Mike White: It's snowing out, but let's have some hot talk. State championships Thursday through Saturday. Who is player of the year now around here? Basketball has started. Signing day for football is Wednesday. Who will sign Matt Sieg? Let's talk.

Mr Ed: This is a premature question given they have one more big game to play, but in terms of lower classification teams(1-2A when four classifications, 1-3A now) is Avonworth one of the most impressive you have seen? They haven’t mercy ruled everybody like Steel Valley but they beat 4A champs and TJ decisively. What strikes me is how many different kids on that team can beat you. Lot of times dominant high school teams have one “go to” player.

Mike White: Avonworth is really, really good. I think better than last year. Agree that so many kids can beat you. Even the Jones kid at receiver. Watch him. Defense pretty good also. It's a rematch of last year's stitle game. Northwestern Lehigh is really good again. But I'll take Avonworth this time.

Wpial dude: What is the most memorable reaction you ever got from a kid when you told him he made the fab 22? Any kid ever cry? How do they normally react?

Advertise with us

Mike White: No, I've never had a kid cry. Had some that are very thankful. Pine-Richland's Oobi Strader tweeted this year that it has been a goal since he was a little kid to make the Fabulous 22. Most memorable reactions were with basketball Fabulous 5. Mt. Lebanon's Geoff Kestler made it. He was on vacation with his family in another country. His dad flew him back early just to be in the Fab 5 picture. Pete Sauer, whose dad was the president of the Pirates, was in Bradenton for spring training. He flew in to Pittsburgh. Took the Fab 5 picture and then flew back to Bradenton. You can say well he had the money to do that. But he didn't have to.

Mike White: I remember longtime Blackhawk baseball coach Bob Amalia (God rest his soul) when I told him his daughter made the girls basketball Fab 5. He said, "Mike, I'm crying." Those reactions are pretty neat. We did an all-time Fab 22 in 2020. Just of the years from 1980-2020. Here's what former Central Catholic and NFL QB Marc Bulger had to say. Pretty revealing: "“I have jerseys from Johnny Unitas, Dan Marino and Jim Kelly on the wall, [in my basement] But that framed Fab 22 page is front and center.” Enough said.

Panther Fan: You are probably the only person in the world that can answer this question. What is the record for tackles in any WPIAL game? Discussion came up with a group of friends after watching 5A game at Acrisure where the kid had 22 tackles- seemed like 32!. In following WPIAL Football closely for more than 30 years, We could not remember anyone having more than 20 in a single game.

Mike White: No idea. And no one has what the record is. Heck, people are so different in keeping tackles at the high school level. You're talking about James Spratt, who had 22 tackles in the WPIAL 5A final. Great performance. But yes, I've heard players having 20 tackles before. But James had n unbelievable playoff run.

Psu: Would you have picked terry smith to be penn states head coach when bob Palko is on the staff?

Advertise with us

Mike White: I don't know. I definitely would've looked around, though, to see who else might have been interested. Terry should be a candidate.

Recruiting Ram: There are 3 kickers listed on PR’s roster. You’re really telling me that we went for two because no one could make an extra point? No chance we went for two because DOCTOR ledonne is too smart for his own good.

Mike White: No idea bout Pine kicking depth chart. Wasn't on my list of things to track this season.

PGH basketball: Do you think Dice has any chance to take down Obama this year? After seeing their game vs Montour and how Obama fought with butler and LP I don’t think they have a chance

Mike White: Yes, I do. Obama has all starters back, but Allderdice will be good again. Lukas Stead (last year's City Player of the Year) hasn't played yet for Allderdice. He certainly makes a difference. But for now, we have Obama ranked No. 1 in the City League.

Advertise with us

…….: Hey mike, what were your thoughts on the Imani vs noon game? Is it a down year for Imani or is Moon legit?

Mike White: I was not there and didn't watch. So I really have no opinion. Sure, Moon is a team to watch. Transfer of Jackson Bauman in helped immensely.

Fab 22: Looking back on your career, who would you say are kids you regret not making the fab 22? I was looking at old ones and was surprised Justin Watson didn’t make it

Mike White: You can always point to kids who didn't make it and make a point for them. Do we always make the right picks? No. It's easy to sit back years later and say this kid should've made it. Justin Watson was a very good receiver. Should he have made it? Maybe. Maybe not. I always say it's easy for people to say this guy and that guy should've made it. But then who do you take off. It's to say now Justin Watson should've made it. But nobody - and I mean NOBODY - was thinking Justin Watson would be an NFL receiver coming out of South Fayette. And anybody who says they thought he would be is full of it.

pops: Interesting start to the boys basketball season. Imani gets smack by moon and LP appears to have reloaded with not only the pratt brothers but also Frye from Imani. How did that transfer go under the radar? He is easily one of the top sophs in the wpial.

Advertise with us

Mike White: You're talking about Malcolm Frye. I did not know he was now at Lincoln Park. Yes, I guess he was at Imani last year. There is Josh and Jeremiah Pratt who also transferred in to Lincoln Park. Then there is freshman Amaizen Straughters. He went to Connellsville through eighth grade. Talented player. He's now at Lincoln Park. But hey, we all know a kid from Connellsville who decides to go a school all the way in Midland had absolutely nothing to do with basketball, right? The more things change, the more they stay the same with Lincoln Park. But hey, at least they aren't getting players from other countries like Sewickley Academy has brought in.

pops: The kid that transferred to imani last year from north hills (demis?) that got a lot of attention in the pg and even a questionable D1 "offer" seems to have disappeared. Did he transfer again or his he no longer on the team? I watched the imani game at geneva and other than the point guards no one else stood out. Are they going to regret moving up to 6a this year? They don't seem to be as talented as last year and the coaching doesn't seem to be effective with lesser players.

Mike White: He is still with the team. He was at KDKA media day Sunday night.

smitty: I was looking at a few team's basketball schedules and noticed there are a lot of teams who will have played 2 or 3 games before other teams who have not played one. It seems like an advantage to former. Why don't more teams try to play at least one game in the first week?

Mike White: Couple years ago PIAA let basketball teams start a week earlier if they wanted. Some choose not to. I don't think it's a big deal either way.

Advertise with us

Marcus the great: I saw avonworth basketball changed their schedule and cancelled a few games early in the season. That doesn't seem fair to the teams that they cancelled with. I understand that they probably are short a few football players but oh well. Don't schedule games early if you know your roster depends on football guys. Play with the guys you have. Thoughts?

Mike White: Avonworth has a ton of football guys in basketball. You can't not schedule games in basketball the first or second week of the season just because you "think" your football team is going to be good. These basketball schedules are usually two-year things. Yes, Avonworth knew football would be good. But did they know this good? Avonworth asked teams to move games. Some schools complied. Some could've said no. I saw West Allegheny played Avonworth this weekend. They apparently said no.

Wpial: What team is better: 2023 North Allegheny or 2025 PCC?

Mike White: I think we have to wait and see what happens Saturday night.

Marcus the great: I watched the new revamped lincoln park team. The rowan kid wasn't there? Did he transfer out?

Advertise with us

Mike White: Have no idea about a Rowan kid.

Pcc: PCC will have their hands full with lasalle. Lost the first matchup 23-6. 6 points simply won’t cut it with 3 “big time” o-linemen. Thoughts on the game?

Mike White: Of course, Central will have their hands full. La Salle is really good. So is Central. When they played the first time, it was first game for Central soph. QB Owen Herrick. He struggled big time. Was 8 of 30. Got sacked. Hung onto ball too long. He's improved greatly. But La Salle has seasoned QB in Gavin Sidwar. Missouri recruit. Thrown for over 8,000 yards. Also No. 1 player in state in WR-DB Joe O'Brien, going to Notre Dame. Keys are QB play, Central's secondary and Central better be able to run the ball with some success.

Wpial: Were you the guy who said that this years pine team would be the best wpial team in the past 10 years or was that some other numbskull

Mike White: I never said that.

Advertise with us

doug: Hey Mike. My question for you is why are 1a athletes so under looked. Ben hays ran for almost 2,000 yards and I have been told he has 0 college offers or interests. I understand it’s 1a ball but you can’t tell me a college program won’t even look at him for special teams?

Mike White: Pretty simple. Colleges apparently don't think they're good enough. Ben Hays could maybe get a spot at at D-3 program. He was really good player. But I'm sorry, you have to look at where he played. The Tri-County South isn't exactly the Allegheny Six of 5A.

X: Do you know how many tackles Spratt had against McDevitt? Peters hung tough. 180 yards in penalties against McDevitt played a big role. McDevitt's qb was very accurate. I didn't think Centeral Catholic was competitive with LaSalle when I saw them play early in the year. I think LaSalle has a tall receiver that is ranked the best player in the state, but they didn't really even have to target him much in that game. I've been to Central's last 2 games and they've improved a lot. Herrick can sling it but too bad he doesn't have the receiving talent they had the past 3 years...Gonzalez, Gompers, and Sullivan (that's Penn State, Duke, and Michigan now). How do you see the rematch playing out?

Mike White: See above post. I talk some about Central game and address some of your points. As for Spratt, I think he had over 20 again.

PGH basketball: Also when will the kdka release their basketball games of the week schedule?

Advertise with us

Mike White: Some time this week.

Games: what basketball games this week are most interesting to you?

Mike White: We don't have all the basketball tournament schedules yet for this weekend. But Friday night, Pine-Richland at Norwin isn't bad. Mohawk is No. 1-ranked in 3A. Playing at Central.

Whatup: Mike, did moon have a transfer in basketball? Was he from knock? Weren’t some moon people very upset about PR transfers in football?

Mike White: Ewwwwww. Inside jab.

Advertise with us

Coach T: As my name suggests I am a HS basketball coach. I want to vent here a bit but want your opinion. I wish kids took more pride in playing for their school instead of their social media. I hate to spoil it for these kids but no one is fooled by stuff you put online. Any the laughable "rankings" that are released on social media accounts aren't doing anything for you. Take over hoops, the content king, wpial insider, etc are hurting high school sports and they don't even realize it. They do it for clout and $. Not the kids.

Mike White: Yes, kids care a lot about social media. As for rankings, you see any Tom, Dick and Harry sometimes doing rankings right now. Hey, some are legit. Some just want to get in on this stuff. Who am I to rip on them? But naive parents and players believe so much what's on social media and don't have a clue.

X: Of the 3 wpial teams have, how do you rank them in order of chances of winning the state title? What do you think about Farrell vs Southern Columbia. Farrell has been dominant in the playoffs and played a tough team or two out of conference early in the season.

Mike White: I wouldn't rank them at all. They all have tough games. I think maybe Clairton has the best shot to win. As for Farrell and Southern Columbia, you do know Southern Columbia has been rolling also.

Mr Ed: No question, just wanted to say one of the most enjoyable parts to me of your coverage over the years are the video interviews you do with the players. The kids for the most part are still innocent, kinda naive, honest, and funny in their responses. Just the way teenagers are meant to be. Maybe that’s one of the reasons you have enjoyed doing this for so long, they keep you feeling young!

Advertise with us

Mike White: Thank you very much Mr. Ed. I love dealing with kids. Keeps you young. And I enjoy talking with them, even when I started in this business. But I'd say the same about coaches. Kids and relationships are the primary reason I coach some, too.

pops: PR has a target on their back from all of the transfers and the stuff their players put out on social media. Is it fair to say they are the closest thing we have a villain in high school football? I never remember so much hate towards a public school football team before.

Mike White: I have no idea about social media stuff that Pine-Richland says, or says about them. Don't really care, either, unless they're making a college choice.

Marcus the great: you have no idea about the rowan kid? You did stories about him transferring in last season from florida.

Mike White: Oh, OK. That kid. I have no idea if he's still with Lincoln Park or not.

Advertise with us

X: I think 2023 NA is better. Kushner was a dual threat qb...very good with his legs and Herrick doesn't run. Boyd is a better receiver than any that Central Catholic currently has. The NA kid on the dline that is at Richmond was pretty dominant

Mike White: We can debate. But Central has some pretty dang good players, too. Seriously, I don't know how you can make any kind of comparison until you see what Central does in the final game.

Joey: What other teams did you consider for the best of the past 25 years?

Mike White: Not long ago I ranked my top 10 teams from the past 25 years. Here's a link. https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/high-school-football/2025/09/25/to...

X: Wow, that's something for Spratt. I was at the game and it did seem like he had quite a few again. Chrys Black the last 2 weeks doesn't at all remember the Chrys Black in the first two games. He weaved gold out of straw quite a few times the past 2 weeks. That's not a knock on his line, but Black was just that good.

Advertise with us

Mike White: Black was hurt at the beginning of the year.

smitty: I saw KDKA post things on social media about hosting the game of the week again. Pretty nice event and idea. Will this continue after kdka boss man's kid graduates from PR? I saw he was the only one to get an individual post. I hope it continues but that stuff makes me doubt it will.

Mike White: I have no idea. I would hope so.

Dr. P: My son is obsessed with college basketball recruiting. Took him to the Allderdice Montour game to check out the sophomore with the Green Bay offer. My son would like to know, If he is a division 1 prospect, how is Rowan Carmichael not at Duke?

Mike White: You're talking about the Schachter kid. I'm not saying anything - and I think that says enough.

Advertise with us

Joey: Do you think central’s line has lived up to the hype considering they are all prospects?

Mike White: Look, recruiting is based a lot of potential. Those guys have all the measurables. If you notice, we didn't pick any of them to Fab 22. Not a knock on them. Good linemen. But maybe not dominant. Doesn't mean they aren't good. I'm not saying they didn't live up to the hype. I did a story on them because of their size. A lot of hype is created by college offers -- and not play on the field. But they have a year left to be dominant. And still a game this year.

Bart: What is the saddest story you had to write about a high school kid?

Mike White: John Challis - Freedom High School in 2008. Google him. He became a national story. I cried when I interviewed him. Went to his funeral and cried. Tom Rinaldi from ESPN sat right behind me.

5A: What are your thoughts on Penn Hills vs Moon on Friday

Advertise with us

Mike White: Good matchup. Some good guards going at it. I think maybe I like Penn Hills.

John: Have you seen or heard anything about Ambridge hoops?

Mike White: New coach. Daryn Freedman. He's been around. We shall see.

Schachter's agent: Don't be jealous. I am very good at my job. I get results and pay the right people for these "offers." I even might get GB-Wisc arena named after their dad.

Mike White: Here we go again. More Schachter stuff.

Anonymous: How many wins do you think The char valley girls will have this year they are a very young team???

Mike White: 30

Ryan: How will The Kiski cavaliers men’s and women’s Basketball Team Do this year GO Kiski also how will the mars fighting planets do also GO Mars

Mike White: Well it's boys and girls. Not men and women. Kiski boys should be pretty decent I think. I have no idea about the girls. Mars boys have some injuries to overcome but they could be pretty good still.

1A questions: Ben Hays is a legit college running back at some level, Guesman kid from JM last year is at Cal and Dehoet was really good at JM this year, Canevin apparently is good enough in 1A to have multiple D1 kids, Johnson from Cornell is a D1 kid and CH QB was really solid this year, Laurel has a ton of d2 and d3 kids on that roster, it's not just Sieg and Clairton kids but seems 1A might have more competition than 2A and some really good players, it's not the 1A football of 10-15 years ago?

Mike White: I never said Class 1A players couldn't make it in college. Heck, look at Tyler Boyd. I just mean just because you might put up big stats at a Class 1A school doesn't mean you are material that colleges are looking for.

X: Who has the best basketball team east of Monroeville in the wpial?

Mike White: On their own level, Jeannette. All five starters back from WPIAL championship team.

1a answers: He obviously not good enough to get the d1 looks you are claiming he deserves. 1a players sometimes get overlooked but most of the time their success is a product of lower competition. Facts

Mike White: Very true.

1A questions: Sorry Mike my question was is 1A better now than it was 10-15 years ago, seems with coops and Catholic school situations there are much better players top to bottoms in 1A now than ever before?

Mike White: No, I definitely would not say that. More smaller schools have smaller rosters. Definitely wouldn't say it's better. I would say the gap between good teams and not-good teams is wider.

Mike White: Well, that's about it for today. Gotta finish a little shoveling and then have some of the great Mrs. White's turkey cream soup that is waiting. Talk to y'all next Tuesday at 11.