There were no signs in the stands. No indignant protestations from fans. No vitriol spewed in the direction of the Fox Chapel administration.
When it was all said and done, Fox Chapel and Pine-Richland played their game Friday night the exact same way they did in 2024 with the exact same result. The Rams came away with a lopsided, mercy-rule victory in their Northeast Conference matchup against the Foxes.
Senior running back Maclane Miller carried 14 times for 158 yards and three first-half touchdowns to lead Class 5A No. 1 Pine-Richland (5-1, 3-0) to a 63-3 romp against host Fox Chapel (2-4, 0-3).
“We just wanted to come out explosive,” Miller said. “With all the stuff going on and everything, we just wanted to play our game and keep it going. This is how we want to play every game.”
On Thursday evening, Pine-Richland coach Jon LeDonne sent a letter out to his team’s parents, explaining to them the school’s athletic office had been in contact with Fox Chapel and the two had reached an agreement for the game to be played with a 12-minute first quarter, an eight-minute second quarter and two eight-minute quarters after halftime played with a running clock.
“I understand the concern and the situation of what they’re dealing with here. We’re never out to embarrass an opponent,” LeDonne said. “At the end of the day, we’re still a small fraternity and a brotherhood with the football network that we have.”
Read More
Prior to the game, the two teams agreed to play the first half normally and play the second half as previously arranged. Because the score was 42-3 at halftime, it would have been played with a running clock anyway because of the high school mercy rule.
When a team has a 35-point lead at any point in the second half, the clock stops only for penalties, changes of possession, called timeouts or scores. The only difference in this game and a normal mercy-rule game is they shortened the second half by eight minutes.
In the teams’ 71-0 game at Pine-Richland last year, they agreed to the same second-half terms at the intermission. But once the letter was released to the public this week, Fox Chapel came under immediate criticism.
“I told them I’m proud of them and what happened isn’t a reflection of them. It’s a reflection of my leadership and my ultimate goal to keep them safe and finish their season,” Fox Chapel coach Dave Leasure said. “I thanked coach LeDonne. Originally we had some things planned and our seniors wanted to do more, and they did — and, boy, did they fight. I’m most of all happy that we came out of this happy that we’re able to do things we haven’t been able to do around here in a long time.”
Pine-Richland and Fox Chapel agreeing to an abbreviated game came on the heels of Baldwin athletic director Tony Cherico sending a letter out Wednesday to the athletic directors of his team’s final five opponents asking them to “sprinkle in JV kids early and often,” as the team has only 30 active players — including just five seniors — on its roster.
He also asked that the game begin with a running clock — ostensibly starting off with the mercy rule in effect — and all but guaranteeing their opponents they would win the games.
“It was surprising, a little overwhelming and crazy. The community right now is split,” Baldwin football booster club president Jamie Jackson said. “There are parents who have caused a lot of issues in the community, spreading a lot of stories around without getting the truth behind it.”
Baldwin (0-6, 0-1) lost its Allegheny Six Conference opener at home Friday against South Fayette 49-13. The Highlanders own a 25-game losing streak that is currently the longest in the WPIAL and played the first half normally instead of opening with a running clock.
“Our boys are strong, dedicated, and those who are on the field don’t want to give up. They never asked for the mercy rule. They just want to come out and play football the way it’s supposed to be played,” Jackson said. “I believe that the majority of the parents just want the boys to go out and play fair without injuries.”
Though the decision for Fox Chapel and Pine-Richland wasn’t expressly known until Thursday and more widely discovered until Friday morning, players from both sides knew what was happening.
“I was one of three kids on the team who knew of it beforehand. I didn’t know the rest of our team did not know, ... but the coaches and the AD [Michael O’Brien] just did what was in our best interest and were looking out for us,” Fox Chapel senior quarterback Joey Geller said. “We were just trying to cut out all the noise and not listen to what everyone was saying on Twitter [X] and keep it light and keep people out of our business.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.