Mt. Lebanon appeared in the PIAA Division 1 girls lacrosse semifinals in 2014, so the players had a pretty good idea of what to expect when they took the field Tuesday against Conestoga at Cumberland Valley.
Though the opponent had changed from that loss to Garnet Valley two years ago, the end result was the same as the Blue Devils were knocked out, 20-5, in one of the more lopsided games in state playoff history.
“Truthfully, early on in the first three or four minutes, we hit two posts and the goalie made a save,” Mt. Lebanon coach Brian Kattan said. “We couldn’t convert on all our early opportunities and they converted on theirs and I think that, maybe if we got a couple of those early in the game, it would have been a different game.”
Megan Gibbons and Kate Srmac each had two goals to lead the Mt. Lebanon attack, but it wasn’t enough to stem the tide against the Conestoga onslaught. The District 1 fifth-place Pioneers attacked the Blue Devils at will, pulled them out of their game plan and rolled to a 13-2 lead at the intermission.
“The score doesn’t show how well we played because two years ago we were flat-out beat and they beat us.” Kattan said. “This time, we had our shots, we didn’t make our shots and they made their shots, but we didn’t play a terrible, terrible game.”
It’s not just Mt. Lebanon that has had nightmarish experiences in the state playoffs. Since the PIAA first added a state lacrosse tournament in 2009, no WPIAL team has made an appearance in the finals and the closest of the semifinal defeats the past four years were a 12-9 Peters Township loss in 2013 and a 13-10 Quaker Valley loss last season.
“I think we need to go out there and play the better competition out east,” Kattan said. “They have 32 teams that can make their playoffs, they can all play lacrosse. They also know what they’re doing and we have eight teams in two sections.”
District 1 has owned the state tournament the past eight years. All 16 finalists, including Conestoga and Radnor this year, have come from the suburban Philadelphia district with Garnet Valley winning three times and Radnor twice previously.
It’s not just the girls from that part of the state who have dominated the state tournament. All of the finalists in the boys division, including District 12 champion LaSalle College and District 1 third-place finisher Springfield this year, are from the Philadelphia area.
“Those kids want to play at a higher level and get to a higher school play in college,” Kattan said. “Here we have some great athletes who may or may not want to play in college and get to those bigger schools and I think that also definitely makes a difference.”
Experience also counts. Many of the players in the Pittsburgh area don’t pick up the sport until their freshmen or sophomore years of high school and have to learn the nuances of the game on the fly, while the eastern schools have players who were raised on the game.
That disparity in training from the extensive Philadelphia youth programs compared to Pittsburgh, which has relatively few, also comes into play with the depth of quality teams from the east. It’s also one of the reasons why a fifth-place team from District 1 can beat a WPIAL champion by 15 in a state semifinal.
“I think it’s the speed of the game that they play with out there and the physicality,” Kattan said. “I think we’re going to have to do a better job of scheduling games out that way over the next couple of years just so we can help ourselves when we get to that position to make sure we know what the speed of the game is like out there and their physicality.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.