One in an occasional series on top players, athletes, teams, coaches and games in WPIAL sports since 2000.
An unforgettable play that the team called “Our Father.” A controversial penalty on the final play of regulation. Overtime games. A battle of running backs. The highest-scoring title game in WPIAL history. A game played with snow falling.
Those are just some of the happenings in great WPIAL football championship games in the 2000s.
Most of the WPIAL championship games in the 2000s have been played at Acrisure Stadium (formerly Heinz Field), but some have also been played at high school stadiums. Four more championships will be played Saturday at Acrisure, but this century already has had some classics. Five title games have gone to overtime since 2000 and others have been memorable.
It’s not easy to pick the best championship games, but here’s one guy’s list of the top 10 since 2000:
1. 2007 — Central Catholic 35, Gateway 34 (OT)
Read More
There is the “Hail Mary” pass in football. Well, the Gateway Gators had an unforgettable play they called “Our Father,” and it tied the game with one second remaining.
Central Catholic took a 28-13 lead with only 1:02 left, but Gateway made a terrific comeback. Gateway scored with 31 seconds left, recovered an onside kick and had the ball at the Central Catholic 29 with only nine seconds on the clock after a timeout. That’s when Gateway coach Terry Smith called for the “Our Father,” and the Gators pulled off the hook-and-lateral trick play to perfection. Quarterback Rob Kalkstein threw a pass over the middle to Jonathan Pryor, who caught the ball at the 12. He quickly pitched a lateral to Cam Saddler, who ran into the end zone with one tick left. Gateway needed a two-point conversion to tie and got it when Steve Horvath caught a pass from Kalkstein to knot the score at 28.
In high school overtimes, each team gets a possession from the 10-yard line. Leon Green scored on Gateway’s possession, but the Gators had trouble with the extra-point snap and Ryan Lichtenstein’s kick never made it over the line. Central Catholic’s Tino Sunseri scored on a 1-yard QB snea,k and Matt Oczypok kicked the winning extra point.
“They’re already saying this is one of the greatest games in WPIAL history,” Central Catholic coach Terry Totten said after the contest.

2. 2016 — West Allegheny 38, McKeesport 37 (OT)
This game had a controversial penalty on what would’ve been the final play of regulation. Trailing 30-27, West Allegheny’s D.J. Opsatnik had a 50-yard field goal come up short on the last play. But McKeesport was called for roughing-the-kicker and Opsatnik, who had made 32 field goals in his career, then converted a 34-yarder to send the game into overtime.
Ray Zellars scored on a 1-yard run for McKeesport in overtime and Caleb Schork kicked the extra point. Will Weber scored on a 2-yard run for West Allegheny to make it 37-36. Coach Bob Palko elected to go for two and Nick Ross ran for the winning conversion.

3. 2015 — Aliquippa 44, South Fayette 38
Aliquippa won the game by converting a double pass for a touchdown with 1:11 remaining. Quarterback Sheldon Jeter threw a backward pass to Jassir Jordan, who then lofted a pass downfield that 5-foot-7 Thomas Perry hauled in for the winning touchdown to snap South Fayette’s 44-game winning streak. South Fayette quarterback Drew Saxton set a WPIAL championship game record by throwing for 435 yards. Aliquippa’s Kaezon Pugh ran for 179.
“That’s about as good of a football game as I’ve ever been in,” said Mike Zmijanac, Aliquippa’s longtime coach.
4. 2009 — West Allegheny 36, Hopewell 28
This game was memorable because of the performances by running backs Mike Caputo of West Allegheny and Rushel Shell of Hopewell. Caputo, a junior, ran for 178 yards and carried the ball 21 times in the first half alone. Shell, a sophomore who is still the WPIAL’s all-time leading rusher for a career, ran for 274 yards, the most ever in a title game at Acrisure or Three Rivers Stadium.

5. 2023 — North Allegheny 44, Central Catholic 41
This contest at Norwin was the highest-scoring championship in WPIAL history. The first half had five lead changes alone. North Allegheny lost to Central Catholic by 28 points in the regular season, but quarterback Logan Kushner helped the Tigers turn the tables on Central. Kushner ran for 240 yards on 25 attempts, and it was the most yards rushing for a quarterback in any title game since at least the early 1980s. The win gave Art Walker his seventh WPIAL title.

6. 2013 — South Fayette 34, Aliquippa 28
On a Heinz Field surface that had a dusting of snow, junior quarterback Brett Brumbaugh threw for 315 yards in South Fayette’s win. Justin Watson, an NFL receiver today, caught six passes for 130 yards. The winning touchdown was controversial. Trailing 28-27 and with the ball at the Aliquippa 19, Brumbaugh threw a pass to Conner Beck, who raced downfield and dived while trying to reach the ball over the goal line. Aliquippa’s Dravon Henry hit Beck, causing a fumble that Aliquippa recovered. But officials ruled Beck already had the ball over the goal line when he fumbled.

7. 2021 — Penn-Trafford 24, Moon 21
Snow flurries fell through most of the game. And with Penn-Trafford in green uniforms and Moon in red, it made for a Christmas card-type setting. Penn-Trafford won its first championship in school history when Moon missed a 33-yard field goal with 2 seconds remaining in the game. Penn-Trafford’s Cade Yacamelli ran for 136 yards on 17 carries, scored two touchdowns and had seven tackles.

8. 2024 — Fort Cherry 21, Clairton 20
This game will always be remembered for Matt Sieg’s play for the winning touchdown. Trailing 20-14 in the fourth quarter and facing a 4th-and-5 from the Clairton 13, Fort Cherry’s terrific quarterback took the snap, faked a handoff and ran to his left for a handoff to Shane Cornali. But a few Clairton defenders were suddenly in Sieg’s face, so he turned to his right, took a few steps backward and threw a TD pass to a wide open Ryan Huey. Nik Massey kicked the go-ahead extra point with 4:56 left.

9. 2020 –—Thomas Jefferson 35, Aliquippa 28 (OT)
Aliquippa scored twice in the final six minutes to tie the game, 28-28, after regulation at North Allegheny. In overtime, Thomas Jefferson’s Jake Pugh scored on a 2-yard QB sneak. On the third play of Aliquippa’s overtime possession, Thomas Jefferson’s McClain Finn intercepted a pass in the end zone to give coach Bill Cherpak his ninth WPIAL championship. Pugh threw for two touchdowns and ran for two in the game.

10. 2019 — Central Valley 13, Aliquippa 12 (OT)
If you like hard-hitting defense and close games, then this one was a classic. The game was tied, 7-7, after regulation. In overtime, Central Valley’s Michael Barbuto scored on a 10-yard run on the first play, and Ethan Ott kicked the extra point. Aliquippa’s Isaiah Towler scored on an 11-yard run, and coach Mike Warfield then tried for the win. But Barbuto tackled Towler short of the end zone on the two-point conversion run.

JUST SAYIN’
• The finalists for the seventh annual Bill Fralic Memorial Award are North Allegheny’s Lincoln Hoke, Gateway’s Roberson Louis-Jeune, New Castle’s Jayden Shaffer, Derry’s Dylan Pitzer, Apollo-Ridge’s Connor Bogdanski and Clairton’s Avaughn Pompey. The award is named after the legendary former Penn Hills High School, Pitt and NFL offensive lineman and goes to the top senior interior lineman in the WPIAL. A committee selects one lineman from each classification as finalists. The bet here is that the award goes to Hoke, a Pitt recruit who has been excellent the past two seasons.
• Many have been wondering and asking. Yes, the four WPIAL football championships Saturday at Acrisure Stadium will be televised live on KDKA+.
• It will be interesting to see attendance for the four title games at Acrisure. The weather looks pretty good, but like many years, there are a few teams in the championships that don’t bring many fans. Attendance last year was only 10,763, the second-smallest crowd ever for four games at either Acrisure or Three Rivers Stadium. Total attendance for the two title games (4A and 6A) at Pine-Richland last Saturday was 4,970. That total is surprising because the McKeesport-Aliquippa game looked almost filled.
• Basketball season is just around the corner. In the WPIAL, one boy and two girls are back after making the Post-Gazette Fabulous 5 teams last year, and all three are signed or committed to Division I schools. Lincoln Park’s Josh Pratt, who transferred from Aliquippa, is headed to Columbia of the Ivy League. Greensburg Central Catholic’s Erica Gribble signed last week with Richmond and Shady Side Academy’s Karis Thomas signed with Purdue-Fort Wayne.

A HOCKEY-FOOTBALL STORY
Peters Township’s Cole Neupaver is one of the more interesting stories of the WPIAL football playoffs. Only two years ago, he left Peters Township and thought his future was in hockey. He didn’t even play football from eighth grade through his sophomore year. As a sophomore, Neupaver attended North Catholic and played for the Pens Elite travel hockey team out of Cranberry. But Neupaver (5-foot-10, 185 pounds) came back to Peters Township and football last year as a junior, saw some playing time and now has rushed for 1,314 yards heading into the WPIAL championship. Some Division III colleges are interested. “I saw the success the football team was having, and I still loved football,” Neupaver said. “I was pretty big into hockey, but I just didn’t see a future in it for me. I decided to come back on the football field, and it’s one of the best decisions I’ve ever made in my life.”
DATA WAY
3 — Times that the same teams have met in a WPIAL football championship for three consecutive years. The first was Aliquippa vs. South Fayette from 2013-15. Central Catholic and North Allegheny played in the 6A title game last week for the fourth consecutive year. Peters Township and Pine-Richland will play Saturday in the 5A championship for the third year in a row.

REMEMBERING WHEN
Fifty-five years ago, Mt. Lebanon, under coach Art Walker, won the first WPIAL championship at Three Rivers Stadium when it defeated Kiski Area, 35-12. Thirty years later in 2000, Mt. Lebanon won the final WPIAL championship at Three Rivers when the Blue Devils, coached by Chris Haering, beat Woodland Hills, 14-13. A botched extra point by Woodland Hills with 39 seconds left was the difference in the game. Walker went on to win five more championships, four at Mt. Lebanon and one at Shady Side Academy.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and @mwhiteburgh on X.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.