In high school softball, nothing is more important to a team’s success than having a great starting pitcher.
It’s no surprise, then, that two of the most successful seasons in Elizabeth Forward’s history have coincided with the arrival of Kailey Larcinese.
As a freshman last year, Larcinese pitched the Warriors all the way to the WPIAL Class 4A championship game while compiling a 19-2 record with a 1.47 ERA. Although Elizabeth Forward lost to Belle Vernon and current Penn State pitcher Bailey Parshall, 5-4, Larcinese bounced back with a stellar sophomore season and led the Warriors back to the WPIAL title game.
Once again, Larcinese had to square off against one of the best pitchers in the WPIAL in Mount Pleasant senior Carolyn Alincic. This time around, Larcinese pitched a complete-game shutout to bring Elizabeth Forward its first WPIAL championship in program history with a 3-0 win.
Just to prove it wasn’t a fluke, Larcinese outdueled Alincic again in the teams’ rubber match in the PIAA semifinals, which the Warriors won, 2-1, to advance to their first state championship game.
Although they lost, 3-2, to West Perry after Larcinese gave up a walk-off single in the bottom of the seventh inning, Elizabeth Forward coach Harry Rutherford believes the experience she has gained pitching so deep into the playoffs her first two years will prove invaluable for both Larcinese and the team going forward.
Read More
“Kailey had an outstanding performance,” Rutherford said. “She didn’t miss her spots too often. She did miss a couple of pitches, but still did a good job for us. She’s still a young pitcher. She’s only a sophomore. So I’m real pleased to have her back for two more years.”
Larcinese finished her sophomore season with a 17-5 record and 202 strikeouts, with four of those losses coming at the beginning of the season in the team’s trip to Vero Beach, Fla. With seven starters returning and Larcinese leading the way, don’t be surprised to see the Warriors make a return trip to both the WPIAL and PIAA championship games next season.
No end in sight
Although many of the best pitchers in the WPIAL were seniors this year, Larcinese does have some company for the title of “Best pitcher in the class of 2021.”
Hempfield sophomore Callie Sowers stepped into a starting role this season and didn’t miss a beat for the Spartans, going 18-6 with a 2.29 ERA and 165 strikeouts in her first full season on the mound. She pitched four innings of no-hit ball in Hempfield’s 15-0 victory against North Allegheny in the WPIAL Class 6A championship game to guide the Spartans to their fifth consecutive title.
While Hempfield came up short in its bid to win a fourth consecutive state title after falling to eventual champion Central Dauphin in the PIAA semifinals, 4-1, there’s no reason to believe the Spartans’ unprecedented dynasty will be coming to an end anytime soon. That’s because Sowers and her battery mate, sophomore catcher Emma Hoffner, still have two more years ahead of carving up bats and feasting on opposing pitchers.
Hoffner led the team with a .527 batting average, 10 doubles and 27 RBIs, and her presence in the middle of the lineup along with Sowers on the mound should make Hempfield a prohibitive favorite to make it back to next year’s WPIAL title game for the sixth year in a row.
“To go this far and be exposed to this kind of play, they get a taste of what it’s like,” Hempfield coach Bob Kalp said. “They’ll come back next year stronger for it.”
First time’s the charm
Like Elizabeth Forward, PIAA Class 2A champion Frazier graduated only two seniors from its starting lineup and will have seven starters returning next season.
And just like Larcinese has with the Warriors, Commodores ace pitcher Logan Hartman has guided her team to a spot in the WPIAL championship game every year of her high school career.
As a freshman, Hartman pitched a complete-game shutout in the WPIAL title game as Frazier captured its first WPIAL championship. The Commodores then lost in the title game to Laurel each of the past two years, but they made up for it this time by winning their first state championship in program history.
The WPIAL’s other PIAA champion in softball, Penn-Trafford, won’t have quite as much starpower returning as Frazier, as the Warriors lost four seniors to graduation in their starting lineup, including power-hitting first baseman Emma Armstrong.
To make up for it, Penn-Trafford has both starting pitcher Morgan Hilty and reliever Mia Smith returning, and the Warriors rely on their defense to win games just as much as their bats. Hilty, a junior, gave up three runs in 4⅓ innings in Penn-Trafford’s 5-3 win against Lampeter-Strasburg to capture its first PIAA title, while Smith, a freshman, pitched 2⅔ perfect innings to earn the save.
“Mia is such a good backup pitcher. She comes in and does her job perfectly every time, and it’s so nice to have someone like that,” Hilty said. “It’s really nice to have Mia there, and I feel confident in the outfield when she goes in.”
In short, don’t count out a repeat performance from either of the WPIAL’s first-time state champions next season.
Steve Rotstein: srotstein@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SteveRotstein






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.