A few years from now, Drew Lafferty and Luke Guth could be mound opponents in an SEC game.

Their first ever meeting came in a PIAA playoff game Monday, and the outcome saw the Vandy Boy outduel the teen who will soon be part of Big Blue Nation.

In a battle of aces, Guth and Franklin trumped Lafferty and South Park, as Guth’s outstanding performance helped Franklin defeat the WPIAL champion Eagles, 3-0, in a Class 3A first-round game at Seneca Valley.

South Park (18-6), which beat Mohawk, 11-1, for the WPIAL title last Wednesday, saw its season end with a PIAA first-round loss for the second year in a row. District 10 runner-up Franklin (15-7) advanced to play the Punxsutawney in Thursday’s quarterfinals.

Advertise with us

Guth, a junior who has verbally committed to Vanderbilt, was masterful, firing a two-hitter with 16 strikeouts and two walks. Using a fastball that his coach said has topped out in the low 90s and a filthy slider, Guth made South Park hitters uncomfortable throughout. He struck out the side three times, including the final inning. South Park’s only hits came on Lafferty’s single in the first and Zach Ludwig’s single in the fifth.

“We haven’t really seen a pitcher all year that was throwing with the velocity that he was, and mixing it with that hard breaking slider,” Lafferty said. “He threw with good velocity downhill, and we just couldn’t get to him.”

Guth’s 16 strikeouts weren’t even a season high. He’s struck out 19 in two games and 18 in another. Guth has now fanned 129 in 54 innings this season.

“It’s kind of crazy. They’re video game numbers,” Franklin coach Brian Schmidt said.

Guth had to be on his game in order to outduel South Park’s ace. Lafferty is a senior and Kentucky recruit who pitched well enough to win Monday. He gave up only four hits before being lifted with one out in the seventh after reaching the pitch limit. Lafferty struck out nine, but it was his shaky top of the second that produced the only run Franklin would need.

Advertise with us

Franklin loaded the bases with one out courtesy of two walks and a bloop single. Lafferty then plunked No. 9 hitter Ethan Nightingale, allowing Aidan McCracken to score.

“I told the guys before the game even started, ‘This is going to be a 1-0 game,’” said Lafferty. “‘We’re not going to be smacking the ball around the park like we did against Mohawk. We need to settle in and manufacture runs any way we can.’ My control got away from me a little bit in the second inning. That was the difference in this one.”

As dominant as Guth was, South Park had some chances to score. The Eagles put the tying run on second with two outs in both the fifth and sixth innings. Dylan Wilder put a drive into a Guth pitch in the fifth, but center fielder Carson Wible ran it down to end the inning. Guth then struck out Luke Rider swinging to end the sixth.

Chances are the one run would have been good enough with Guth on the mound, but Franklin didn’t want to leave it up to chance. Wible smacked a two-run double off of reliever Austin Lafferty (Drew’s cousin) with two outs in the top of the seventh to increase the lead to 3-0.

“Going into that last inning, we had an opportunity,” South Park coach Brad Shamitko said. “And obviously when they got those two insurance runs in the top of the seventh, that sort of changed things a little bit. We still feel that we could have got three runs on him in the last inning if things turn out a different way.”

Advertise with us

Connor Klingensmith led off the bottom of the seventh with a walk, but Guth struck out Dylan Orth, Ludwig and Ryan Bywalski to end the game.

Round 1 might have gone to the Vanderbilt recruit, but Lafferty said he is looking forward to potentially getting the chance to pitch against Guth again in a few years.

“That will be a great rematch there,” said Lafferty.

And Lafferty said he won’t forget how the first one turned out.

“Oh yeah,” Lafferty said, laughing. “I’ll hold it against him.”

Brad Everett: beverett@post-gazette.com and Twitter: @BREAL412.