Many athletic directors in the WPIAL feel fall high school sports should go on as scheduled despite the COVID-19 pandemic.

But a Pittsburgh Post-Gazette survey conducted from Friday through Tuesday shows there is also a rather significant amount who believe football — and at least a few other sports — should be postponed until the spring. And among those who favor moving sports to the spring are a few football coaches who also are athletic directors.

The questionnaire was sent to athletic directors at the 117 football-playing WPIAL schools. The ADs were asked to vote for one of three scenarios:

• Proceed with all fall sports as scheduled.

Advertise with us

• Play some fall sports but move the sports of football, boys and girls soccer and field hockey to the spring and have shortened seasons.

• Postpone all fall sports and move them to the spring with shortened seasons.

A total of 74 athletic directors responded, and 69% voted to play all fall sports as scheduled. But nearly one-third of the respondents — 31% — voted to move at least football, soccer and field hockey to the spring. Eight athletic directors believe all fall sports should be moved to the spring, with three shortened seasons.

The WPIAL is part of the PIAA, and the PIAA board of directors is scheduled to meet Friday afternoon to decide whether to have fall sports as scheduled. Indications coming from PIAA executive director Bob Lombardi strongly suggest the board will vote to conduct fall sports, but it will be up to individual schools around the state to choose if they want to participate. WPIAL executive director Amy Scheuneman has already said the league wants to have fall sports, though some schools, such as Uniontown and Summit Academy, have already elected to not have fall seasons.

McGuffey athletic director/football coach Ed Dalton, who has been a football coach at five different Pennsylvania schools and has a 196-127-1 record across more than three decades, believes all fall sports should be moved to the spring.

Advertise with us

“I would absolutely want to play right now, but my fear is an overreaction after a week or so, and no plan to pivot,” Dalton said. “That said, I think the three-season model beginning after July 1 gives all athletes the best opportunity to play. Honestly, I think for a multiple sport athlete, it would be a blast.”

Fall sports in Pennsylvania include football, boys and girls soccer, field hockey, boys and girls cross country, girls volleyball, girls tennis and boys and girls golf. The three-season model that Dalton prefers would put winter sports — basketball, wrestling, girls gymnastics and swimming and diving — from December or January to March; fall sports from March to May; and spring sports — track and field, baseball, softball, boys tennis, boys volleyball and boys and girls lacrosse — from May to the end of June or early July. A few other states have already decided to use similar models for their high school sports.

“I’m not sure my opinion is popular, but it is thought out and has been discussed,” Dalton said. “We must not deny opportunities for athletes like we did last spring, if it is within our power to make adjustments and put a plan in place.”

Gov. Tom Wolf and the state departments of health and education have recommended that all school and recreation sports be called off until Jan. 1. But that is not a mandate.

Ryan Matsook is the athletic director at Western Beaver and in his first season as football coach. He won a football state championship only four years ago as the coach at Beaver Falls.

Advertise with us

“I would be supportive of moving some fall sports to the spring,” Matsook said. “My worry is we start those higher-risk sports now and get shut down a few weeks in.”

Bill Cherpak is the athletic director at Thomas Jefferson but also one of the most successful football coaches in WPIAL history, winning a record eight WPIAL titles. Cherpak didn’t vote on whether football should be moved to the spring.

“My answer would depend on what happens if an athlete tests positive. Is there going to be a protocol for everybody?” Cherpak said. “If you have to shut down a team for two weeks, then I don’t see how it’s going to work. … Football, soccer, volleyball — they would be safe to move to the spring.”

Mike Bosnic is Washington High’s athletic director/football coach who won a WPIAL title three years ago and has coached a team to a championship game three times in the past eight years.

“I’m not strongly advocating one thing or another,” Bosnic said. “My thinking is with all the uncertainty and questions we have right now, it just seems reasonable to push some sports back to the spring. Hopefully by then, things are a lot better.

Advertise with us

“There’s really no right or wrong answer. It’s just a mess, and it’s been very frustrating as an athletic director. All indications we’re getting is that we’re moving forward with sports. We’re excited and we have to get the kids ready and make it a good experience for them. But it’s just a tough situation to be in.”

The PIAA’s decision on fall sports in Pennsylvania would affect more than 100,000 high school student athletes. According to the most recent participation statistics provided by the National Federation of State High School Associations, 119,000 boys and girls played fall sports in the state in the 2018-19 school year.

Some athletic directors believe baseball and softball could be switched to the fall season. Here are some opinions from WPIAL ADs who are in favor of moving football, and at least a few other fall sports, to the spring:

Charley Kiss, McKeesport: “Prioritizing spring sports should lead the discussion if fall sports move to spring. Spring sports are the sports that have lost the must thus far. Kids have been playing baseball and softball all summer and would be conditioned to play a high school season now. Additionally, by playing spring sports now, they can practice and play nearly the entire season outdoors and we can eliminate overcrowded facilities in the winter and spring months.

Don Short, Hopewell: “I would like to see sports start, but after Week 1, I believe it will become a cluster. There will be teams shut down and scheduling will become a nightmare. I could see only two or three teams in a section being able to play.

Advertise with us

Ron Ledbetter, Moon: “[Move fall sports to the spring] provided they don’t overlap the other sports. Spring sports already got hammered once. They don’t need kids being faced with a choice they shouldn’t have to make.”

Here are some opinions of athletic directors who believe fall sports should go on as scheduled:

John Wolf, Riverside: “We need to start using our safety protocols and see how it goes.”

Bill Cardone, Hampton: “We have been doing a good job with offseason conditioning and should get the opportunity to move forward. How would anyone know what could have been if we don’t at least try? If we won’t move forward, trust me on this, the AAU and club teams of the world will move forward, as well as 7-on-7 football leagues.

Mike McDonald, Our Lady of the Sacred Heart: “I think that with all of the work done by school districts to create return to play and return to school protocols, we should be given an opportunity to see how they work. … We don’t feel that we can guarantee that COVID-19 won’t affect our school, but we would like the opportunity to try to be as close to normal as possible, in the safest manner that we can.”

Advertise with us

Ted Ulmer, Clairton: “Personally, my son played in baseball tournaments all summer long. Some of these places were packed with people. I don’t see why we can’t safely play fall sports with a small number of spectators — maybe two tickets per athlete — provided we maintain appropriate social distancing.”

Scott Stephenson, West Mifflin: “I’m not sure delaying the start dates make anything safer. Why is Jan. 1 safer than Sept. 1? Most medical professionals anticipate a vaccine will not be available until late spring or early summer. Therefore, I’m not sure what delaying each season does since a vaccine will not be ready. … Parents should be the ones who ultimately decide if they want their kid to play or not.”

Clint Rausacher, Shaler: “Our kids have been working unbelievably hard over the past seven weeks to follow the mitigation guidelines our district has implemented, and also without incident. They absolutely deserve an opportunity to showcase that.”

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.