This Week in High School Sports: Football playoffs are upside down

The PIAA instituted a new rule a year ago that the organization hoped would curb some of the transfers for athletic intent. Judging by the number of transfers recently in the WPIAL, people are turning a blind eye to the rule.

The new rule, which went into effect in August of 2018, states that any student-athlete who transfers schools after playing a sport as a sophomore, is automatically ineligible for the postseason in that sport for a year at the new school. So, if a football player spends his sophomore season at School A and then transfers before his junior year to School B, he is ineligible for the postseason as a junior at School B.

The postseason ineligibility can be waived under special circumstances, including a change of residence necessitated by an employment change, or a demonstrable change in income or other financial resources that compels a student to withdraw from a school. But a family must prove a change in finances.

Since July 1, the WPIAL has received 217 requests for eligibility on student-athlete transfers from all grades. Of those 217, the league has received 88 requests to waive postseason ineligibility.

Advertise with us

WPIAL executive director Tim O’Malley doesn’t have exact numbers of transfers in recent years, but said, “We usually have probably between 250-300 for the entire year, so this appears to be a little above average at this time of year. We have four new members on our board of directors and they’re kind of looking at me sideways about all the transfers we have to rule on.”

Many transfers are legitimate. But let’s face it. Many transfers also are athletically motivated, which is supposed to be against WPIAL and PIAA rules. Nobody ever admits a transfer is for athletics and it’s hard for the WPIAL and PIAA to prove. It should be noted the WPIAL has approved more than 90 percent of the 217 transfers so far this year.

There is some public opinion that a student-athlete should be eligible, no matter what the reason is for the transfer, even if it is for athletics. But that’s not what the PIAA rules state and many still believe an open-transfer rule would be horrible. With the new rule last year, the PIAA hoped to address some of the complaints about schools who benefit greatly from transfers.

“The intent behind the rule idealistically was to insure the postseason is not competitively impacted by transfers,” said O’Malley. “There has been an outcry from people saying some schools, because of transfers, have been much more competitive. The attempt was to put a stop to it somewhat by making a transfer ineligible for the postseason.

“One would question is it working?”

Advertise with us

Of the 88 transfers who requested a waiver for postseason competition, 25 have been denied by the WPIAL and 14 have been approved. The remaining 49 already received a letter to inform them of their postseason ineligibility and haven’t requested an appeal.

“The new rule has created a lot more work for district committees who have to make postseason eligibility decisions,” O’Malley said. “Idealistically, the rule is functional unless people don’t adhere to it.”

Walkers and 200

North Allegheny coach Art Walker joined some elite company when his Tigers defeated Central Catholic, 11-10, last Friday. Walker became the 26th coach to win 200 games in WPIAL history. But he also joined his father, also named Art Walker, in the 200 club.

The younger Art Walker (he is not Art Jr. because he has a different middle name than his father) has a record of 200-58. It says a lot about Walker that he reached 200 wins in only 22 seasons. He’s one of the fastest to 200 wins in WPIAL history.

Advertise with us

His father coached Mt. Lebanon for 21 seasons (1967-87) and Shady Side Academy for five (1994-98). The son needs seven wins to catch his father, who had a record of 207-74-8. The Walkers are believed to be the first father and son in state history to win 200 games.

Between them, the Walkers have 11 WPIAL titles. Dad has six and son has five.

Blown opportunity

What a sad situation for Gateway concerning senior football player Jaquan Thomas.

Thomas was a starting receiver-defensive back who was arrested Monday at Gateway High School and charged with six felonies, including robbery, over an incident Aug. 11. The situation is sad because of the opportunity that Thomas threw away and how Gateway went to bat for him just to get him to play this season.

Advertise with us

Thomas failed one year of high school and had used up his four years of eligibility after last season. But Gateway petitioned the WPIAL for an extra year. The league can grant a waiver for an extra year if student-athlete failed a grade because of extreme and unusual circumstances. In July, the WPIAL had a hearing with Thomas. Gateway school personnel, including teachers, spoke on Thomas’ behalf, saying a bad home life and other personal things led to his failure of a grade. They claimed Thomas was now on a good path in life and would be deserving of a waiver for an extra year.

The WPIAL granted Thomas the extra year. Then the news came out Monday about his arrest. It’s just a sad situation for many involved.

Points and no points

The WPIAL has the team with the most points in the state – and also the only team that hasn’t allowed a point.

According to westernpafootball.net, West Greene leads Pennsylvania in scoring with 194 points, an average of 64.7 points a game. Who would think West Greene would lead the state in scoring? This is a team that has made the WPIAL playoffs only four times in school history.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, Laurel is the only team in the PIAA that has not allowed a point. Laurel, the Post-Gazette’s No. 1 WPIAL Class 1A team, is 3-0 and outscored teams, 120-0.

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh