in her. … Just the other day, she had bases loaded, nobody out, and she got us out of the inning with two strikeouts.
“How many times she’s gone through this, the way she knows the game, is so great. I really love watching her and I’m honored to be behind her.”
Even with a WPIAL championship as a freshman and a PIAA championship as a sophomore already on her resume — and Division I softball in her future — Alincic said she has a singular focus for her senior year after losing in both the WPIAL and PIAA semifinals last season.
And with the prolific 1-2 punch Mount Pleasant possesses in its rotation, it’s not too far-fetched to imagine.
“Honestly, it’s kind of state championship or bust,” Alincic said. “I think even if we don’t win the state championship, even this far it’s been a great season with great players. Even the last four seasons have been great seasons with great players, but I want the state championship.”
Steve Rotstein: srotstein@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SteveRotstein







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.