Big-time props go out to Carmichaels High School’s Remmey Lohr for her recent run through boys golf tournaments. She made history, becoming the first girl to qualify for both the WPIAL and PIAA boys championships.
No offense to Lohr’s success and her talents, but she had an advantage, playing from tees closer to holes than the boys. Lohr was simply playing by the rules, but the PIAA needs to change the rules. It’s time for equality.
If you didn’t know, girls can play on boys golf teams in Pennsylvania if their school doesn’t have a girls team. But when the girls play in boys matches, they play from the women’s (red) tees, which are supposed to be about 15 percent closer to the hole than the men’s tees. That can make a major difference. If a hole is 375 yards long, 15 percent is 56 yards. If a par 3 is 175 yards long, 15 percent lets the girl tee off 26 yards closer. In golf, 26 yards on a par 3 can make a big difference.
Lohr finished third at the WPIAL Class 2A championship last month and she was second at a PIAA Western Regional qualifier Oct. 15. She wasn’t at her best at the two-day PIAA tournament in York Monday and Tuesday, finishing tied for 30th with a two-day total of 170. Just getting to the PIAA final round was an accomplishment, though.
But back to the tees and equality. Girls most certainly should be allowed to compete on boys teams if their school doesn’t have a girls team. But if the girls are going to compete against the boys and try to win the same championships, they should play by the same rules. What other sport gives a girl a competitive advantage when they play against boys? Why golf?
Over the years, a few girls have played in the WPIAL boys singles tennis championships. Quaker Valley’s Annie Houghton won the boys Class 2A title in 2004. The PIAA’s rule for golf would be tantamount to Houghton being allowed to use the doubles out of bounds lines to hit while her boy opponent used the singles lines.
If a girl plays on a boys baseball team and pitches, the pitching rubber isn’t moved closer to the plate. If a girl bats against a boy pitcher, does the boy pitcher move back? No.
Numerous girls have been kickers in WPIAL football over the years. When those girls attempt a field goal, the ball isn’t moved closer to the goal post. So why is golf different? If a girl plays an individual boys tournament, she should play the same tees as the boys. I say even when girls play in boys matches during regular season team matches, the girls should play from the same tees as the boys.
Tim O’Malley, executive director of the WPIAL, said the league’s board of directors has long been of the opinion that girls on boys teams should play from the same tees as the boys. But the WPIAL follows the PIAA rules, and the PIAA mandates girls play in boys matches from the women’s tees. Well it’s time to change that rule.
While on the subject of golf rules for girls, one WPIAL rule needs to be changed. If a school doesn’t have a girls team, the school can send only one player to compete in the WPIAL girls individual tournaments. That rule needs to be changed to two.
I understand the WPIAL’s logic behind the rule. The league likes to promote team golf and would like to see more girls teams. If a school has two girls golfers, then find two more and make a team. But that still is not that easy, especially at a small school.
Lohr and her sister, Delaney, both played on the Carmichaels boys team. But because of the WPIAL rule, only one could play in the WPIAL girls championship. Delaney, a senior, played in the girls tournament this year while Remmey went against the boys.
If the WPIAL changed the rule by just one, both Lohrs could’ve competed in the WPIAL girls tournament. If two girls from a school without a girls team are good enough to qualify for the WPIAL girls tournament, let them play. But when they’re against the boys, play by the same rules.
A gray area
Belle Vernon affectionately calls its gold artificial turf “The Beach.” What will McGuffey call its new surface? That’s a gray matter.
The McGuffey school board last week approved a plan to install new artificial turf at the school’s stadium. The turf will be gray. Actually it will be two tones of gray every five yards.
Belle Vernon is the only stadium in the WPIAL with colored turf.
Perfect again?
The Aliquippa and Jeannette football teams have more perfect regular seasons than any two teams in WPIAL history — and both have a chance for perfection again.
Aliquippa and Jeannette both take 9-0 records into their regular-season finales Friday. Aliquippa has 18 perfect regular seasons and Jeannette 17. Clairton is next with 14 and plays Jeannette Friday, but Clairton has two losses.
Washington is fourth in perfect regular seasons with 14 and Thomas Jefferson fifth with 12. Both take 9-0 records into their final game.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.