By the time the Class 1A girls soccer semifinals came around, one thing was for certain: A private school would take home the title.
The final four of Greensburg Central Catholic, Cardinal Wuerl North Catholic, Shady Side Academy and Seton LaSalle featured all private schools, which has become a common theme in recent years.
Since its inception in 2010, Class 1A has been claimed by only two teams. Greensburg CC has won it four times, while Shady Side has won three.
Currently, there are four classifications. Prior to 2010, WPIAL girls soccer was divided into Class AAA and Class AA. Many of the top private schools have settled into the smallest classification due to student enrollment at their schools.
Ashley Davis, the coach of Greensburg CC, said that a culture of winning has kept GCC at the top, even as the other private schools in 1A keep improving, such as Bishop Canevin, Vincentian, Sewickley Academy, Our Lady of the Sacred Heart, Eden Christian, Winchester Thurston and Serra Catholic, which snapped the Centurion’s WPIAL-record 89-game win streak this season.
“They want to be part of a winning tradition,” Davis said of players who come to GCC. “I do think that draws a lot of people in.”
Read More
Public schools have a limited area in which players can come from, while the private institutions can have a larger imprint.
“Anybody can come to a private school and that’s an advantage compared to districts,” said Davis, who has been on both ends of the spectrum. She was a player at public school Norwin before coaching GCC.
Bentworth coach Tyler Hamstra has made his Bearcats an exception to the private school rule. Bentworth has made the playoffs each year since the addition of 1A, however Hamstra has found himself wondering what could have been after each season ends with a private powerhouse on top.
“It’s cost us a lot of section titles and at least chances to the semifinals,” he said. “It is frustrating, that’s for sure. The only one advantage we have is we can develop our players younger than they can. But at any point, they can have a great athlete come to their school.”
While Davis acknowledged the wider net available to schools like hers is advantageous, there are some drawbacks to being non-public. First, private schools charge a tuition, which can be a deterrent. On top of that, players at GCC are responsible for chipping in $350 to go toward expenses such as transportation, referees and the like. They also raise money or receive donations for warmups, uniforms and other needs.
Davis surmised that the kids from families who can pay tuition may also have the money to send them to the best camps and pay for travel teams to boost their skills. Thus, they have the means to develop into talented players outside of school as well.
Hamstra said that the private institutions are good schools and that parents have the right to choose to send their kids wherever they want to.
“I don’t think kids go there for sports,” Hamstra said. “They go there for a great education. I don’t want to be the guy saying they’re recruiting.”
But, Hamstra said, he would like to see a separate section or classification for private schools. Or perhaps they could choose to move up in classification.
“The stars have got to align for a public school to win the WPIAL,” said Hamstra. “It’s a shame. It really is. If you won the same classification every year, wouldn't you want to move up?
Mars
Mars will play for a WPIAL championship, and it has its defense to thank. After Monday’s 2-1 semifinal victory against South Park, the Planets have only been scored on in four matches this season. The Planets (16-1) have 13 shutouts and did not allow a goal to a Class 3A Section 1 opponent. Goalie Claire Valentine has allowed just eight goals. Mars has won four WPIAL titles in the past seven years
Top scorers
Of the 10 leading scorers in the regular season, seven of them were still playing by the semifinals. The WPIAL’s leading scorer, Madison Clayton of Waynesburg, scored 53 goals in the regular season. Moon’s Delaney Snyder (40), Freedom’s Michaela Watkins (38), Yough’s Justin Appolonia (32), Freeport’s Kaylee Comperatore (31), Seton LaSalle’s Mofoluke Obiri (31), and Shady Side Academy’s Krystyna Rytel (31) were the other leaders.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.