Playoff parity between boundary and non-boundary schools continues to be a heated issue in Pennsylvania, with the state Athletic Oversight Committee holding a public hearing to discuss possible solutions Wednesday at Heinz Field.
The committee, led by chairman Rep. Gene DiGirolamo, R-Bucks, spoke with three panels — one comprising PIAA representatives, including executive director Bob Lombardi, one of superintendents in favor of creating separate classifications for non-boundary schools and one of Mike Bariski, athletic director of Lincoln Park, a charter school in Midland.
The hearing comes about six weeks after more than 200 superintendents, high school principals and athletic directors met in University Park to discuss how separate playoff systems could be implemented.
“To this point, I’ve never been in favor of separating the championships,” DiGirolamo said after the hearing. “The superintendents, I think they made some good points. The point where they had a championship game where one team beats the other team in a championship 70 something to 30 something, if that’s happened, if that’s happening with regularity, there’s something wrong with that.”
That’s referencing Imhotep Charter’s 71-35 win against Sharon in the boys basketball PIAA Class 4A championship last season.
I'm here at the Pa. Athletic Oversight Committee meeting where panels are discussing the boundary vs. non-boundary issue in HS sports.
— Sarah K. Spencer (@sarah_k_spence) September 5, 2018
Here's a letter from the Pennsylvania Catholic Conference's director of education that was handed out at the meeting: pic.twitter.com/Dfb44hhOsj
In July, two scenarios were proposed as replacements to the current system:
Read More
• Create a seventh PIAA classification for non-boundary schools and schools of choice. Those schools would compete against one another in the postseason.
• Revert to four classifications for boundary schools and use classifications of 5A and 6A for non-boundary schools.
The PIAA has said it will not separate boundary and non-boundary schools in the playoffs unless legislation is changed, citing House Bill 2104, which was passed in 1972 and states “private schools shall be permitted, if otherwise qualified, to be members of the Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association.”
But the PIAA equity steering committee, composed of superintendents and school officials who want to separate non-boundary and boundary high school teams in the postseason with the hopes of greater playoff parity, interprets that bill differently, arguing it’s not an issue that should be fixed with further legislation, and that the current law doesn’t actually mandate keeping the teams together in the playoffs.
“We believe the PIAA has governance,” Laurel superintendent Leonard Rich said. “They divide people into Class 1A through 6A, they put people into different sections. They certainly could separate boundary vs. non-boundary.”
What comes next, essentially, is figuring out who’s right.
The athletic oversight committee can offer suggestions but can’t force the PIAA to change anything, DiGirolamo said, unless a bill to separate the championships is introduced and passed.
The next step is to see if there’s a transcript of the debate from when the bill became law, and see what legislative intent can be determined.
“I’d like to ask them to go back and do some research,” DiGirolamo said. “It might take a while, to see if there’s any transcripts from the debate. If there are, maybe that will clarify it. If there aren’t, then I think the legal departments, in conjunction with the Legislative Reference Bureau, who make up the bills, maybe they could get together and try to come up with something where they say, here’s what was intended, and here’s what the law says and here’s what it doesn’t say.”
Millcreek superintendent Bill Hall, a member of the equity steering committee, said the committee isn’t opposed to working with the PIAA to discuss solutions, and that the committee’s intent isn’t to be adversarial.
“We just need to keep the conversation going,” Hall said. “We as the traditional 500 school districts need to stay united so that this doesn’t die off. That’s the big challenge for us is just keeping the communication going and the momentum going.”
Sarah K. Spencer: sspencer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @sarah_k_spence.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.