Scan the top of the WPIAL leader boards in nearly every major softball statistic, and you’ll see the name “Zimmerman” so much, you’ll think you’re seeing double.
Indiana senior Haleigh Zimmerman leads the WPIAL with 6 home runs, 17 RBIs, 35 total bases and 12 runs scored through her team’s first seven games. She’s tied for third with 13 hits and tied for fifth with four doubles, all while slugging 1.296. Having made the switch from shortstop to pitcher, the 5-foot-8 IUP commit is also 3-3 on the mound with a 2.98 ERA and 28 strikeouts.
“It feels like every ball that comes off my bat has been over the fence,” Haleigh said. “I was talking to my dad about it, and I was like, when have I hit a single to the outfield? I feel like every time I hit it it’s over the fence.”
Meanwhile, Haleigh’s younger sister Sara also has 13 hits and is tied for fourth in the WPIAL with 10 runs scored. The 5-foot-9 sophomore is also tied for sixth with two triples while belting a pair of home runs, helping the Indians to a 4-3 record to start the season.
But while the Zimmerman sisters are reveling in their one season together, they know not to take their success for granted. As they both know all too well, it can all be taken away in an instant.
●●●
Haleigh and Sara did everything together growing up — except play on the same softball team.
That was supposed to change last year, but Haleigh tore her ACL playing basketball in a late-season game at Mars and missed all of softball season. Sara stepped into Haleigh’s role as the Indians’ starting shortstop as just a freshman and played well, but Haleigh’s absence left a gaping hole in the middle of Indiana’s lineup.
“It was crazy. I could not believe it happened,” Haleigh said. “The first thing I thought about, I totally know what happened, it popped and I felt it and I heard it, and the first thing I thought about was softball, because that’s my main sport.
“I just went through the recovery and pushed myself as hard as I could, and my left knee was almost stronger than my right knee they said. It felt so good to get back on the field.”
Sara was right there when Haleigh’s knee gave out, consoling her as she writhed in pain on the court — but not before blocking an opponent’s layup and giving the ball to the referee so she could go tend to her big sister.
“It was scary, it was very scary, because I didn’t know if I would be able to play with her ever again,” Sara said.
Haleigh traveled to every game with the team while rehabbing her knee with the help of world-renowned orthopedic surgeon Dr. Freddie Fu. She kept stats and did whatever she could to help out and stay involved while watching from the bench. Then, after about 10 months of rehab, she returned to the field in time for the start of preseason practice.
Just when the sisters thought they were finally ready to take the field together at full strength, Sara decided to get a second opinion on her shoulder, which had gotten sore during volleyball season. Doctors originally thought it was just tendinitis, but when Sara went into UPMC, she found out she had a torn labrum on her throwing shoulder.
Now, she faced a decision — have shoulder surgery and miss her sophomore season, or play through the pain and postpone surgery until after the season.
With Haleigh set to graduate after the season, Sara knew this was her last chance to play on the same team as her older sister. So she decided to postpone her surgery and made the switch to second base, where she can still make throws to first base without putting too much strain on her shoulder.
“At first it was a little weird, but they actually need me there, so I figured I’ll just step up and take the position and do whatever they need,” Sara said. “My throwing is a little weird. As long as I can play and hit, it’ll be fine. I can’t really throw that much, but I still get the job done.”
●●●
The Indians have made the WPIAL playoffs every year since Haleigh was a freshman, but have yet to make it past the second round.
They started out 16-1 her freshman year and won a section title, but lost a heartbreaker to Mount Pleasant in the first round of the playoffs, 3-2. Meanwhile, Yough has knocked off Indiana in the second round each of the past two seasons. The Vikings won another close battle between the section rivals on April 2, 4-3, while the Cougars took it to the Indians again in a 13-5 win April 4.
To get where they want to go in the postseason, the Zimmermans will likely have to lead Indiana past both Mount Pleasant and Yough. And while the Indians have come up short the past three years, they’ve never had both Zimmermans in the lineup come playoff time.
“We played Mount Pleasant and Yough both so far, and we lost both times, but definitely the Mount Pleasant game we had it, we definitely had it,” Haleigh said. “It just came down to the last inning and we couldn’t finish it off.”
Indiana bounced back from the defeats with its first section win of the year, a 5-2 triumph Monday against Greensburg Salem. Haleigh and Sara each collected two hits and drove in a run, while Haleigh also tossed a complete game and struck out four. Neither sister homered, but Haleigh’s spot at the top of the leaderboard is still safe for now.
Haleigh said her goal at the start of her career was to make it to states, and that hasn’t changed now that she’s a senior. But regardless of whether she wins the home run crown or leads the Indians to a championship, she’s already way ahead of where anyone could have expected her to be barely one year removed from a devastating knee injury.
“I missed it so much last year,” Haleigh said. “Man, just not getting to play last year really tore me up. So I knew whenever I came back I wanted to make it big.”
Steve Rotstein: srotstein@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SteveRotstein







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.