It’s not an optical illusion when you watch Peters Township senior Nicki Phelps play lacrosse.

His stick really is bigger than he is.

“I wouldn’t say it’s different for the most part because in the years I’ve been at Peters Township, we really haven’t had big defensemen, especially this year, so it’s not bizarre,” Peters Township coach Mike Kaplan said. “But it’s definitely unique to see someone handle that six-foot pole as well as Nicki does.”

At 5 feet 11, Phelps is perhaps the best long-stick midfielder in the WPIAL and is also one of the best faceoff players in the game. This season he scored only 16 goals, but by winning 68 percent of his draws, he helped the Indians have 36 more possessions out of every 100 than their opponents.

Advertise with us

With him on the draw, Peters Township was able to use those extra possessions to win its first section title in school history and roll to its second-consecutive WPIAL Class 3A championship. Phelps was also voted to All-American status by opposing coaches, was named the WPIAL Class 3A player of the year and is the Post-Gazette Boys Lacrosse Player of the Year.

“Throughout lacrosse season I would always have my stick in my hands using a bounce-back in my driveway and throw the ball off my walls so that I’m almost one with my stick,” Phelps said. “Before games when we’re going against someone, we watch a decent amount of film and I watch the habits the other faceoff guys have and look for patterns. I do specific things to counter them and make it difficult for them.”

One of the other things the Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute recruit is also adept at is using his long stick to pick up ground balls, a key still for defending and stopping an opposing attack.

“I guess it’s one of my strong points. I always try to make the ball go on the ground by hitting their stick so they can’t make a clean grab and make it into a 50-50 ground ball,” Phelps said. “Defense is very important and it’s the keystone of a good team. Not even individual players, but players that work well together.”

Though Phelps excels at lacrosse, it wasn’t always his only sport. He played football for two seasons but gave it up his junior year while he was recovering from a broken jaw and was a wrestler for three years before concentrating solely on lacrosse last season.

Advertise with us

“It was the last sport that I played that I started, but it was the one that I loved the most,” Phelps said. “It’s different from the other two because you have your stick and not just your hands and body.”

Playing those other sports, though, helped hone his lacrosse skills in various ways.

“The wrestling aspect really helped him with his aspect of becoming a good faceoff guy and football helped him develop that toughness as an athlete and he’s not afraid of contact,” Kaplan said. “And, he must have gotten it from lacrosse, but his hand-eye coordination and his ability to focus and finding the ball and coming up with it really made him stand out as a lacrosse player.”

And he certainly made an impression on his opponents as well.

“He was a defenseman but he was an animal with a super-high motor and a super-high compete level. He’s going to play at a really good Division III school,” Mt. Lebanon coach Mike Ermer said. “We didn’t completely avoid him, but we let the boys know there were other options where we could push the ball.”

Advertise with us

Still, playing in the WPIAL is a lot different than playing at RPI and he knows he has some adjustments to make before he takes the field in college.

“I just have to do a lot of outside work beyond practice and games,” Phelps said. “It’s all about stick skills and studying up on lacrosse and watching how they play at the next level and constantly improving.”

2018 lacrosse All-Stars (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)