The Post-Gazette’s Legacy Series periodically looks back at notable teams, coaches and athletes in WPIAL/City League history.
When the WPIAL Class 6A football championship is contested Saturday, North Allegheny will attempt to win a third consecutive title. History says it would be a rare feat among the big boys.
Since the WPIAL crowned its first champion 110 years ago, a “three-peat” in the largest classification has happened only three times.
Winning a WPIAL title in the largest classification these days is nowhere near as difficult as it was years and years ago, simply because Class 6A now has only seven teams. When the WPIAL’s largest class had its second three-peat in 1978, the classification had 56 teams.
But a three-peat is still an achievement. The first team to win three in a row in the largest class did it more than 100 years ago. The second to do it had a dynasty in the late 1970s and actually won four titles in a row, although one was a co-championship because of a tied game. The team had one of the greatest players in Western Pennsylvania history and many other major-college players, although one of their titles was later vacated.
The third team to three-peat was, coincidentally, North Allegheny.
Read More
Here’s a trip down memory lane, chronicling those three teams:
Penn Hills (1976-79)
Considering Penn Hills played in the largest classification, the Indians’ four-year run is considered one of the greatest in WPIAL football history.
Penn Hills, under coach Andy Urbanic, was 49-2-1 from 1976-78, had 26 shutouts and allowed an average of only 4.8 points in those 52 games. The team that wore helmets with big stars on the side had plenty of star players. The biggest — figuratively and literally — was Bill Fralic, a starting lineman on the ’77, ’78 and ’79 teams. Fralic was a big and menacing two-way standout who started as a freshman in 1977, which was virtually unheard of back then. Fralic went on to be an All-American at Pitt, the No. 2 overall pick in the 1985 draft and an NFL All-Pro. He is a member of the College Football Hall of Fame.

Also, a starting quarterback-defensive back on the Penn Hills 1978-79 teams was Tommy Flynn, who also went on to play at Pitt and won a Super Bowl as a defensive back with the New York Giants.
Those Penn Hills teams also had a number of other Division I college players. Joel Coles, who rushed for 151 yards in the 1977 WPIAL title game, went on to play running back at Penn State. Dan Biondi, who scored the only touchdown in the 1978 WPIAL final, played defensive back at Penn State. Tom Johnson and Bob Lawson from the 1979 team also played at Pitt and Leon Rhodes at Virginia Tech.
The man who was coach of all those championship teams was Urbanic, who left after the 1980 season to become an assistant at Pitt.
But Penn Hills’ run from 1976-79 included one of the most unusual championship games ever (it was played over two nights) and a court case that almost kept the 1979 team out of the playoffs.
Penn Hills’ first title came in 1976 when the Indians defeated Butler 23-14 at Pitt Stadium. Penn Hills trailed in the fourth quarter until a short pass from Jim McCallister to Joe DeRiggi turned into a 75-yard touchdown. McCallister scored the final touchdown when he picked off a Butler lateral and returned it 45 yards for a touchdown.
The 1977 championship might be the strangest in WPIAL history. The game was started on a Friday night, and Butler had a 7-0 lead on the defending champs when the lights went out at Mt. Lebanon Stadium because of a power failure. The two teams had to come back the next night to finish the game, and Coles’ touchdown in the fourth quarter, followed by the extra point, tied the game 7-7. The game ended deadlocked because there was no overtime back then.
After the game, Urbanic told the Pittsburgh Press, “We had the momentum, and if the game had gone into an overtime period to decide just one champion, I’m sure we’d have won it. But that would have been unfair to Butler since quite obviously they were the better team the night we started play.”

In 1978, Penn Hills won the title by defeating Blackhawk 7-0 at Pitt Stadium. Penn Hills started the winning drive at its own 36 with 3:12 left. Flynn had five runs and two pass completions on the drive, and Biondi capped it with a 2-yard touchdown run with just 41 seconds remaining.
While the 1977 championship game was strange, the 1979 playoffs were strange for Penn Hills. Penn Hills had used an ineligible player in reserve duty in a few games during the regular season. The school turned itself in to the WPIAL, and the league voted to remove Penn Hills from the playoffs.
The playoffs were delayed a week while Penn Hills won a preliminary injunction from a court judge to participate in the postseason. Penn Hills won a semifinal game 10-7 against a North Hills team that had allowed only nine points all season.
The only Penn Hills loss in 1979 came in the season opener against nationally known Cincinnati Moeller, which was coached by Gerry Faust, who became the head coach at Notre Dame two seasons later. (Faust died Monday.) In the WPIAL championship game in 1979, Penn Hills played Gateway on a cold Friday night at Mt. Lebanon Stadium. The game was scoreless until the fourth quarter when Penn Hills’ Mike Holodonik, who missed two earlier field goal tries, kicked a 28-yarder with 3:31 left to give the Indians a 3-0 victory.

A year-and-a-half later, the WPIAL won a court case appeal and vacated the title. But the court couldn’t take away what Penn Hills already proved on the field. And the legacy created by those Penn Hills teams in the late 1970s will last a long time.
North Allegheny (2010-12)
North Allegheny won three WPIAL championships in three years and had a 45-2 record in that time. The Tigers also won two state championships.
North Allegheny had seven-point victories in all three WPIAL title games, beating Woodland Hills 21-14 in 2010, Upper St. Clair 28-21 in overtime in 2011 and Woodland Hills 21-14 in 2012.
Art Walker was the coach then and is still now, seeking his eighth WPIAL title Saturday. (He also won two at Central Catholic.) Walker was blessed with some outstanding individual talent at North Allegheny. In 2010, Rob Kugler and his younger brother, Pat, transferred to North Allegheny after their father, Sean, became the Steelers offensive line coach. Kugler, who was a senior in 2010, went on to play at Purdue, while Pat, a sophomore in 2010, played at Michigan.

Elijah Zeise, a junior on the 2012 team, went on to play at Pitt. Alex Papson, a senior on the 2010 team, set a school record with 4,533 career rushing yards.
Mack Leftwich was a terrific quarterback on the 2011-12 teams. He came to North Allegheny in 2011 when his father, Spencer, became Pitt’s offensive line coach.

The 2012 North Allegheny team has to be considered among the best in the WPIAL in the past few decades. The Tigers finished 15-0 and scored 56, 45 and 63 points in three state playoff games. The 63 points against Coatesville set a record for a PIAA title game, and Leftwich finished with 3,331 passing yards, still ninth best in a WPIAL season.
"After a statement win like this in a state championship game, I think our team has to be considered one of the best of all time," Leftwich said after beating Coatesville.
Wilkinsburg (1914-16)
Wilkinsburg was the WPIAL’s first champion 110 years ago, back when the league was small and had only one classification. There wasn’t even a championship game in 1914. Wilkinsburg was simply named the champion by a group named the Syracuse Alumni Association, and Wilkinsburg was given the Syracuse Cup, a symbol of the WPIAL title.

The next two seasons had championship games, and Wilkinsburg won them both. It is interesting to read newspaper stories about Wilkinsburg’s team and the championship games. The week of the championship games, stories told of how Wilkinsburg was working hard at practice with the “forward pass,” which didn’t happen often back then.
Back then, newspaper stories about games only included last names of players and not first names.
In the first WPIAL championship game in 1915, Wilkinsburg defeated Fifth Avenue 12-7 at Forbes Field. A Wilkinsburg player named Hileman scored both touchdowns. Now, 109 years later, neither school is even open. Wilkinsburg closed in 2016. Fifth Avenue eventually joined the City League and closed in 1976. The school is now an apartment building.
Wilkinsburg was referred to as the Holy City back then, and the Wilkinsburg football team went after the WPIAL’s Holy Grail one more time in 1916. Playing at Forbes Field once again, Wilkinsburg defeated Butler 27-0. The game was scoreless at halftime, but Hileman scored three touchdowns in the second half.
The WPIAL had its first three-time champion.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.