Isaac and Owen DeGregorio are eligible to play basketball at North Catholic for their dad, coach Dave DeGregorio, the PIAA appeal board ruled Thursday.

The PIAA overturned the WPIAL’s September decision, which ruled the boys ineligible to play basketball this season after transferring from Hampton to North Catholic. Dave DeGregorio was named North Catholic’s basketball coach in April.

After Thursday’s appeal, the board came away feeling that it wasn’t an athletically motivated transfer but rather a family situation, according to PIAA executive director Bob Lombardi.

“In this case, the board didn’t feel that the kids had a motivation to go play basketball at North Catholic as much as it was outweighed by the fact of being with their dad,” Lombardi said. “The board didn’t feel that it was athletically motivated, meaning if [their] dad wasn’t the coach, they wouldn’t be there. It was family.”

Advertise with us

The PIAA appeal board, which consists of five members from the Board of Directors, voted 5-0 to overturn the WPIAL’s ruling.

“We’re happy and excited,” Dave DeGregorio said. “You just feel vindicated. Common sense took over and won, and I think that it’s in the best interest of the boys.”

After the WPIAL’s ruling in September, WPIAL executive director Tim O’Malley suggested, should the PIAA overturn the decision, that it should tweak the language of transfer rules to make it clear transferring to the same school where a parent is a coach is allowed. A PIAA bylaw states athletic purpose may be indicative if “the student follows the student’s coach or other student-athletes to another school to which the coach or athletes have transferred, or seeks to play for a particular coach ... due to a prior relationship with the coach.”

That’s hard to do, Lombardi said, since they have to take into account the spirit and intent behind each student’s decision to transfer and handle it on a case-by-case basis.

“It all depends,” Lombardi said. “I think it’s very difficult to write rules for every individual case, for the 350,000 kids that are playing in athletics. Because every case is different. So I think the board has done a pretty good job to try to write rules that are of a general nature, but then you have to apply some spirit and intent to those situations that come up. And the courts have told us that the board, in eligibility cases, are to make individual assessments and make determinations on a case-by-case basis on the merits of the case.”

Advertise with us

Sarah K. Spencer: sspencer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @sarah_k_spence.

Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.