Scott Seltzer doesn’t know what comes next in his life, but he is sure about one thing.
He is stepping down as the WPIAL executive director effective Dec. 20. Seltzer submitted his resignation to the WPIAL board of directors at its monthly meeting on Tuesday, and it was accepted.
“I decided to retire. It’s time. I was talking with my wife, and we decided that it was a good time to go now,” Seltzer, 58, said. “I was very humbled to be able to sit in the same seat as Tim O’Malley. I sort of hope that people remember me as someone who was helpful, gave them my honest opinion and didn’t lie to them.”
Seltzer took over as the executive director on July 1, 2022, when his predecessor, Amy Scheuneman, stepped down to take a position as the youth programming director at P3R, an area race organizer that oversees such events as the Pittsburgh Marathon and the upcoming EQT 10 Miler. At the time of his hire, Seltzer was the assistant superintendent at Chartiers Valley, served as the WPIAL president for six years and was on the WPIAL board of directors for 13 years.
Seltzer, who lives in New Castle, will be replaced by the current chief operating officer of the WPIAL, Vince Sortino, who was initially brought into the WPIAL as assistant to the executive director under Scheuneman.
Sortino is a Seton LaSalle alumnus who played football on two WPIAL championship teams in 1979 and 1980 under Tom Donahoe, who went on to become the Steelers general manager. Sortino is also the former athletic director at Baldwin and ran all postseason tournaments, chose sites, organized playoff games and helped evaluate officials in his three-plus years in the position.
Read More
“My goal is to try to make the league in a little better place than when I came in and when I started, and I think that’s everyone’s goal when they start a position or a job,” Sortino said. “I get an opportunity to try to shape and mold the product on a much larger scale and hopefully be a good mentor/resource for younger athletic directors and administrators.”
With Seltzer leaving, the onus will be on Sortino, longtime finance director Diana Rossmann and newly hired assistant to the executive director Matt Manz, who replaced communications director Ethan Woy, to keep things moving forward.
“I think we had the league going in a positive direction as a team,” Seltzer said. “I thought it was a pretty good team effort with Vince and Diana and Ethan and now with Matt.”
Sortino was tabbed immediately after the WPIAL accepted Seltzer’s resignation. But that didn’t change the fact the board was reticent to see him depart.
“Scott’s been a part of the league for a decade-plus and definitely put a lot of time, effort and energy into the league, and we’re definitely appreciative of that,” WPIAL board president Brian Geyer said. “We didn’t see that one coming at the start of the school year. Hopefully the league doesn’t miss a beat and we can continue to improve and do the things we need to do for our member schools.”
Though Seltzer opting to step aside came as something of a surprise to the board, it wasn’t to those who worked with him on a day-to-day basis.
“I’ve known for a while. I talk to Scott all the time, so I know what his plans were, but I was caught a little off guard when he chose to retire,” Sortino said. “That hour here and an hour back drive for 20 years, I don’t know how he did it.”
Sortino plans to retain many of his current duties, including the one he’s doing currently, which is helping to organize the fall playoffs by working with schools that act as neutral sites and arranging for officials. He also plans to take on most of Seltzer’s duties but also hire someone who would handle some of his current duties with non-revenue-generating sports like golf, field hockey and cross country.
“The job title is going to be the same, but the job description is going to be a little different,” Sortino said. “I see the job shared more in the office. I will be more actively involved still in what I do now, but new people coming on will share in those responsibilities.”
Seltzer’s resignation comes less than two weeks after longtime PIAA executive director Bob Lombardi announced he would be retiring from his post at the end of the year, with Mark Byers taking over his role in 2026.
What comes next for Seltzer, though, remains unclear.
“I don’t know. I might fill in. If anyone needs an administrator to fill in or sub for them, I might do that,” Seltzer said. “I haven’t really put a whole lot of thought into what’s next.”
He’ll still have a few more of those 70-minute drives to and from New Castle to figure that out.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.