The New Castle School District on Thursday became the latest client to sue FieldTurf USA over what the district claims was defective turf on its football field.
The district filed the suit, which seeks class-action status, in federal court in Pittsburgh, saying the Florida-based company's product has not performed as advertised since its launch in 2005 with a nationwide marketing blitz.
The company has been the target of many other lawsuits across the country since an investigation in 2016 by a New Jersey media outlet into its business practices. The media project's findings are cited in the complaint.
Lawyers for the New Castle district said it bought FieldTurf's "Duraspine Turf" for its football field in 2009 at a cost of $800,000 but that it started to fall apart after a year.
The lawsuit, filed by Philadelphia lawyers Daniel Levin and Charles Schaffer, is asking for reimbursement for costs, punitive damages and a determination that FieldTurf was "unjustly enriched" by selling a product it knew was defective. Between 2005 and 2012, the lawsuit says, FieldTurf earned more than $570 million installing 1,400 fields.
FieldTurf disputed the New Castle claims, saying company records show it installed a different kind of field at the school, not Duraspine, that has not been the subject of complaints.
"The school district has gotten roughly 12 years of use from the field — well beyond the standard eight-year warranty term," FieldTurf said in an email.
The lawyers who filed the suit did not respond to messages Thursday.
According to the suit, FieldTurf marketed its Duraspine fields as more durable than other artificial fields, saying they would last 10 years or more. But many started deteriorating quickly and "crumbled to pieces," the lawsuit alleges, shortly after installation.
The complaint also says the company was slow to honor warranties and fully aware that its product did not match its advertising or promotional promises.
In December 2006, according to the suit, an employee wrote an email that was copied to the chief executive officer saying that "we are seeing fields showing splitting after under a year of play and have already had to replace one full-size field due to yarn failure after only a few months of installation."
The employee also wrote that the company was lying about the product's quality.
"Every day we are putting stuff out there that can't and won't live up to the marketing spin," he wrote.
FieldTurf on Thursday defended itself against the Duraspine claims, saying it has tried to be forthcoming with customers and "not hid from this problem."
The company also said that the problems with Duraspine have not impacted safety but only how the fields look as they wear.
In addition to FieldTurf USA, the suit names as defendants two related companies, FieldTurf Inc. of Montreal and FieldTurf Tarkett SAS of France.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.