Mike White: Well, the NCAA tournament is in Pittsburgh this weekend - but the "Elite Eights" are here for high school basketball in the state playoffs. Great time if you love basketball, right? Too bad all of our local D-1 colleges are all down. Would add some more excitement. Oh well, let's get chat going. Now open for questions.
Let's Go!: Who determines what districts get to ref these big state playoff games. It seems like interpretation of the block/charge call varies greatly around the state and that could really swing some games.
Mike White: Honestly I'm not sure how it's done. Obviously, it two teams from same district, then officials will come from that district. Two different districts? Not sure how officials are picked.
Bob: Why is hockey not a WPIAL sport?
Mike White: Because the WPIAL and PIAA have not wanted to sponsor it and there is no push from the schools to have WPIAL and PIAA sponsor it. Why? One is money. Hockey is dang expensive, with ice time, equipment, etc. Some school athletic budgets have been cut. Adding another sport with high cost would not be good. Also, hockey would have to follow PIAA rules in terms of classifying teams, etc. Not sure if hockey wants to do that.
Bill: Who do you see winning and what are the keys to the Canevin Imani game tonight?
Read More
Mike White: Imani has all that size, but will that matter? I think Imani gives them a game, but Canevin wins.
Fairview Forever: Read some of your stuff about Quaker Valley. How do you stop them (asking for a friend)?
Mike White: Hope Adou Thiero and Markus Frank have off nights. One of best one-two scoring punches in high school WPIAL history. But they have faced triangle and twos and they still score. And if you let other guys open, look what can happen: Jack Gardinier goes nuts last week and scores 36 vs. Belle Vernon.
Andy: How do you see the Penn Hills New Castle game going? Personally I think New Castle the favorite but you definitely can’t count out Chris Giles team and I think Penn Hills has something to prove after their QuarterFinal loss.
Mike White: Penn Hills has gotten hot in WPIAL playoffs. Penn Hills has height advantage. They have to hope to win rebounding battle. Penn Hills defense against the 3 and New Castle's offensive sets also are key. And New Castle will defend you. Plus, New Castle's 3-point shooting is also key. If Wells and Boice are making 3's, Penn Hills has problems.
Randy: Who do you see going to Hershey in 3a from the west side of the bracket?
Mike White: Well, we are guaranteed a 5A team. Four quarterfinalists in boys are all from WPIAL - New Castle, Gateway, Penn Hills, Laurel Highlands. I think OLSH makes it and Canevin has a good chance.
WPIAL Basketball Fan: Do you think Laurel Highlands will go all the way and win the state championship. I personally think they can but they gotta clean it up a bit, in the WPIAL Championship game 4th Quarter tie game 27 seconds left and 4 timeouts, instead of using their timeouts they force a stupid shot with Rodney and set New Castle for the win. Than with about 8 seconds left in the 1st overtime LH is up 3 and they let New Castle shoot the game tying 3 instead of fouling and putting New Castle on the line. Plus LH also had a scare from Highlands last round. I get their undefeated and I want them to go all the way, Rodney is a great kid and Laurel Highlands is a great area with great fans and they deserve a state championship but I don’t see them winning it. Unfortunately I think the mistakes will catch up with them.
Mike White: Hey, let's remember Laurel Highlands wasn't exactly playing Cupcake High. You're talking about games with New Castle and Highlands. Those two teams are very good. No shame having close games with them. Yes, things could've been better down stretch, but ... they still won.
Dunks: Do you see Quaker Valley winning a boy hoops state championship? Why or Why not?
Mike White: It wouldn't surprise me if they won it. It wouldn't surprise me if they lost in final or maybe not even get there. Hey, there are really good teams left. I'm telling you Fairview is good. Then there is winner of Montour and Archbishop Carroll. Carroll is good. Always tough Neumann-Goretti is on other side. The road is filled with top teams.
WPIAL Fan: Do you think there should be changes with how high school hockey polices the stands. I mean they let a fight happen at a Shaler game and there’s been instances of student section members cussing out parents, security did not stop these situations. Maybe instead of worrying about throwing people out who tap the glass they should be worried about the fighting that’s going on in the stands.
Mike White: One of the problems is that since it's not school sponsored, there is no school security personnel there or a principal or AD usually. It's just security from the rink. Not the same. That's part of the problem.
Moon Tigers Fan: What’s you’re thoughts on who would win a potential state semifinal match in 5a Girls Basketball between Chartiers Valley and Moon?
Mike White: I'll take Char Valley in a closer one. But they have to both win in quarters.
Spalding: Mike--it really feels like Butler football proposed a fair agreement to play D10 for two years and then return to the WPIAL, especially considering schedules are finalized. What do you think is the rationale behind the WPIAL's decision?
Mike White: Well, let's set up the story for those who don't know. Butler left WPIAL in football only because their program is horrible and can't compete. Joined District 10 for football only as associate member. Then suddenly they're eligible for District 10 playoffs and play for a shot at state playoffs. So you tell me if that makes sense? A team can't compete where they belong -- and every other sports team at school plays. So they go play in a district that has only two other 6A teams and they can maybe make state playoffs from there. Do you think that's fair? I don't. You can't have your cake and eat it, too. I don't believe with Butler.
Mike White: About earlier thing with Butler. Let's say Pitt basketball says, "We're having trouble competing in ACC. So we are going to leave ACC for hoops only. But let our other teams in ACC. And we are going to play four teams from the NEC where it's much easier. And we win that mini league, we go to the NCAA playoffs." You think that would be fair?
Money: Who do you see winning state in 6a boys basketball
Mike White: A team from the east.
Constitution: Who’s the biggest threat at stopping OLSH?
Mike White: Portage or Constitution. Constitution played OLSH in final last year.
Todd: 7 out of 8 remaining teams in single a boys are non boundary schools. Seems a little disproportionate. Congratulations to coach Stanley and the Union Scotties for being public school champions.
Mike White: What else is new.
LeboKid: Good morning, Mike. Despite the fact that the WPIAL won 7 AAA titles, and had 34 wrestlers earn top-8 medals, the PIAA has put forth a plan to eliminate one WPIAL qualifier (down to three from four per weight class) for the state tournament. Do you know where this proposal stands, and what recourse does the WPIAL have to ensure that this doesn't go through? It's ridiculous that District 3 (South Central PA) picks up an extra qualifier. Results matter! Thanks, Mike.
Mike White: Sorry, I not know where this proposal stands. I will have to check with our wrestling writer Ken "Stats" Wunderley - or Bruno Sammartino.
Rodrick: South Allegheny making it much further in states?
Mike White: Well they play Bishop Guilfoyle. BG is always pretty good. South Allegheny will have hands full. But could win. Then they play either Aliquippa or Avonworth.
Leader of Pack: After what transpired in boys 5A this year, is it time for the WPIAL to re-evaluate “follow the leader” as method to send teams to PIAA playoffs? Shouldn’t WPIAL goal be to send the best seven teams to represent District 7 in states? If New Castle had won WPIAL final, state quarter finalist Penn Hills would have never gotten its chance.
Mike White: Yep, I don't like follow the leader system, either. But the WPIAL seems set against having playbacks. They did it a few years ago, but got rid of it. I don't see them coming back.
Coach O: If I could stick a football note in here; last week you mentioned Belle Vernon’s non conference schedule and it sure is a doozy. On the flip side, could you see them being the new Central Valley in 3A? Looking over the newly reorganized classification, very few strong teams. Quinton Martin could be a runaway train this year.
Mike White: Despite a tough non-league schedule, Belle Vernon could be really good in 3A. Might be No. 1 team going in, even though they lost a lot.
DanFortsonFan: Any early predictions on the 6A games this week with North Hills and FC?
Mike White: Archbishop Wood is really good. They had defending state champ Reading by 25 on Sunday. Point guard going to Drexel. Other good players. Will take a monumental effort from North Hills. Fox Chapel plays those Konkrete Kids from Northampton. Those kids are hard to crack. ..... Wooooo hoooooo. I'll be here all week.
Bob the Builder: Heard on the podcast you or brad only have 4 boys team so 6a misses and what was your other
Mike White: I don't think I named the classes. I think we only have 3-4 make it.
Tyus Edny: Who is your pick for 6a coach of the year? Gabos or Skrinjer?
Mike White: I think you have to wait to see how it plays out. And I don't think we pick coaches of the year by class.
Notre Dame to the Big Ten: Butler has been banned from the district 10 playoffs because they are technically a member of district 7. If they want to be playoff eligible could they elect to return to the WPIAL and play in their home district? I thought the goal was to rebuild the program. If you are fighting to be playoff eligible, then your program is rebuilt and ready to return to full competition.
Mike White: I addressed this situation above.
Bob the Builder: Who’s got a better chance of winning NH or FC. have to say FC even though they’re playing a soft opponent while North Hills is prolly playing the top team in the state. That Reading Wood game was game of the year I heard
Mike White: I haven't seen film on Northampton. Obviously, they're good. I've seen film on Wood. I have a hard time believing Northampton is better than Wood.
Ice Castle Melting: Do you think fighting in the stands and poor security is one of the reasons that hockey is not sponsored by the WPIAL?
Mike White: No. Money is.
WPIAL Basketball Fan: How about the bang-up job Brian Batko did covering that game on Saturday? Might be time to give that guy a raise, or at least a guest appearance on the podcast
Mike White: There was Hoops Weiss, legendary basketball writer in Philly. Then there's Basket-case Batko, another legend. As for a guest on podcast? We are like Kennywood. You have to be over a certain height to get a ride on Varsity Xtra Podcast. Taller than 5-foot-4. Brian doesn't make the cut.
Bob the Builder: Do you know what wpial schools in basketball could be forced to move up?
Mike White: I can only tell you boys right now. I would have to check again on girls. By making quarterfinals, OLSH will move up to 3A next year. They have the required six success points and at least one transfer the past two years. Canevin already is bumped up to 2A because of enrollment. So even if they would go to state final and have required 6 success points, they wouldn't be bumped up further than 2A. If New Castle makes 5A state finals, they will be bumped to 6A.
John: Can Gateway beat Laurel Highlands tonight? What are there chances???
Mike White: No chance. Gateway has forfeited. ... Of course they have a chance. Need to shoot the ball well, hope Laurel Highlands doesn't shoot it well. Gateway must also get on glass and use their size to win rebounding battle.
Plop: I have been following North Hills basketball this year. I watched their game over the weekend. It seemed like it was officiated much differently than many of their other games in the playoffs. Did it benefit them playing away from Pittsburgh?
Mike White: The second round game Sunday was pretty clean game. Clutching and grabbing was called. Some officials call it differently than others. That's the way it goes.
SingleA: Hey Mike. Great work, as usual. Always enjoy this chat. Thanks for doing it. The Ellwood vs. Avonworth game came down to one thing; poise. I was so impressed with how Avonworth handled situations, and Ellwood got Ts and kicked chairs and looked rattled. It matters!!
Mike White: I didn't see any of the game. But I do know Avonworth took control in fourth quarter. Coach said their press paid dividends. I don't know about Ts or anything else.
TM: IF, Laurel Highlands and New Castle win...will their next matchup be the biggest game in the WPIAL this year? Sure hope it happens, I would want to go see that one.
Mike White: Hmmmm. I would say ... probably yes. Considering their records, the players, what happened in WPIAL championship. Good call.
Mike: Would Chartiers Valley get moved to 6A next year?
Mike White: You're talking about Char Valley girls. By winning second round game guarantees them of being bumped to 6A next year. You need six success points and one transfer over two years to move up. CV got 4 points last year for making the state final. Making the state quarters is worth 2 points. So they now have 6 and have one transfer. So up they go to 6A.
D9 Dave: Can you explain the process of how the PIAA designs the state brackets and how & which eastern teams play on the west side of the bracket?
Mike White: They are pre-determined brackets. They do not seed teams for stats. In some of the classes, there are many more teams in the eastern side of the state, so some of the eastern teams play in the west bracket to balance things out. Many times, they try to keep a district champ on their side of the state bracket, until at least the semifinals.
Mike: Mike who you got in the Moon vs McKeesport matchup?
Mike White: I'll take Moon.
Money: Who do you see winning state in 1a boys basketball
Mike White: Canevin vs. I don't know who from the east. Some good teams from the east also.
WPIAL NO 1: what’s the record for most boys hoops state championships won by the wpial in a year
Mike White: Three. 2004 and also 1992. 2004 Penn Hills, Sto-Rox and Moon. 1992 Blackhawk, Carlynton and Duquesne.
D9 Dave: Are you surprised that Rodney Gallagher at LHo has already said he is going to play football in college. He is a heckuva basketball player too. What do you think is his best sport?
Mike White: No, I'm not surprised. He didn't get recruited near as much for basketball as he did for football. He thought basketball recruiting might take off after last summer when he did fairly well in AAU. But it didn't. Better offers in football. Not surprised. Although I do know he really likes basketball.
Mick Wight: How are officials chosen to ref playoff games? Championship games?
Mike White: Picked by the WPIAL. They have evaluators at games. Supposedly based on performance. Coaches can also give a list of who they do want and who they do NOT want on games. WPIAL will look at that also.
D9 Dave: I attended the WPIAL championships at the Pete and the atmosphere was outstanding even better than the state championships at Hershey. Games were outstanding and the Pete is a nice venue except for the parking for the WPIAL championships. Your thoughts.
Mike White: The Pete for smaller class games is not good. It's empty. Dead atmosphere lot of times. But the 4, 5 and 6 games, atmosphere can be especially good. I did a story on attendance last week. Almost 25,000 this year. By far the best it's been for 6 classes. Friday and Saturday night, and some Thursday, it was loud. It was great!!!! Good they curtained off the upper decks. I just wish they would let students sit in end zone seats. Would make it even better.
Mick Wight: Are refs critiqued on their performances? Is there ever any punishment for poor performances?
Mike White: Yes, there is punishment. They make them listen to an hour long recording of "you can't do that!!!!!!" over and over and over and over. No, there isn't punishment. You just might get a future playoff game.
Concerned: Not punishing LH for having players that transferred in for athletic intent has taken opportunities away from other schools who did not. Why are private schools the only ones who are punished? Those kids all played aau together while going to school in different districts. Bad look wpial
Mike White: I don't disagree with you. But WPIAL approved them. And they did physically move into Laurel Highlands district. And I don't know if any principal challenged the move.
Gizzeria: Hi Mike, who are your 4A boys basketball (west region) winners tonight and the eventual winner on Friday?
Mike White: New Castle and Laurel Highlands ---- and New Castle wins Friday.
Timbo mcc: I am not saying any schumaman has an easy job but it seems like her decisions are inconsistent. Piaa is even worse. Why do they have rules with so many loop holes. Especially with recruiting.
Mike White: In WPIAL's defense, hard to prove recruiting if you don't have any evidence and if a school doesn't stand up and not sign off on transfer. If a school signs off on transfer, hard to prove anything. It's not as easy as most people think. Sure you know a kid transferred to athletic reasons, but might not have any evidence.
FOR 3: Whats the record for most 1,000 point scores on 1 team at the same time?
Mike White: There have been three from the same class in school. But I don't know if ever four. New Castle in late 1990s came close. David Young, Ed Pagley and Desmond Wetzel all had 1,000 and Pat Cain was close.
Lister: Do you think coaches should be given multi year contracts? I’ve heard it’s always 1 year.
Mike White: Yes, it's always one year supplemental contracts. That's just way school do it. You'll find here and there a two or three-year contract maybe, but not often.
JP: I agree on Butler Football. Teams should not shop for an easier district. Also I noticed on Max Preps TJ football is playing a week 0 game in New Jersey against one of their state champs.
Mike White: Wow. Did not know that. Interesting.
Lister: I assume olsh coach rod will retire if they are forced to move up a classification. Too much competition. Thoughts?
Mike White: I think he walks away no matter what. I think he almost walked last year or two. He's coached a long time. I know he has great success at OLSH, but there are some things that have worn on him but will never speak about publicly, because that's not him. Some parental things.
Pete: These schools have to travel so far for piaa games. Do the kids have to go to school the following day?
Mike White: Yes, it does seem ridiculous. They might get home at midnight or so on a school night. I don't know each school's policy. I'm sure they might get a break. But it is "state" playoffs, remember. So you sometimes have to travel the state. Plus, I know many kids are still up at midnight on their phones or watching TV anyway.
Spring Time: When does the Baseball preview come out ? Early favorites ?
Mike White: Spring sports preview next week. I think NA No. 1 in 6A. Why not? They have guys back, including a first-round draft pick probably. A number of teams in WPIAL championships have a number of returners, but might be missing their ace pitcher.
Mike White: Well that's about it for now. Time for a lunch sandwich, story on the shot clock for later this week and then off to 5A doubleheader at RMU. Now that's a good day!!! Everyone, be good.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.