Penn-Trafford has won the WPIAL Class 2A field hockey championship each of the past three years, but this was the first time the team did not have to go through a preliminary round match to get into the state bracket.

“It was exciting and it was really good and we got a lot of work in,” Penn-Trafford coach Cindy Dutt said. “Unfortunately, it just wasn’t enough to sustain any prolonged attack, so it was good for the girls to prepare mentally.”

Just because Penn-Trafford didn’t have to go through the rigors of a pigtail match doesn’t mean it got an easy first-round draw. The Warriors had to take on Twin Valley, the District 3 third-place finisher that made it all the way through to the state semifinals a year ago.

And, even though they didn’t get District 4 champion Selinsgrove again in a neutral site, they were dominated for much of the match before losing, 9-1.

Advertise with us

“We held them in the first half and they peppered us but we were able to get a couple down in shots,” Dutt said. “They were a lot deeper and had a lot more skill and speed.”

To its credit, Penn-Trafford only trailed, 2-1, at the intermission as sophomore Emma Little scored the Warriors only goal and junior goalkeeper Samantha Doherty played brilliantly to keep them in the match.

In the end, though, it was just another case of the WPIAL being outgunned in the state playoffs.

“It’s going to take girls who can dedicate themselves year-round to hockey and start traveling and pick up the game in the third or fourth grade,” Dutt said. “I’m from the east in New Jersey and field hockey is the game … and it’s going to take a whole change in culture, in my view, for us to become fully competitive.”

Little didn’t just score the only goal for Penn-Trafford. She scored the only WPIAL goal in the state tournament.

Advertise with us

In Class 1A, Shady Side Academy was rolled up, 7-0, by District 3 Newport. It wasn’t any better in Class 3A as reigning WPIAL champion Peters Township was dusted, 8-0, by Wilson West Lawn and Pine-Richland was ripped, 7-0, by defending state champion Penn Manor.

Having an entire district get outscored, 31-1 in the first round of the PIAA playoffs, especially one as large as the WPIAL, is certainly enough to give pause as to how much the sport is moving forward in comparison with its eastern competitors. However, most established programs insist the region overall is improving even if the scores don’t quite reflect it.

“I think, in the WPIAL we have girls going on to play at colleges, but we don’t have them in the numbers they do in the eastern part of the state,” Shady Side Academy coach Betsy Gorse said. “But we have girls involved in the futures program and the winter programs. It’s there, it’s come a long way since I was doing this 30 years ago.”

Since the PIAA first started holding state field hockey championships in 1974, no WPIAL team has ever made it into the semifinals, much less played for a title. There have been sporadic victories in the state tournament, most notably a first-round Class 1A win by Ellis School in 2017 and one in Class 2A from Shady Side Academy in 2011 — but the fact that, outside of a few pigtail matches over the years, Class 3A has not won an actual first-round match since Vincentian in 1987 is somewhat alarming.

To that end, it’s likely WPIAL teams will diversify their schedules and expand their non-conference slates to include more eastern programs in an effort to improve the product.

“We’re doing the right things and what we need to do short of playing the entire season over there and you can’t do that,” Gorse said. “But I think getting two or three games a season in the Harrisburg area and over will be a good way for the girls to experience that.”