Shady Side Academy girls tennis coach Jeff Miller held the second-place trophy in his hands after his team lost a heartbreaking 3-2 match to North Allegheny in the WPIAL Class AAA finals last week and pondered where he should put it.
“I’ll just give it to one of the kids to take home because our athletic director won’t accept it,” Miller joked. “I still have last year’s in my basement. We don’t play for second place, but hey, they deserved it. They beat us.”
It has been a rough few years for Shady Side Academy as the team has made it to the WPIAL Class AAA team championship match six consecutive years, but has taken home the second-place trophy each of the past five trips. The Indians have not won the team title since defeating Mt. Lebanon, 3-2, in 2010, the last of their four championships in five years.
That was also the last time Shady Side Academy won the PIAA Class AAA title. Since the state added the girls team title in 2000, the Indians are tied with Lower Merion for the most appearances in the championship match with six, but they only have two titles to their credit, adding a 5-0 win against District 3 Hempfield to their 3-2 victory against Mt. Lebanon in a 2010 WPIAL finals rematch.
Perhaps the most frustrating thing about that runner-up trophy is that Shady Side Academy might be the second-best team in the state. The problem is that No. 1 happens to be North Allegheny, the three-time reigning WPIAL and two-time defending PIAA Class AAA champion.
Both teams head to Hershey Racquet Club looking for a possible rematch, not only of their WPIAL final from last week, but of the 2014 state finals when North Allegheny knocked off Shady Side Academy, 3-1. Because the outcome had been decided, the No. 2 singles match between Tina Li and Emma Perelman was suspended after two sets.
When the two players met in the WPIAL team finals, though, Perelman came away with a surprising 6-3, 6-1 win over Li that avenged an earlier loss when the two teams met in a non-section match.
That earlier meeting, a 3-2 Shady Side Academy victory that ended North Allegheny’s 49-match winning streak, gave the Indians hope heading into the team finals and, with Perelman’s win and a subsequent victory in No. 1 doubles, all they needed was a win in any of the other three matches to take home the title.
That was when everything changed as Li’s sister, Anna, the Tigers’ No. 1 player, knocked off defending PIAA Class AAA singles champion Ananya Dua in a state championship rematch, 3-6, 6-1, 6-2 and helped North Allegheny win the final three matches and take home its third consecutive title.
“Ananya was cruising and Anna got into her game and she fell apart a little bit,” Miller said. “We were hoping she wasn’t human. It wasn’t that Ananya played bad. It was that Anna stepped up.”
Now, though, for Shady Side Academy to end its current runner-up-run, the Indians will need to figure out a way to knock off North Allegheny again. The Tigers, who will play at 11 a.m. today, are looking to become the first team to win three consecutive PIAA Class AAA team titles and tie Peters Township with a record four state titles in the highest classification.
“I shook Shady Side Academy coach’s hand and said I’m probably going to meet you in the finals up in Hershey … but we have two more matches up there before we play them and every match we play is in preparation for a championship match,” North Allegheny coach Michelle Weniger said.
“They’re so excited about going to Hershey, but you have to keep them grounded and tell them those opponents want to come out and beat us because it would be thrilling for them to beat North Allegheny.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.