The WPIAL football committee meets Monday to make playoff pairings and seedings. Some of the hardest questions the group will have to answer are:
• Who should be seeded No. 1 in Class 2A?
• Where should defending WPIAL and PIAA Class 5A champ Penn Hills be seeded?
• Who should Jeannette play in a Class 1A quarterfinal?
Let me save the committee some time and effort. I have the answers. Below are predicted playoff pairings and seedings for all six classifications.
By the way, the playoffs start Friday. The Class 6A, 4A, 3A and 1A championships will be Nov. 16 at Heinz Field. The Class 5A and 2A finals are Nov. 23 at Norwin.
Read More
Let’s play bracketology.
WPIAL CLASS 6A
Pairings: Canon-McMillan (6) at North Allegheny (3); Seneca Valley (5) at Mt. Lebanon (4).
Central Catholic (1) and Pine-Richland (2) get byes to the semifinals. Central Catholic will play the Mt. Lebanon-Seneca Valley winner, and Pine-Richland will play the North Allegheny-Canon-McMillan winner.
Just sayin’: There is nothing to really say about Class 6A because this is the only classification where first-round matchups are pre-determined. What’s a little odd is that Pine-Richland and Central Catholic could play the same opponent two games in a row. Pine-Richland beat North Allegheny Friday and will likely play North Allegheny again in the semifinals. Central Catholic beat Mt. Lebanon Friday. If Mt. Lebanon can beat Seneca Valley, which is not a given, Central Catholic will meet Mt. Lebanon again in the semifinals.
WPIAL CLASS 5A
Pairings: Fox Chapel (16) at Penn-Trafford (1); Shaler (15) at Gateway (2); Latrobe (14) at Moon (3); Baldwin (13) at Penn Hills (4); Mars (12) at Peters Township (5); Kiski Area (11) at McKeesport (6); Franklin Regional (10) at Bethel Park (7); Upper St. Clair (9) at North Hills (8).
Just sayin’: This classification doesn’t have an undefeated team, but Penn-Trafford’s only loss is to a strong Massillon, Ohio, team. So, Penn-Trafford is undefeated against the WPIAL. Gateway is a second-place team in its conference, but I still believe Gateway deserves the No. 2 overall seed because it has the second-best team right now. Penn Hills is a defending WPIAL and PIAA champ, but this team certainly isn’t as strong as the 2018 squad. Don’t make this year’s seedings based on last year’s results. No. 3 Moon and No. 4 Penn Hills could be switched. But I put Moon at No. 3 to keep the Tigers away from a probable quarterfinal matchup against a team (Peters Township) from their own conference.
I really believe Latrobe should be the No. 15 seed or even 16. But that would put Latrobe in a first-round game against a team from its own conference. That should be avoided when possible.
WPIAL CLASS 4A
Pairings: New Castle (8) at Thomas Jefferson (1); West Mifflin (7) at South Fayette (2); Montour (6) at Belle Vernon (3); Greensburg Salem (5) at Blackhawk (4).
Just sayin’: With eight-team brackets, sometimes you must have first-round games between teams from the same conference. That being said, my first inclination was to put West Mifflin at No. 8 against No. 1 Thomas Jefferson, even though the teams just played Friday. But West Mifflin owns a victory against New Castle on New Castle’s home field. That should mean something. So, New Castle goes to the No. 8 seed. Yes, New Castle defeated Montour this season, but Montour is playing well, winning four of the past five. The only loss was a 31-24 setback to No. 2 South Fayette on Friday. New Castle, on the other hand, is 3-3 in the past six games, including a loss to a 3-7 Highlands team.
The bottom line is you could do this bracket a number of different ways — and people could still poke holes in it.
WPIAL CLASS 3A
Pairings: Mount Pleasant (8) at Central Valley (1); Elizabeth Forward (7) at Aliquippa (2); (6) South Park at (3) North Catholic; Beaver Falls (5) at Derry (4).
Just sayin’: Central Valley owns wins against Aliquippa and North Catholic and is the easy No. 1 seed. The question is whether Aliquippa or North Catholic should get the No. 2 seed. But it really is meaningless. Seeds 2 and 3 are on the same side of the bracket. And if you want to match North Catholic and Aliquippa against a team from the other conference, the opponents stay the same no matter who is No. 2.
WPIAL CLASS 2A
Pairings: Shady Side Academy (16) at Washington (1); Serra (15) at Avonworth (2); Southmoreland (14) at Burgettstown (3); South Side Beaver (13) at Neshannock (4); East Allegheny (12) at McGuffey (5); Riverside (11) at Apollo-Ridge (6); New Brighton (10) at Brentwood (7); Charleroi (9) at Freedom (8).
Just sayin’: This classification has three undefeated teams (Washington, Avonworth and Burgettstown). Who should get No. 1? Avonworth has an impressive resume with wins over five teams seeded in the top 12 (Neshannock, New Brighton, Apollo-Ridge, East Allegheny and McGuffey). But Washington still gets the nod as the top seed because you pick what team you think is best. That doesn’t mean Avonworth can’t win the title, but I’ll go with Washington as the best team right now. I originally had Freedom as a No. 6 seed, but the Bulldogs have lost three in a row, including one to Western Beaver Saturday. I think Southmoreland should be the No. 15 seed, but that would mean Serra would be No. 14 and play conference foe Burgettstown in the first round.
WPIAL CLASS 1A
Pairings: Our Lady of the Sacred Heart (8) at Clairton (1); California (6) at Sto-Rox (3); Greensburg Central Catholic (5) at Cornell (4); Jeannette (7) at West Greene (2).
Just sayin’: These aren’t really true seeds for this classification. These are creative seedings. For example, Jeannette should be the No. 2 seed and there is no way West Greene is the No. 2 seed. But the WPIAL has the Class 1A playoffs set up in such a way that Jeannette has to play a road game and has to be seeded no higher than No. 5. And West Greene is a conference champ and gets a home game. So, West Greene can’t be seeded lower than No. 4. If you seeded Jeannette at No. 5 and West Greene at No. 4, that would set up a possible semifinal game between Jeannette and Clairton. That shouldn’t happen. Those two teams should be on the opposite side of the bracket.
I honestly believe the WPIAL’s setup for the Class 1A playoffs isn’t fair. In every other classification, at least the top four teams in every conference qualify for the postseason. But in Class 1A, only the top three teams from two of the conferences qualify. In one conference (Tri-County South), only the top two teams qualified this season.
I know the WPIAL said two years ago that the league didn’t feel there were enough quality Class 1A teams worthy to make a 16-team bracket. That might be true. But what’s a major factor in the WPIAL’s playoff system is the league also wants to have four title games at Heinz Field. If the Class 1A field had 16 playoff teams, that would mean an extra week of playoffs. Then only three title games would be played at Heinz Field instead of four.
What would’ve been right is for the WPIAL to take four teams from each of the Class 1A conferences to the playoffs — and give four teams a bye to the quarterfinals. Yes, this would mean only three title games at Heinz Field. But so what? The Class 1A title game usually doesn’t draw more than 500 fans to Heinz anyway.
Look at Laurel’s situation. The Spartans finished 7-3, beat a conference champ (Sto-Rox) and shut out another playoff team (California). Laurel tied for third place in its conference, but didn’t make the playoffs. Yet, the WPIAL playoff field in other classifications has a 3-7 team, a 4-5 team, two 4-6 teams and nine 5-5 teams. That’s not right. Things might change next year, but that doesn’t help Laurel in 2019.
As for this season, a big question in Class 1A is who does Jeannette play? I put Jeannette against West Greene because West Greene is the worst of the four teams playing a home game.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.