Varsity Xtra 2019: New coaches take center stage

Should there be separate playoffs for public high schools and Catholic/private schools?

What about the PIAA and WPIAL rules for student-athlete transfers? Are they appropriate?

Adults are the ones who answer these questions. Everyone from school administrators to WPIAL and PIAA officials rule on these matters.

But what do the kids think? Well, the Post-Gazette decided to find out.

Advertise with us

During football preseason camp, a few members of the P-G high school sports staff informally polled 21 WPIAL players and asked them all the same six questions. They were asked about the playoffs, transfers, best player of all time and more. Players came from big schools and small schools and a few Catholic school players also participated. Players were given anonymity because the thought was they would be more truthful.

It is certainly not a scientific poll, but some of the answers were eye-opening. Here are the six questions and some of the responses.

1. Best stadium to watch a game in the WPIAL?

Players did not have to play in the stadium, but they also could not pick their own. They could have simply been at the stadium. The answers were wide ranging.

But of the 21 players surveyed, five picked Pine-Richland as the best stadium. Pine-Richland’s press box is huge, probably the biggest in the WPIAL, maybe even as big as, say, Heinz Field.

Advertise with us

“I like looking up and seeing all that glass in the press box,” said one player.

Varsity Xtra 2019: New coaches take center stage

North Hills’ Martorelli Stadium got three votes. It sits down in a valley, the stands are close to the field and it can be a great atmosphere. North Allegheny’s Newman Stadium also got three votes.

“They have JuJu Smith-Schuster at their games sometimes,” one player said.

One player actually picked the stadium of Bishop Gorman.

2. Any rule you’d like changed in high school football?

Advertise with us

A few players answered they would like to be able to use “crackback” blocks again. But the rule most often mentioned is hurdling a defender. It received six votes.

An offensive player who hurdles a defender can actually be assessed a penalty. Rules makers say the rule is for safety reasons.

“It’s stupid,” said one player.

The actually wording of the rule says “hurdling over an opponent who is contacting the ground with no part of his body except one or both feet is illegal.”

But if a player is kneeling on the ground, hurdling is OK.

Advertise with us

3. Best player in the history of the WPIAL or City League?

Some responses to this were eye-opening, to say the least. We knew many players would answer with players from the modern era. Still, it was impressed on the players to consider players from long ago and that the WPIAL has a number of players in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

But many of the answers illustrate how many high school players really don’t know much WPIAL history or don’t start following high school football until maybe junior high or high school.

“You should’ve said Dan Marino,” Player A said to Player B at one school.

Player B responded: “Why? Where’s Dan Marino from.”

Advertise with us

“Central Catholic,” Player A said.

“Wow, I never knew Dan Marino went to Central,” Player B said.

Penn Hills graduate Aaron Donald got five votes. Yes, he is a modern player, but certainly a good pick. He was the NFL defensive player of the year last year and some say he is headed to the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

But Marino, a Hall of Famer, also got five votes and Aliquippa’s Darrelle Revis three.

Two players from the same school picked Clairton’s Lamont Wade, who is a junior at Penn State. When told a number of WPIAL players are in the Hall of Fame, one player said, “Yeah, I know. But Lamont Wade was good.”

Advertise with us

A few other answers were: Thomas Jefferson’s Chase Winovich, South Fayette’s Brett Brumbaugh and ... Penn Hills’ Dan Mason.

4. Should there be rules for transfers of student-athletes, or should everyone be eligible if they move into a district, no questions asked?

Seven players said there should be some kind of rules for those who transfer for athletic reasons. One said there should be only rules for those who transfer to Catholic schools. Nine said there should be no rules, as long as a student-athlete physically moves into a district. Four said they were undecided on the issue.

“What does it matter. Even when the WPIAL makes someone ineligible, the PIAA overturns it anyway,” said one player.

Another player said, “I see why the WPIAL has rules, but I feel like the WPIAL messes it up sometimes.”

Advertise with us

5. Should there be separate playoffs for public and Catholic/private schools?

Seven players said there should be separate playoffs.

“Look at the Catholic schools. They get players from everywhere. That’s not right,” said one player.

Another player said, “I say don’t separate them because it feels so good when you beat the Catholic schools.”

One other player said, “They all should play together. It makes it more intense.”

Advertise with us

6. Is there too much time demanded of high school football players in the offseason?

Between weightlifting and team workouts and 7-on-7 tournaments, players can spend lots of time on football in the offseason. But not one of the 21 players thought there is too much time asked of them in the offseason.

“There should be more,” said one player.

Another said, “Some kids quit because it ruins their summer, but summer is football.”

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh