When the Allderdice boys soccer team first joined the WPIAL in 2012, the former City League power had a revelation.
"It was a complete shock to me," said coach Sam Bellin. "The speed and physicality of the WPIAL caught us completely by surprise. It took us some time to adjust."
But now, Allderdice resides in the WPIAL soccer fast lane — and backs down to no one.
Allderdice has pushed its way into WPIAL prominence and given City League schools a boost. The Dragons won the WPIAL Class AAA Section 4 championship, beating out some teams that have rich soccer traditions, like Mt. Lebanon. Allderdice is 11-1-3 after Wednesday's 1-0 loss to Obama and the Dragons are a team to watch for the WPIAL soccer playoffs that begin this weekend.
The section title is a fairly big step for Allderdice's program, but a gigantic step for a handful of City League schools that, starting in 2012, became associate members of the WPIAL in a few sports.
"The city and suburban teams are different, and in important ways," said Bellin. "Our kids are aware of it. The sports teams in the City League have had a hard time [in the WPIAL] and our kids are aware of that. So this means something to them."
Allderdice, Brashear, Carrick and Obama are the four City League schools that are associate members of the WPIAL in boys and girls soccer, baseball, softball, tennis, golf, volleyball and swimming. Not all of the schools have teams in the WPIAL in every one of those sports. For example, Allderdice is the only City League school in the WPIAL in boys and girls tennis. Also, no City League teams are in the WPIAL in football, basketball and a few other sports.
Most City League teams have struggled mightily in the WPIAL. For example, in boys and girls soccer, baseball and softball, City League teams have a winning percentage of only .240 since joining the WPIAL in 2012. Out of 48 City League teams in those four sports since 2012, only five had winning seasons.
But there are small signs that maybe some City teams are becoming more competitive. Allderdice was 2-14 in baseball in its first WPIAL season of 2013. Last season, Allderdice finished 11-4 and made the WPIAL Class AAAA playoffs. This past spring, the Obama boys volleyball team opened eyes when it won a section title and made it to the WPIAL Class AA championship before losing to Ambridge. Obama also made it to the PIAA semifinals.
In soccer, Allderdice was the perennial power in the City League and was competitive at times against WPIAL teams in the PIAA playoffs. But Allderdice was 6-9-2 in its first year of WPIAL soccer. The Dragons, though, have increased their win total every year in the WPIAL. Also, the Obama boys soccer team has a 25-24 record over the past three seasons.
"You can just tell from the stands that [City] teams are getting better," said Bellin. "It might not always show in their records, but I just saw Brashear play. They are so much better than when we beat them in the last City League championship [in 2011]. There are two main factors we have to overcome. One is, we don't have as many resources as the WPIAL. The second one is that in many areas of the city, the sport of soccer just is not all that popular."
But Bellin added, "Soccer is big in the east end of Pittsburgh, which is where we are."
Allderdice had enough players to start a freshman team this year, which is unheard of for a City League school. Counting freshman, JV and varsity, Allderdice has 70 players.
City League athletic director Mike Gavlik also believes City teams are improving. It has already been decided that Allderdice, Brashear, Carrick and Obama will continue as associate members of the WPIAL for at least the next two years.
"We've taken our lumps, too," said Gavlik. "But I think in the four years, we've seen some improvement overall. I think everyone understands the recipe a little better now -- about offseason conditioning, summer leagues, fall leagues, clinics. I think everyone is getting more accustomed to things."
But a major question about City League athletics is will the league join the WPIAL in football and basketball in the near future. Westinghouse has requested to join the WPIAL in football for next season and Obama in baseball, but the WPIAL hasn't decided yet whether to accept those schools in those two sports. Gavlik said there are no plans for the City League to join the WPIAL in football and basketball, at least for the next two years. Some City League coaches, especially in basketball, have expressed a desire to join the WPIAL. But some coaches, though, want to stay in the City League to keep the league's identity.
"This is strictly my personal opinion. I think we should try to go to the WPIAL in all sports," said Bellin, who is an Allderdice graduate. "I'm sort of an old-time City League guy. I get the City League pride thing. But the better competition, the better resources, the better exposure for our kids ... It might be hard in the first few years, but in the long run, I think being part of a bigger pool will help all City teams."
Four City League schools (Allderdice, Brashear, Carrick and Obama) joined the WPIAL in a handful of sports in the 2012-13 school year. While boys soccer experienced some success, girls soccer, baseball and softball struggled. Here's a look at the records of those sports since the 2012-13 season:
Sport: Record/Pct.
Boys soccer: 81-64-10/.555
Girls soccer: 41-196-7/.182
Baseball: 33-103/.243
Softball: 23-117/.164
Total: 178-580-17/.240
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1975 and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.