A pair of PIAA medalists have been sidelined for the 2024-25 high school wrestling season, which begins Friday.

Pine-Richland senior Vaughn Spencer and Derry junior Dylan Pitzer are out for the season for different reasons.

Spencer, a two-time WPIAL Class 3A champion and one-time PIAA champ, is expected to miss his senior season while recovering from another knee injury.

Spencer missed his freshman season with shoulder and knee injuries, along with concussion complications. He returned a month into his sophomore season and won a WPIAL title while competing at 189 pounds but suffered another knee injury during the PIAA tournament.

Advertise with us

Last season, he came back and competed at 172 pounds and won WPIAL and PIAA titles but suffered yet another knee injury in the semifinals. In August, Spencer underwent ACL reconstruction surgery and will not be wrestling this season.

“The doctor told us that Vaughn’s recovery time is six to nine months,” said Brad Spencer, Vaughn’s father. “With that in mind, he will not be wrestling this season.”

Pine-Richland’s Vaughn Spencer, top, won a state championship last season, but will miss his senior season because of a knee injury. (Ken Wunderley / Tri-State Sports & News Service)

In his two seasons at Pine-Richland, Spencer had a 71-4 career record. He plans to wrestle at Lehigh University.

“The coaches at Lehigh have been great about Vaughn’s surgery,” said Brad Spencer. “They want him to be healthy when he gets to Lehigh.”

Pitzer is not wrestling this season for a much different reason. A junior, Pitzer wrestled the last two seasons at Mount Pleasant but transferred to Derry during the summer.

Advertise with us

The WPIAL ruled him ineligible, claiming the transfer was at least partially for athletic intent, which is against WPIAL and PIAA rules. The Pitzer family appealed the decision to the PIAA, and the PIAA upheld the WPIAL’s ruling, making Pitzer ineligible for the 2024-25 season.

“Dylan is a very talented wrestler,” Derry coach Troy Dolan said. “It’s unfortunate that he can’t wrestle for us this season. It’s not the outcome we had hoped for, but we will push forward and welcome Dylan back for his senior year.”

Pitzer placed second in the WPIAL Class 2A tournament last year at heavyweight. He also finished fourth in the PIAA and has a two-year record of 79-16.

Spencer and Pitzer may be out of the picture, but there are still 20 wrestlers returning in the WPIAL who have placed at least once at the PIAA tournament.

Latrobe is the only team that has three returning PIAA medalists. Luke Willochell, Leo Joseph and Hunter Snyder all placed at last year’s state tournament.

Advertise with us

“Having three PIAA medalists back speaks well for our program,” Latrobe coach Mark Mears said. “It shows the talent and depth of our program.”

In fact, Willochell is one of only two WPIAL wrestlers who are three-time PIAA medalists. The other is Thomas Jefferson’s Maddox Shaw. Willochell is also a three-time WPIAL champion. Only 32 wrestlers in WPIAL history have won four titles.

Below is a look at the WPIAL’s 20 returning PIAA medalists. Fifteen are from Class 3A.

Norwin’s Landon Sidun, top, last season became the 21st wrestler from the WPIAL to win a state title as a freshman. (Ken Wunderley / Tri-State Sports & News Service)

Class 3A

Jake Conroy, Ringgold (Sr., 43-4, 117-16):  Conroy became the first Ringgold wrestler to win a WPIAL title with his 5-1 win in the 215-pound final against North Allegheny’s Aidan Buggey. He went on to place fourth at the state tournament.

Nico Fanella, Indiana (Sr., 41-5, 108-14): Fanella, a Brown University recruit, is back in Class 3A after the Little Indians spent the last two years in Class 2A. He was a WPIAL runner-up at 106 in 3A as a freshman. In Class 2A, he was a two-time WPIAL finalist and one-time champ, and a two-time PIAA medalist, fourth at 114 as a sophomore and third at 127 last year.

Advertise with us

Mark Gray, Kiski Area (Sr., 9-4, 69-20): Gray placed third in the WPIAL and seventh in the PIAA last season as a 172-pound sophomore. He missed most of last season with an injury but returned to place fifth in the WPIAL at 172 pounds, just falling short of a PIAA berth.

Ramil Islamov, Baldwin (Sr., 40-5, 100-21): Islamov became the third Baldwin wrestler, and first since 2005, to place at the PIAA tournament when he finished fourth at 133 pounds. He also placed third in the WPIAL in Class 3A.

Leo Joseph, Latrobe (Sr., 37-11, 101-33): Joseph is a three-year starter who placed third in the WPIAL and eighth in the PIAA while competing at 114 pounds. He finished eighth in the WPIAL as a sophomore.

Bode Marlow, Thomas Jefferson (Sr., 39-7, 112-27): Marlow, a Pitt recruit, is a three-year starter and two-time PIAA Class 3A qualifier. Last season, he won a WPIAL title and placed third in the state at 160 pounds. He placed third in the WPIAL as a 152-pound sophomore.

Nicholas McGarrity, Peters Township (Soph., 43-4): McGarrity won the WPIAL Class 3A title at 107 pounds last season as a freshman. He also placed sixth at the PIAA tournament.

Advertise with us

Evan Petrovich, Connellsville (Sr., 41-7, 110-27): Petrovich, a Pitt recruit, is a three-year starter who won a WPIAL Class 3A title and placed third in the PIAA last year as a 145-pound junior. He placed fifth in the WPIAL his first two years.

Cooper Roscosky, Kiski Area (Jr., 40-5, 72-15): Claimed the WPIAL Class 3A title at 189 pounds last season and then placed sixth at the state tournament. He placed sixth in the WPIAL as a freshman at the same weight.

Maddox Shaw, Thomas Jefferson (Sr., 43-3, 128-12): Shaw is a three-time WPIAL finalist and two-time champion. He is also a three-time PIAA medalist, third as a 126-pound freshman, second as a 133-pound sophomore and first as a 139-pound junior.

Landon Sidun, Norwin (Soph., 42-2): Last season, Sidun became the 21st WPIAL wrestler to win a PIAA title as a freshman and the first since Frazier’s Rune Lawrence won in 2021. He also placed second in the WPIAL in his debut.

Santino Sloboda, Butler (Jr., 38-3, 78-6): Sloboda, a Pitt recruit, is a two-time WPIAL finalist and champ last season. He is also a two-time PIAA medalist, fourth as a 107-pound freshman and sixth last season at the same weight.

Advertise with us

Hunter Snyder, Latrobe (Soph., 38-8): Snyder had an impressive debut as a 172-pound freshman for the Wildcats. He placed second in the WPIAL and sixth in the PIAA in Class 3A.

Lonzy Vielma, Connellsville (Sr., 39-9, 111-34): Vielma is a three-time PIAA Class 3A qualifier who placed fifth last year at 160 pounds. He is also a three-time WPIAL top-four finisher: third as a 138-pound freshman, fourth as a 139-pound sophomore and second as a 160-pound junior.

Luke Willochell, Latrobe (Sr., 41-3, 121-12): Willochell is a three-time WPIAL champ at 106 as a freshman, 114 as a sophomore and last season at 121. He is also a three-time PIAA medalist, second as a freshman, fifth as a sophomore and fifth last season.

Derry’s Mason Horwat, top, is back after winning a WPIAL championship as a freshman. (Ken Wunderley / Tri-State Sports & News Service)

Class 2A

With Pitzer ineligible and Indiana’s Fanella moving up to Class 3A, there are only five WPIAL Class 2A wrestlers who have previously placed in the PIAA tournament. None are returning champions, and none finished higher than fourth at Hershey.

Jackson Angelo, Frazier (Jr., 39-10, 72-18): Angelo is a two-year starter who placed third in the WPIAL as a 160-pound freshman. He moved to 189 last season and placed third in the WPIAL, third in the Southwest Region, and fifth in the PIAA.

Advertise with us

Cameron Baker, Burrell (Jr., 44-7, 85-18): Baker is a two-time PIAA medalist at 107. He placed second in the WPIAL, second in the Southwest Region, and fourth in the PIAA. Last season, he placed first in the WPIAL, third in the region, and sixth in the PIAA.

Antonio Boni, Central Valley (Jr., 35-4, 69-17): Boni won a WPIAL title, placed third in the Southwest Region and sixth in the PIAA as a 107-pound freshman. Last season, he competed at 121 and won a second WPIAL title. He also placed fourth in the region, then fell one win short of placing at Hershey.

Mason Horwat, Derry (Soph., 38-7): Horwat made his varsity debut as a 145-pound freshman. He won a WPIAL title, placed third in the Southwest Region and finished fifth at Hershey.

Braedon Welsh, Fort Cherry (Sr., 40-9, 114-27): Welsh, a Brown University recruit, is a three-time PIAA qualifier and two-time medalist who placed fifth at 172 last year. He is a two-time WPIAL finalist who placed first as a sophomore and second as a junior.