Mt. Lebanon has gone head to head with North Allegheny for several years and knows just how good the Tigers’ girls and boys teams are to swim against.
That doesn’t mean the Blue Devils didn’t take a lot out of their early season loss to North Allegheny as they move forward and prepare for the upcoming WPIAL and PIAA Class 3A meets.
“It was an awesome meet with a lot of pool records and a lot of school records set,” Mt. Lebanon coach Tom Donati said. “The girls meet was a lot more exciting than the boys because, I’ve been doing this a long time and in 26 years I haven’t seen a boys team, top to bottom, so strong as North Allegheny. I was really impressed.”
Despite the losses in both halves of the meet, Mt. Lebanon is gearing up for a rematch with North Allegheny at Pitt’s Trees Pool in early March. But despite a talented group, the Blue Devils will have a lot of work to do if they are to dethrone the boys team that has won five championships in a row and 10 of the past 11 and a girls squad that has racked up eight in a row.
And he would know. Donati was the coach at Upper St. Clair in 2011 when the Panthers defeated the boys by winning the final heat of the 400-yard freestyle relay to upset the Tigers and break up what could have been an 11-year winning streak.
“I really believe to this day that if we don’t win that relay, the boys go on to beat Bethel Park’s streak of 20 consecutive titles, and they still may,” Donati said. “I’ll never forget the reaction of their then-assistant coach Pat Wentzel because he knew with the pipeline they had, they were going to make a run like nobody ever has.”
After graduating several senior state qualifiers, the Mt. Lebanon boys might not have enough to pull off the upset and end North Allegheny’s boys streak, but the girls might be another issue altogether. The Blue Devils actually sneaked past the Tigers in the PIAA meet last year as they finished third, 19 points ahead of North Allegheny.
“We gave them a good fight last year and, halfway through the meet, it was us and St. Clair and we were in a three-way fight and they got us at the end,” Donati said. “Then we got to states and we jumped ahead of them.”
Mt. Lebanon also has something it didn’t have on the girls side last year; a healthy Kathryn Nicholson. The senior Alabama recruit sat out all of last year with an undisclosed injury, but is back at full strength and could be a key factor in the Blue Devils perhaps ending one of the longest current team winning streaks in the WPIAL.
“The thing with them is, for every superstar we have, they have a superstar and two stars,” Donati said. “We have a lot of stars and we have some girls that are very, very, good, but they have numbers behind them which makes a big difference. I think my team is more of a state team.”
West Allegheny
In 2014, West Allegheny ended a solid run in girls swimming when the Indians capped off their fourth consecutive WPIAL 2A team title.
For a while it appeared they might make a run at Oakland Catholic’s record of 11 in a row in the classification. Then, like the Eagles, West Allegheny had its string end not in the pool, but in the boardroom by the PIAA biennial realignment.
Since moving up to Class 3A, the Indians’ best finish was 10th in 2015, but there is a little bit of solace for the school this season. The West Allegheny boys have also moved up to Class 3A this year, which means the two won’t have to do split meets anymore.
“Overall we look pretty good and the girls are 4-0 and the boys are 3-1,” West Allegheny coach Bob Miller said. “The boys side, the depth this year is better than it has been in recent years, so that will be a challenge.”
West Allegheny brings back senior Michael Kocher, who finished third in the state in the 200 individual medley with a time of 1:53.83. With the move up to 3A, that pace would have placed him eighth, but his morning qualifying time of 1:57.19 would have left him out of the consolation race.
His situation is one of the reasons why Miller believes the PIAA should have expanded to three classifications when it increased football, basketball, baseball and softball to six classes while leaving the so-called individual/team sports such as tennis, wrestling and swimming at just two.
“They say they can’t do it, but it could be done if they really wanted to do it and wrestling got stuck the same way,” Miller said. “That really makes it tough on what I call the middle group of schools like us who have something like 250 kids graduating this year and we have to compete against schools that have 700-plus. The PIAA deemed that as fair as compared to a team that has 260 competing against a team with 210 as not.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.