South Fayette has always been one of those hockey programs that is just good enough to qualify for the PIHL Class A playoffs, but anything beyond has been out of arm’s reach.

At least until this season.

All South Fayette (8-3-0) has done so far is equal its win total from last season, post signature wins against perennial contenders Thomas Jefferson and Serra Catholic and move into third place in the Western Conference, just three points behind second-place Montour (9-1-1).

“It’s really been two things in that, last year, we had six or seven kids come up from our middle school team to play varsity hockey and we didn’t have a junior varsity program and we do this year for the first time,” South Fayette coach Frank Certo said. “It’s hard to go from middle school non-checking to play at the varsity level and we did what we could do just to have the bodies we had. The game was a little over their heads even though they got better as the season went on.”

Advertise with us

South Fayette had not had a winning season since 2010-11 when the team went 12-7-2 and lost to Mars, 5-0, in the first round of the PIHL Class A playoffs. In their past five postseason appearances, the Lions are 0-5 and have been outscored, 42-11, a streak that includes a 9-8 loss to Thomas Jefferson in the 2015 Penguins Cup tournament.

There are, however, several factors that could help South Fayette turn things around this season, first among them being the fact that all four of last season’s semifinalists, including champion Mars and perennial finalist Quaker Valley, were moved up to Class AA leaving a gaping hole in the classification for almost every school to fill.

“I don’t think there’s any question, and with those two teams being there, we played each of those two teams three times. It’s crazy because there’s no way in the world they’re going to beat them. I look like the only idiot in the room trying to figure out a way to beat those guys,” Certo said.

“It’s no question they should have moved up and it sparked hope. The bottom line is that there is a very open opportunity and, not only are we a more developed team and more able to handle the challenge, we know that, if we catch fire, we can be there in the end.”

South Fayette has never won a Penguins Cup title, but could become a challenger if it gets it full lineup on the ice. Only three players, forwards Logan McConnell and Alex Hornick and defenseman Eric Milburn, have played all 11 games. Freshman Jeremy Anthos is the team’s leading scorer with 21 points in 10 games, but all-star forward Jordan Thimmons has 12 goals and 17 points in just four games and Spencer Barber has 14 assists and 19 points in eight as the two are among several Lions who play for the high school team around their travel hockey schedule.

Advertise with us

“Jordan’s one of those Pens Elite kids and he’s, unfortunately, not there all the time … but I think they’re finding out that they can be successful and win without some of our big guns,” Certo said. “That’s huge because, when he’s there, he just makes us that much better.”

South Fayette will have its full roster tonight, in fact, when the team hosts Freeport (8-2-0 before playing South Park Thursday), the second-place team in the Eastern Conference, at 7 p.m.

“We’ve only played one game this year with our full lineup,” Certo said. “Who knows what we’ll be when we get all these guys in the lineup, but we could really get moving.”