Bobby Fadden, fatigued? Oh, what a knee slapper. What’s next, elephants flying?
“I’m tired in the morning for just a little when I get up,” Fadden said. “But once I get going, I just go.”
And go ... and go ... and go ... and go ... and go. That’s five goes, one for every sport Fadden plays.
It’s been said the days of the three-sport athlete are dwindling in high school athletics. That’s true. Then along comes Fadden, a Mohawk senior who gives new meaning to all-around athlete.
Life is a ball for Fadden. He throws the brown one, hits the little white one, shoots the orange one, smacks the white one with stiches — and jumps over a bar and into sand pits just for good measure. He is an amazing story, competing in five sports at Mohawk.
In the 1960s and early ’70s, “Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons” was an ultra-popular band with the younger generation. At Mohawk, a small school in Lawrence County, Robert John Fadden III is his own one-man band: “Bobby Fadden and The Five Seasons.”
Read More

For Fadden, the five seasons are football, golf, basketball, baseball and track and field. He competes in all of them. There have been documented stories in the WPIAL over the past two decades of athletes playing two sports in the same season. Just recently, Ellwood City’s Joseph Roth starred in the rarest two-sport combination during one season — basketball and swimming.
But Fadden (6-foot-1, 180 pounds) plays two sports in the fall — and spring. In the winter, he plays only basketball. (What a slacker.) He has been a starter in football, basketball and baseball since his freshman year. And get this: He will graduate next June with 17 varsity letters — four in football, four in basketball, four in baseball, three in track and field and two in golf. Oh, yeah, he also has a 3.98 grade-point average on top of it all.
“The kid just never rests,” Mohawk football coach Tim McCutcheon said with a sense of admiration.
When asked how tiring it is playing five sports, Fadden said, “I’ll get sore sometimes. But soreness isn’t really tired. I think tired is kind of a choice.”
But it’s not just competing in five sports that makes Fadden rare. He is a standout and has made both WPIAL and Mohawk history.

• In football, he was a starting receiver as a freshman and sophomore before moving to quarterback as a junior. He is only the second player in WPIAL history known to have 1,000 career yards passing, 1,000 yards receiving and 1,000 yards rushing. In a win against Riverside last Friday that put Mohawk in the WPIAL playoffs, Fadden completed 15 of 18 passes for 218 yards and three touchdowns and rushed for 50 yards and two touchdowns.
He now has 3,034 career passing yards, 1,116 rushing and 1,404 receiving on 81 receptions. The only WPIAL player to have 1,000 career yards in those categories was Beaver Area’s Darius Wise, a 2017 graduate who went on to play receiver at Colorado State and then Edinboro. Fadden also is a starting defensive back, with four interceptions this year, a punter and kick returner.

• In basketball, Fadden already has set a Mohawk school record with 1,702 career points. This season, he likely will become only the 42nd player in WPIAL history to score 2,000 career points. Fadden’s father, Robert II, and uncle, Brian Fadden, also scored 1,000 points.
• Golf isn’t Fadden’s best sport, but he was good enough to qualify for the WPIAL Class 2A individual championships in each of the past two seasons. He has played golf for only two seasons. Mohawk football usually practices around 4:30 p.m., which allows Fadden to play in nine-hole golf matches after school and then go to football practice.
How about this for endurance: On a Friday once this fall, Fadden walked 18 holes in a golf match after school and then immediately went and played quarterback-defensive back in a football game.
• In baseball, Fadden is a middle infielder-pitcher and has been a starter since his freshman year. He has hit better than .300 in every season.
• In track and field, Fadden competes in the jumping events. This past May, Fadden qualified for the WPIAL individual championships in the triple jump but skipped the event because Mohawk had a playoff baseball game that day.

“I guess it starts with just his compete level,” McCutcheon said. “It’s more complex than that, but there also couldn’t be a simpler man. He always has a smile on his face. Years ago, I used to worry about fatigue with him and overuse, but he has never shown a sign of that.”
Jay Wrona, Fadden’s cousin, played football, golf, basketball and baseball at Mohawk, but Fadden has gone one better with track and field.
You want more evidence of Fadden’s athletic ability? Listen to Mohawk basketball coach Mike O’Lare.
“He lives across the street from me. My son is one year younger, and they hunt and play sports together,” O’Lare said. “Bobby’s been like a second son. ... For what he has done at the level he has done it for so many years is a true testament to his ability to show up every day and put the work in. He wanted to have the best high school experience possible, something he will never forget. And on a side note, he won the schoolwide ping-pong tournament the past two years that we do at the end of the school year.”
Fadden is an avid hunter and fisherman also. He answered a phone call from the Post-Gazette on Sunday and was talking very quietly, like he had just woke up from a nap.
“No, I’m in the woods in a tree stand waiting for a deer,” Fadden said.
In the days when many high school athletes specialize in one sport and say playing two is too demanding, what in the world drives the soft-spoken Fadden to never stop — and have such high grades in the classroom? It’s something in his inner self.
“To me, it doesn’t seem all that outrageous,” Fadden said. “The reason I do this literally is because I love to compete.”
A natural question: What does the future hold for Fadden? He says he likes whatever sport is in season but admits to being most fond of basketball and football. He has not talked to any colleges for football, but some small colleges are interested in him for basketball.
He’s one of those kids who isn’t a major-college prospect but is just a super high school athlete.
“Some coaches at some schools might be selfish in their seasons and what they will allow a player to do,” McCutcheon said. “But this is supposed to be about the kids. I have kids on our team that play in the band at halftime and aren’t in the locker room for halftime adjustments. If they have other passions, I’ll be the last guy to get in their path if something can be worked out.”
For Bobby Fadden, the passions are many.

JUST SAYIN’
• Mayson Mitchell took over as Gateway’s No. 1 quarterback only after starter Elvis Koutsakis was injured in the second game. All Mitchell did from there is throw for the second-most yards ever by a WPIAL freshman in the regular season. Mitchell (5-foot-10, 165 pounds) completed 155 of 253 passes for 2,042 yards. The only freshman to throw for more in the regular season was Western Beaver’s Jaivin Peel, who threw for 2,434 in 2023.
• Leading the WPIAL in passing yardage doesn’t necessarily mean someone is the best quarterback in the league. But statistically, it’s been almost four decades since a WPIAL quarterback had back-to-back seasons like North Catholic’s Joey Felitsky. A senior, Felitsky led the WPIAL in regular season passing for the second consecutive season, throwing for 2,437 this year, only 7 more yards than last season. The last player to lead the WPIAL in passing in two consecutive seasons was Jeff Palladino of Penn-Trafford in 1988-89.
• The Moon boys basketball team’s playoff fortunes just got a little better last week — if the Tigers make the playoffs. The PIAA overturned an earlier WPIAL decision and made the Bauman brothers eligible for the postseason. Jackson Bauman, a senior projected to be one of the WPIAL’s top guards, and his younger brother, Brody, transferred from Knoch to Moon in the spring. Their father, Alan, was their coach at Knoch but resigned. The WPIAL ruled the brothers eligible for the season but ineligible for the playoffs. The PIAA overturned the WPIAL’s decision.
• Speaking of basketball eligibility, 7-footer Loic Kalau has been ruled eligible to play this season at Montour. Kalau came from Congo a few years ago and played at Andrews Osborne in Willoughby, Ohio. He enrolled at Montour in the summer and is living with the family of Kaleb Platz, who played football and basketball at Montour just last year.
• In girls basketball, Thomas Jefferson’s Kaylee DeAngelo was projected to be one of the WPIAL’s top junior guards this season. She is committed to Robert Morris. But DeAngelo will miss the season after recently suffering a torn ACL.
COMING BACK TO WPIAL?
At various times in the past seven seasons, five teams — Albert Gallatin, Butler, Brownsville, Connellsville and Uniontown — left WPIAL football and played an independent schedule because they had trouble competing in the WPIAL because of small rosters. But some of the independent schools are considering a return to the WPIAL for next season when the league realigns. Uniontown coach Tim Bukowski said he “fully expects” the Raiders to be back in the WPIAL. “My concern, though, is where the [enrollment] numbers fall in [Class] 3A or 4A,” Bukowski said. Athletic directors at Albert Gallatin and Connellsville said their schools will decide in the near future, while Butler athletic director Bill Mylan said, “We won’t decide until we see if anything new scheduling-wise is going to be implemented.”

DATA WAY
22.2
Percent of the time a run by McKeesport’s Kemon Spell ends in a touchdown. That means Spell, a junior running back, scores almost once every four times he carries the ball. He has 81 carries and 18 rushing touchdowns. On top of that, Spell is averaging 13.3 yards per carry this season and 12.1 over the past two seasons.
REMEMBERING WHEN

Fort Cherry’s Matt Sieg set WPIAL records this season for career touchdowns and career offensive yardage. Forty years ago, another Fort Cherry player led the WPIAL in regular season rushing yardage. In 1985, Brad Tokar was a junior who rushed for 1,384 yards. A year later, he finished his career as one of only six WPIAL players to run for 4,000 career yards. He had 4,027 before going on to an outstanding career at Westminster College. He led Westminster in rushing in four consecutive years and is still the school’s all-time leading rusher with 5,269 yards. Tokar went on to officiate WPIAL football.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and @mwhiteburgh on X.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.