One of the area’s most downtrodden football programs is looking for a new home, but the WPIAL isn’t going to allow it.

Butler filed a formal request to the WPIAL board of directors to be removed from the WPIAL in football only and move to participate in Erie’s District 10 instead. But the WPIAL board felt it would be setting a bad precedent to let a school leave for another district in one sport only.

“The board denied the request of Butler to withdraw in football only,” WPIAL executive director Tim O’Malley said. “What the board will allow them to do is simply not take a schedule from us.”

O’Malley’s suggestion is for the Golden Tornado to create their own, independent schedule rather than playing the schedule the WPIAL creates for them as a part of the Class 6A Quad County Conference. Albert Gallatin started the trend last year after going through a similar rough patch in Class 5A, and it turned out to be just the type of confidence boost the Colonials needed as they finished 2019 with a 5-3 record after enduring 35 consecutive losing seasons.

Advertise with us

“Another option, if they like, would be to go to District 10 in all sports, but the board was of the opinion, based on advice from our counsel — the constitution doesn’t allow us to let them leave in one sport and stick around in other sports,” O’Malley said.

Butler leaving the WPIAL for District 10 in all sports seems like a highly unlikely scenario, but the Golden Tornado refusing to accept the WPIAL’s schedule and going independent seems much more realistic. Butler has struggled through back-to-back winless seasons in the unforgiving gauntlet that is Class 6A, and things don’t appear to be turning around anytime soon with enrollment numbers continuing to dwindle.

“I kind of figured [the WPIAL’s decision] might be a possibility, but we’re obviously just looking to try to find some positive growth for our football program,” Butler athletic director Bill Mylan said. “It’s probably the one program we’ve struggled with consistently over the last 20 years, so [we’re] just attempting to find a more competitive situation for us, schedule-wise.”

Despite having the third-largest student population among the WPIAL’s more than 130 member schools with 728 boys in grades 9-11, Butler’s roster sheet dipped from 61 players in 2018 to just 43 players in 2019. The Golden Tornado has made the WPIAL playoffs only one time since the turn of the century and hasn’t had a winning season since 1997.

O’Malley said Butler has until Jan. 3 to inform the WPIAL whether it wants a football schedule or whether it plans on going independent.

“I wouldn’t say it’s a done deal,” Mylan said about leaving the WPIAL in football to explore other options. “I would say we’re still open to the different possibilities, weighing our options and figuring out what’s best for our program moving forward.”