It was a transfer case of follow the leader, but the WPIAL stepped in the way. Now Asante Watkins and Samuel Fairley are ineligible to play football at Imani Christian.
Watkins and Fairley transferred last month from University Prep in the City League to Imani Christian, a small private school in the WPIAL that re-started its football program this season after a three-year hiatus. But, after a hearing Monday with the WPIAL, Watkins and Fairley were ruled ineligible to play. The WPIAL board of directors claimed both transferred for athletic reasons.
WPIAL executive director Tim O’Malley said the board made its decision because it believed Watkins and Samuel left University Prep to follow either assistant coach LaRoi Johnson or talented senior Kenny Robinson. The WPIAL had a hearing Aug. 17 with Robinson, a Division I college prospect who also transferred from University Prep to Imani. University Prep challenged Robinson’s transfer, claiming he left for Imani because he was recruited by Johnson, a former University Prep assistant. University Prep also challenged the transfers of Watkins and Samuel.
PIAA and WPIAL rules state that an athlete who transfers to follow a coach or player can be ruled ineligible. But the WPIAL ruled Robinson eligible. Two days after the Robinson ruling, Imani turned in transfer paperwork to the WPIAL, requesting eligibility for Watkins and Samuel.
“Our board couldn’t remove from fact that on Aug. 17, Robinson was ruled eligible, Aug. 18 it was publicized and Aug. 19 Imani initiated the transfer paperwork [for Watkins and Fairley],” O’Malley said. “It appeared to the majority of the board that they followed a coach and player, and that’s a stipulation in the by-laws.”
At Robinson’s hearing Aug. 17, University Prep alerted the WPIAL that more transfers could occur if Robinson was made eligible. Imani Christian athletic director Cliff Simon told the board that no other University Prep players had transferred at that time. O’Malley said Simon testified Monday that Fairley and Watkins were with the team Aug. 15.
“Imani didn’t say they were practicing, but they said they were at practice Aug. 15,” O’Malley said. “But the transfer waiver request was not initiated until the day after Robinson was made eligible.”
Other WPIAL matters
• The WPIAL voted to accept the penalties that Upper St. Clair has placed on boys golf coach Craig Borst, who had his team forfeit in the middle of a big match last week against Peters Township. The WPIAL could’ve slapped more penalties on Borst, who was upset at his players after a rain delay.
O’Malley said the league can’t reveal Upper St. Clair’s penalties on Borst. When asked if it was a suspension, O’Malley said, “No comment.”
• The WPIAL granted an extra year of eligibility to Raekwon Dillard, a football player at Washington. Dillard had academic difficulties at schools in Virginia for two years before moving in with family friends in Washington. He had to repeat ninth grade and has not graduated yet. Dillard told the WPIAL of personal and family struggles while living in Virginia. Dillard played last season and was listed at 6 feet 4, 315 pounds.
“The testimony presented was verifiable that a hardship was involved in presenting academic difficulty a few years ago,” O’Malley said.
• The WPIAL denied Rashad Bolton’s request for a fifth year of eligibility at Cardinal Wuerl North Catholic.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.