Beaver girls volleyball coach Charlene Horwatt is disappointed with the PIAA’s decision to add a fourth classification for the 2016-17 season.

“I don’t see a good reason for adding a fourth class,” said Horwatt, a 19-year coaching veteran. “It compromises the integrity of the sport. With three champions, it really meant something to be a WPIAL champion. Adding a fourth class makes it less meaningful and waters down the competition.”

Our Lady of the Sacred Heart coach Mike McDonald agrees.

“In general, I think adding a classification is not a good thing for girls volleyball,” said McDonald, who also serves as chairman of the WPIAL volleyball committee. “A few concerns are geography and distance, not playing your long-time rivals, and strength of sections and classifications.”

Advertise with us

Freeport coach Tom Phillips is in favor of having a fourth classification.

“I like the change to four classes,” Phillips said. “It allows more teams to compete with teams their own size and gives more teams an opportunity to compete in the postseason.”

The WPIAL will open the 2016 season with 121 teams, down one from last year, as West Shamokin returned to District 6.

Last year’s three-class alignment had 36 teams in Class AAA, 44 in Class AA and 42 in Class A.

The new alignment has 26 teams in Class AAAA, 28 in Class AAA, 35 in Class AA and 32 in Class A.

Advertise with us

With only 26 teams in Class AAAA, two sections have only six teams, while the other two have seven teams. That’s significant because the top four teams from each section qualify for the WPIAL playoffs. That means 68 of the WPIAL’s 121 teams will qualify for postseason play.

“The biggest negative from my perspective is that the top four teams from each section make the playoffs,” Thomas Jefferson coach Ron Kelly said. “The four sections in Class AAA have seven teams in each. That means more than half of the teams [16 of 28] make the playoffs. We will surely have teams with losing records qualifying.

“Winning a WPIAL title will still be a nice accomplishment, but it’s really watered down in sports with six classifications, like football and basketball.”

The nine sections in Class AAA and AA each have seven teams. Class A has the biggest sections with eight teams each.

“Having 14 section matches gives us less flexibility in scheduling non-conference matches with other Class A opponents,” McDonald said. “That will make seeding for the playoffs more difficult.”

Advertise with us

Ten teams moved from Class A up to Class AA: Avonworth, Beth-Center, Cardinal Wuerl North Catholic, Carlynton, Neshannock, New Brighton, Serra Catholic, Shenango, South Side Beaver and Washington.

“Six of the 10 teams that moved up to Class AA were in the Class A playoffs last year, so I think there will be less upper-level teams competing in Class A this year,” McDonald said. “There’s not a lot we can do about it, but these are the ramifications of the east wanting six classes in football and the fallout from all other sports having to follow suit. The attitude going forward is simply ‘this is what we have so let’s make lemonade out of it.’”

Twenty-six of the 36 schools that competed in Class AAA last season make up the new Quad-A classification. The 10 teams that moved down to the new Class AAA are: Albert Gallatin, Chartiers Valley, Gateway, Hampton, Laurel Highlands, Mars, McKeesport, Ringgold, Trinity and West Allegheny.

“We had a team that was worthy of a playoff berth last season, but fell one win short in a very strong section. It was unfair for us to be competing with schools so much bigger than us,” Chartiers Valley coach Jason Ferri said. “The realignment is a good thing for us. It puts us in a class with schools more our size.”

The additional class also increases the number of WPIAL teams that qualify for the PIAA tournament from 10 to 13 teams. The top four teams qualify in Class AA, while the other three classes have three qualifiers.

Advertise with us

Avonworth is one of the teams that moved up to Class AA. The Antelopes, a playoff team in Class A last year, have been placed into Section 2, the strongest of the five Class AA sections.

“I had reservations at first, but now I am glad the change has been made,” Avonworth coach Doug Vandervort said. “We will face stiff competition every night. There are no easy teams in our section. We will be tested in every match. That will better prepare us for the playoffs.”

A few coaches contacted by the Post-Gazette were indifferent to the change.

“I am honestly neutral on the decision,” South Fayette coach Scott Sundgren said. “Our section has changed a number of times over the 17 years I’ve coached. Our new section is very similar to the section we were in several years ago.”

South Fayette has moved up to Class AAA to Section 2, the strongest of the four sections.

Advertise with us

“I feel the new section is a strong one with well-coached teams,” Sundgren said. “We have been in a good section for many years, but this is stronger because all the teams bring a high level of competition to the gym. It is going to be a challenge.”

Obama Academy coach Pete Vitti was not surprised that his squad moved up to Class AAA, but was disappointed with the distance his squad must travel to compete in Section 1.

“We’re all over the map: Indiana, Greensburg Salem, McKeesport, West Mifflin,” Vitti said. “Almost all of our section matches will require a bus ride of at least an hour.”

The same is true for Obama Academy’s boys team. The Eagles were one of two teams that changed sections in the 2017 realignment.

Obama Academy and Bishop Canevin have switched sections. The Eagles are now in Section 2, while the Crusaders moved to Section 3.

Advertise with us

“I was very disappointed with our move to Section 2,” Vitti said. “Our shortest trip is 40 minutes to Deer Lakes. The rest are at least an hour.”

The only other change to the boys alignment is that Mars will make its WPIAL debut in Section 2, replacing West Shamokin.

------------------

SETTING THE STAGE

• Reading has the biggest enrollment of any school in the state with 1,593 girls (from grades nine through eleven).

Advertise with us

• North Allegheny (950) has the biggest enrollment of any WPIAL school.

• Armstrong (394) is the only team playing up in classification, as it opted to move up to Quad A.

• Franklin Regional (435) missed the cutoff for Class AAA by two girls. The cutoff is 433.

• Gateway (431) is the biggest Class AAA school, two fewer than the cutoff.

• Highlands (264) and Yough (265) are the smallest Class AAA schools.

Advertise with us

• Beaver (238), Hopewell (238) and Quaker Valley (237) are the biggest schools in Class AA, as the trio barely made the cutoff of 238.

• Serra Catholic (137) is the smallest Class AA school, two more than the cutoff of 135.

• Northgate (132) is the biggest Class A school, three fewer than the cutoff.

• Beaver County Christian has the smallest enrollment in the WPIAL with 22 girls.

GIRLS ALIGNMENT

Advertise with us

(enrollment in parenthesis)

Class AAAA

Section 1 - North Allegheny (950), Seneca Valley (854), Butler (851), Pine-Richland (551), Shaler (547), North Hills (509).

Section 2 - Mt. Lebanon (652), Canon-McMillan (590), Bethel Park (585), Peters Township (537), Upper St. Clair (531), Baldwin (518), Moon (438).

Section 3 - Hempfield (665), Norwin (652), Latrobe (500), Penn-Trafford (471), Connellsville (460), Franklin Regional (435), Armstrong (394).

Advertise with us

Section 4 - Penn Hills (530), Fox Chapel (520), Oakland Catholic (457), Kiski Area (460), Woodland Hills (455), Plum (441),

Class AAA

Section 1 - Gateway (431), McKeesport (392), Obama Academy (337), Greensburg Salem (332), West Mifflin (327), Indiana (321), Highlands (264).

Section 2 - West Allegheny (410), Trinity (401), Chartiers Valley (391), Montour (375), Ringgold (337), South Fayette (323), Ambridge (278).

Section 3 - Laurel Highlands (374), Albert Gallatin (373), Thomas Jefferson (332), Uniontown (330), Belle Vernon (297), Elizabeth Forward (283), Yough (265).

Advertise with us

Section 4 - Hampton (381), Mars (375), Knoch (312), New Castle (299), Lincoln Park (280), Central Valley (274), Blackhawk (269).

Class AA

Section 1 - Ellwood City (202), Beaver Falls (175), Neshannock (163), Laurel (157), Mohawk (154), New Brighton (143), Shenango (143).

Section 2 - Beaver (238), Hopewell (237), Quaker Valley (237), Avonworth (188), Freedom (177), South Side Beaver (151), C.W. North Catholic (146).

Section 3 - Southmoreland (232), Waynesburg (187), Brownsville (185), McGuffey (185), Charleroi (174), Beth-Center (147), Washington (147).

Advertise with us

Section 4 - Keystone Oaks (235), South Park (233), Steel Valley (181), South Allegheny (173), Carlynton (160), Seton-LaSalle (148), Serra Catholic (137).

Section 5 - Derry Area (234), Deer Lakes (224), Freeport (224), Valley (223), Burrell (222), East Allegheny (173), Apollo-Ridge (151).

Class A

Section 1 - O.L. Sacred Heart (126), Aliquippa (101), Western Beaver (97), Union (92), Rochester (81), Cornell (60), Quigley Catholic (45), Beaver County Christian (22).

Section 2 - Frazier (129), Bentworth (111), California (108), Carmichaels (103), Geibel Catholic (63), Mapletown (88), Jefferson-Morgan (80), West Greene (68).

Advertise with us

Section 3 - Northgate (132), Brentwood (128), Burgettstown (127), Sto-Rox (122), Fort Cherry (114), Chartiers-Houston (110), Bishop Canevin (101), Avella (74).

Section 4 - Greensburg C.C. (124), Springdale (116), Vincentian (110), Riverview (107), Leechburg (98), St. Joseph (73), Eden Christian (58), Trinity Christian (35).