A 28-year-old former high school football coach who posed as a teenage girl and exchanged sexual messages with teenage boys on Snapchat was sentenced Thursday to house arrest.

Patrick I. Onesko, of East Millsboro, Fayette County, wept at various times through the roughly hour-long sentencing in front of Allegheny County Common Pleas Court Judge Alexander P. Bicket.

Judge Bicket sentenced Onesko, who previously coached football at both South Fayette High School and California University of Pennsylvania, to one year less one day to two years less two days in jail and released him immediately to house arrest. He also sentenced Onesko to five years probation, and the former coach will have to register for life as a sex offender.

Judge Bicket said he took into account that Onesko expressed remorse for his actions, had already spent three months in the Allegheny County Jail and has a strong support system of friends and family. He said he does not think Onesko poses a serious risk to society.

Advertise with us

“I am concerned that the messages took place over a period of time,” Judge Bicket said, “but I do believe...rehabilitation is possible and probable.”

The messages were sent over about a month-long period.

South Fayette police obtained an arrest warrant for Onesko in March 2017 after the father of one of the victims came forward. Prosecutors said Onesko told the 14- and 15-year-old victims on the Snapchat messaging app that he was a 15-year-old girl from Bethel Park. He used the screen name ALAINABP5

Prosecutors believe Onesko was “grooming” the teens and said he began talking to them about their genitals and offered oral sex to one.

A jury convicted Onesko Dec. 7 of solicitation, unlawful contact with a minor and two counts of corruption of minors.

Advertise with us

Several of Onesko’s friends and family attended the sentencing hearing and cried at various times throughout. Onesko’s mother, Kim Onesko, tearfully addressed the court and asked Judge Bicket for mercy.

“I want to believe in our justice system, that a person’s life is not destroyed because they make one mistake,” she said.

Onesko also addressed the court in tears and told Judge Bicket that he’d “lost his way.”

“It will be a lifelong battle for me to seek forgiveness,” Onesko said.

Deputy Assistant District Attorney Janet Necessary read a letter from the families of the two boys that Onesko contacted in which the families asked that Judge Bicket give Onesko the maximum possible sentence.

Advertise with us

“Clearly Mr. Onesko is a sick individual who needs a severe punishment to hopefully deter him from doing something similar again,” the letter read.

Ms. Necessary also asked Judge Bicket to consider the many letters of support Onesko’s family and friends wrote on his behalf with a grain of salt.

“A person can appear to be an upstanding citizen and a good guy in public and yet engage in the activities like the defendant did entirely in secret,” she said, and asked the judge to consider “the insidious nature of this secret life the defendant was apparently living while he was a coach and mentor to young people.”

Per state guidelines, the lowest recommended range for Onesko’s crimes would be two to three years in prison. Onesko’s attorney, Stephen Misko, asked Judge Bicket to sentence Onesko below those guidelines to ensure “the time matched the crime.”

He emphasized that Onesko never actually met with the two boys he messaged. Judge Bicket later agreed with Mr. Misko that the state guidelines were “tough.”

Advertise with us

Onesko’s family gasped and cried when the sentence of house arrest was pronounced. Family members of the two boys declined to comment.

Shelly Bradbury: 412-263-1999, sbradbury@post-gazette.com or follow @ShellyBradbury on Twitter.