ERIE, Pa. -- Body on body up front and nearly yard for yard in the box score, Thomas Jefferson matched Cathedral Prep on Friday night at Veterans Memorial Stadium.
But the District 10 champion Ramblers made more big plays in a 28-21 victory that ended the Jaguars' 11-game winning streak and their season in the PIAA Class AAA quarterfinals.
Thomas Jefferson (11-3) returned a blocked punt for a touchdown to open the scoring and led, 14-7, at the half. But Cathedral Prep (13-1) took the lead for good on a 1-yard run by Sullivan Johnson set up by Chris Muldrew's 60-yard burst with 51/2 minutes to play.
"The mismatches they had were unbelievable," Jaguars coach Bill Cherpak said. "We hung in there as long as we could, but they were like Ohio State out there. They have phenomenal skill players."
Thomas Jefferson took a 7-0 lead when Peter Metro blocked Preston Kidder's punt from the Cathedral Prep 19 and Nick Freiwald scooped the ball off the turf and ran it back 6 yards for a touchdown.
"We knew the way they ran it that if we could get a little push that could happen," Cherpak said of the block.
Cathedral Prep tied it on a 17-yard pass from Joe Mischler to Koran Williams, but Thomas Jefferson re-took the lead when Bobby Kelley connected with Jon Muehlbauer for a 34-yard touchdown with 3:30 to go in the half.
Muldrew scored from 5 yards out in the third quarter to tie it again.
On Prep's next possession, a pass interference call against the Jaguars set up the Ramblers at the Thomas Jefferson 15, and Mischler went back to WIlliams, who made a leaping catch in tight coverage in the end zone.
Thomas Jefferson responded with Kelley's 16-yard touchdown pass to Zane Zandier, but on the next series Muldrew broke loose to set up the winning score.
"I'm pleased," Cherpak said. "Our kids played as hard as they possibly could. They played their hearts out."
Mischler, a sophomore who missed most of the practice reps last week with two pulled hamstrings, threw for 123 yards and two scores.
"The injury was a little rough, but the confidence I had from my teammates -- they had faith in me the whole time," Mischler said. "We came in here and played our game."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.