ALTOONA, Pa. — Peters Township pulled off the greatest comeback in WPIAL championship game history when it overcame a 19-point halftime deficit to unseat defending champion Pine-Richland.
Coming back from 11 points down at the intermission against defending champion Bishop McDevitt to take a lead in the fourth quarter in the state semifinals? Child’s play.
Holding that advantage, well, that was something the Indians couldn’t do this time around in a PIAA Class 5A semifinal..
Peters Township (13-1) had a four-point lead with 7:51 remaining in regulation and later tied it up on a 24-yard field goal from Anthony Maiello with 1:33 left in the fourth quarter. But given one final opportunity, Bishop McDevitt (12-2) showed why it won the title in 2024, as it drove the field on the Indians and moved on to the state championship when Aidan Grella nailed a 24-yarder of his own on the game’s final play in a dramatic 31-28 victory for the Crusaders on Saturday afternoon at Mansion Park Stadium.
“I told them, if we didn’t win the state championship, I’d want to walk off the field with one second left [knowing] that we went down fighting to the end,” Peters Township coach TJ Plack said. “It’s not like we were down and we knew the game was over. We fought to the end, and if we didn’t win the state championship, that’s how I want to go out.”
For a minute, it appeared the game was headed to overtime after Maiello hit his late field goal to knot it up 28-28.
Read More
Bishop McDevitt had a 2nd-and-13 at the Peters Township 49 with less than a minute remaining, and Indians linebacker James Spratt blitzed through a hole right up the middle and had a clean shot at quarterback Sebastian Williams. But the junior first-year starter flipped a pass over the middle into the spot Spratt vacated and hit Ishmael Palmer on a short underneath crosser. The speedy receiver turned it into a 41-yard gain that gave the Crusaders a first down at the Indians 8.
“It’s one of our favorite plays and it’s one that we hit for the first touchdown, but we always have a hot [route],” Bishop McDevitt coach Jeff Weachter said. “We just wanted to get inside the 40[-yard line] because Aidan can kick 55-60 yards. We thought we would get the back on the flare, but when he saw the double A-gap blitz, he did a great job of seeing the built-in hot.”
Peters Township had an opportunity to possibly put the game away on its previous possession.
Trailing 28-25 at with a drive starting at their own 7, the Indians relied on the right arm of Villanova recruit Nolan DiLucia to get them down the field. Thanks to three Bishop McDevitt penalties — including a heads-up call on defensive back RJ Duffy on a pass interference at the goal line when he shoved a wide-open Lucas Shanafelt in the chest to prevent an easy touchdown — Peters Township had a 1st-and-goal at the Crusaders 8.
But on both first and third downs, DiLucia had his passes batted back in his face, and a Cole Neupaver run on second down got them nothing, so the Indians had to settle for the 24-yard field goal and the tie.
DiLucia finished 19 of 36 for 264 yards and two touchdowns but was more effective in the second half, when he completed 11 of 16 for 179 yards and both scores.
“We just couldn’t capitalize on that touchdown, and that’s on me, as well. I made a lot of mistakes,” DiLucia said. “I can’t do anything about it now because it’s all in the past, but we fought. We fought to the last second, and that’s what I love about every single one of these guys.”
Game flow
Considering how things started, it’s a wonder Peters Township was in the game at all. Everything that could have gone wrong for the Indians in the first half did, as Bishop McDevitt built up a 14-0 lead 24 seconds into the second quarter.
Neither team could move the ball early, and it took a big play from Bishop McDevitt to open the scoring, as Williams threw deep into double coverage and hit Howard Holton for a 58-yard touchdown and 7-0 lead with 2:10 left in the first quarter.
Peters Township was forced to punt on the ensuing drive, and Reston Lehman hit one straight up the chute that bounced at the Indians 27. Palmer grabbed the ball chest high as it came off the turf and raced untouched for the touchdown and a 14-0 Crusaders lead.
Peters Township finally broke the ice on its next drive when Maiello hit a 28-yard field goal. Then, following a Neupaver interception at the Peters Township 23, he capped the 77-yard drive with a 6-yard touchdown to get the Indians back to 14-10.
Just one play later, the deficit was back up to 11, as Eastern Michigan recruit Nazir Jones-Davis broke one up the middle for a 42-yard touchdown with 2:45 left in the half and a 21-10 lead at the intermission.
But this one was just getting started.
Peters Township got that one back when DiLucia hit Lucas Rost, who had nine catches for 99 yards, for an 8-yard touchdown. He then connected with Lehman for the two-point conversion, and the deficit was only three — 21-18 with 46 seconds left in the third quarter.
Peters Township took its only lead on its next possession when DiLucia tossed a 70-yard bomb to PJ Luke down the right sideline to put the Indians ahead 25-21 with 7:51 to play. But that lead only lasted 3:40 until Williams, who finished 16 of 22 for 250 yards and two scores, found Jontai Quick for a 26-yard touchdown and a 28-25 lead with 4:11 left that led to the last-minute drama.
Key stats
• There were three lead changes and a tie in the fourth quarter.
• Peters Township was held to 46 yards on 25 carries.
• Bishop McDevitt was flagged 18 times for 173 yards.
Quotable
“I always have hope with this team. I know this team can do great things. We’ve done great things this season, and sometimes it doesn’t go your way.” — DiLucia
What it means
Bishop McDevitt will have an opportunity to defend its 2024 PIAA Class 5A title when it meets District 12 champion Roman Catholic, which posted a 48-20 victory against Springfield Delco in the eastern final. The Crusaders defeated Roman Catholic 34-31 in overtime in last year’s state final.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.