Most teens never get the chance to hear themselves talked about on national television, especially on multiple occasions.

Plum’s John Nonnenberg is an outlier.

Last week, media star and Plum grad Pat McAfee shouted out Nonnenberg on his ESPN show. He has known Nonnenberg since he was a child, as Nonnenberg’s father, Keith, was McAfee’s teacher and volleyball coach at Plum.

“Little Johnny Nonny is the No. 1 quarterback in 5A football right now,” McAfee said. “Isn’t that absurd to think about?”

Advertise with us

This week, the senior QB shrugged off the attention he’s received from McAfee.

“That was pretty cool. I’m actually wearing one of the hoodies he gave me right now,” Nonnenberg said. “That’s my guy. He does that every once in a while.”

Led by Nonnenberg, McAfee’s old team is off to its best start in years.

Plum is 5-0 for the first time since 2020. That’s as many wins as the Mustangs had last season and is tied for the most since the 2020 team won eight games and reached the WPIAL semifinals.

“I feel like we’re more together than we’ve ever been,” Nonnenberg said.

Advertise with us

Optimism is running high in the Plum community as the Mustangs prepare to host Armstrong (4-1) in the Class 5A Northeast Conference opener Friday. Armstrong’s only loss came to a team from West Virginia in the season opener.

Plum is not short on momentum, as the Mustangs are coming off one of the biggest comebacks in recent WPIAL history. They stormed back from 28 points down in the second half to win at Kiski Area, 29-28.

Coach Matt Morgan, a Plum graduate who went on to play at Pitt and in the NFL, called the win “insane,” adding that he has never been a part of a game that had such a big comeback.

“What’s special about that win was that we hadn’t been down all year,” Morgan said. “We’ve been up on people and haven’t faced adversity. It was nice to see those kids finally be able to fight. I’ve never seen that much fight in a team before. This game really showed their resilience and their heart.”

Plum stunned Kiski Area by scoring three touchdowns in the game’s final four and a half minutes.

Advertise with us

Nonnenberg was one of the stars, completing 31 of 53 passes for 334 yards and four touchdowns. With 19 seconds left in the game, he threw a 15-yard scoring strike to Semaj Robinson to pull Plum within one. Then he called his own number on the two-point try, scoring to put the Mustangs ahead.

“I was just waiting for the referee to put his hands up,” Nonnenberg recalled from his winning run. “And when he did, I knew it was game.”

Nonnenberg, who is listed at 6 feet 1 and 175 pounds, has some real game, as he has developed into one of the WPIAL’s top quarterbacks.

Nonnenberg now leads the WPIAL in passing with 1,316 yards. He has thrown 17 touchdowns to just three interceptions. He’s also rushed for 129 yards.

“Obviously, our passing game is our heart and soul,” Morgan said. “Our quarterback has been pretty impressive thus far. He’s finding a lot of different receivers. He’s doing his thing. He’s doing everything we’re asking him to do.”

Advertise with us

It helps that Nonnenberg has a go-to target in Robinson, a junior who ranks among the WPIAL leaders with 26 catches for 656 yards and eight touchdowns. The two hooked up 10 times for 139 yards and two scores against Kiski Area.

In addition to Robinson, seniors Tyler Baleno and Chase Tomain, junior Luther Trowell and sophomore Jayden Bruce all have at least nine receptions. Bruce has 346 receiving yards and Baleno four touchdowns.

The Mustangs can pick up yards on the ground when needed, too.

Senior CJ Hart, Nonnenberg and junior Jake Ligo have been the top rushers. Hart is a Youngstown State recruit.

A key has been the growth and maturation of a young offensive line with five new starters. That unit includes senior Terrance Montue; juniors Leo Tristani, Paxton Simonson and David Pupilli; and sophomore Cayden Stephenson.

Advertise with us

“We thought it was going to be a challenging year with five new guys, but one day it was like, ‘It looks like they’ve been working together for years,” Morgan said.

Defensively, Plum gives up just 12 points per game. Senior Kenneth Smith leads the team in tackles and senior Maddox Roedersheimer is tops in sacks.

While Plum has passed all tests so far, it has challenging games coming up.

That includes conference games against North Hills (Oct. 16) and Pine-Richland (Oct. 30). North Hills is unbeaten and Pine-Richland, with just one loss, is ranked No. 1 in Class 5A.

Win one or two of those games, and Plum will squarely be in the conversation for possibly winning a WPIAL title, something the program has not done since 1983.

Advertise with us

And, who knows, maybe “Little Johnny Nonny” will get another mention on ESPN.

“I think we can go all the way,” Nonnenberg said. “Last week showed that when we have a lot of adversity against us, we have the fight to get through it. It really showed who we are.”